- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
BiAAR reconstructs 3D vessels from two calibrated binary projections. It uses an amount–allocation formulation, supervises view-normalized amount maps and a 3D occupancy prior, and combines them with projection evidence through learned fusion and refinement. Experiments use simulated ImageCAS and AVDNet-derived ASOCA projections. The paper reports the highest mean Dice and soft clDice among the compared methods.
Critical strengths
- The ImageCAS gain over AutoCAR is substantial. Dice improves from 0.712 to 0.809 and cIDice from 0.783 to 0.879. HD95 and ASSD also improve.
- The fixed-capacity ablation is useful. Adding both auxiliary losses improves Dice from 0.774 to 0.809 without changing the architecture. The oracle amount result of 0.926 Dice also shows the amount branch matters.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not fully convinced of where the gain comes from. Shen et al. (CVPR 2019) already explored thickness/prior cues. Here, the allocation prior is a full 3D occupancy prediction. The ablation shows intermediate supervision helps. It does not separate the proposed fusion from a standard coarse-to-fine model. A capacity-matched baseline is needed.
- The ASOCA gains are small. Dice improves by 0.023 and cIDice by 0.017 over Two Projections Suffice. HD95 and ASSD are worse than all three non-Gaussian baselines. There are only four test patients. The reported std reflects test-pair variability, not repeated training runs. It is also unclear whether infinite distances from empty predictions were excluded.
Questions for authors
- Could you provide a capacity-matched coarse-to-fine baseline with the same amount and occupancy supervision, but with standard feature fusion and residual refinement? This would help separate the benefit of the proposed fusion from that of intermediate supervision.
- For ASOCA, please report per-patient Dice, soft clDice, HD95, and ASSD. Are the gains consistent across patients, and which cases account for the worse boundary distances? How many samples, if any, were omitted from the distance averages because of empty predictions?
5 comments
Reply to Reviewer anyZ (2/3)
Reply to W2 and Q2: ASOCA patient-level results, boundary errors, and exclusions
Concern: Are ASOCA gains consistent, which patients account for worse boundaries, and were empty predictions omitted?
ASOCA Dice improves in all four patients against every baseline; its overlap gains coexist with a boundary-accuracy disadvantage, and no predictions were excluded. The original benchmark evaluation means are:
| Method | Dice ↑ | soft-clDice ↑ | HD95 ↓ | ASSD ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BiAAR | 0.6361 | 0.5865 | 8.3794 | 1.7028 |
| Two Projections Suffice | 0.6130 | 0.5687 | 7.2923 | 1.5092 |
| AutoCAR | 0.5701 | 0.4857 | 5.9240 | 1.3898 |
| DeepCA | 0.5673 | 0.4397 | 5.7566 | 1.3434 |
| 3DGR-CAR | 0.2303 | 0.2071 | 10.5527 | 3.2407 |
Patient-level results. Each patient contributes separate artery and vein volumes, with 20 pairs per volume. We average within each volume, then equally across the two volumes. Each row summarizes 40 pairs, while the independent sample size is four patients. Distances are voxels on the grid. Below is the comparison with the strongest overlap baseline; bold marks the better value within each patient:
| Patient | Method | Dice ↑ | soft-clDice ↑ | HD95 ↓ | ASSD ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | BiAAR | 0.6333 | 0.5671 | 6.8238 | 1.5208 |
| 3 | Two Projections Suffice | 0.6182 | 0.5664 | 5.8932 | 1.2867 |
| 9 | BiAAR | 0.6446 | 0.6011 | 9.8593 | 1.6481 |
| 9 | Two Projections Suffice | 0.6282 | 0.5773 | 8.9703 | 1.6060 |
| 10 | BiAAR | 0.6805 | 0.6350 | 5.7519 | 1.2297 |
| 10 | Two Projections Suffice | 0.6314 | 0.5795 | 7.9914 | 1.6371 |
| 36 | BiAAR | 0.5860 | 0.5427 | 11.0828 | 2.4128 |
| 36 | Two Projections Suffice | 0.5741 | 0.5514 | 6.3143 | 1.5070 |
BiAAR improves Dice in four patients and soft-clDice in three relative to Two Projections Suffice; both boundary metrics improve for patient 10. Patient 36 contributes most to the boundary disadvantage, with HD95/ASSD differences of +4.7685/+0.9058 voxels. Patient 9 has high absolute HD95 and a smaller gap to this baseline; patient 10 offsets part of the aggregate difference. The complete five-method patient table is in Appendix D.3, Table 6.
Directional distances identify incomplete branch coverage. For patient 36, the mean reference-to-prediction distance is 3.4024 voxels, compared with 0.7366 in the reverse direction; 21.88% of reference surface lies more than five voxels from the prediction. The complete directional diagnostics are in Table 7.
All 160 ASOCA predictions per method are included. There are zero missing records, empty predictions, empty references, or distance exclusions across all five methods. HD95 and ASSD denominators are 160 per method and 40 per patient; Table 8 provides the audit.
The original standard deviations describe test-pair variability for the selected checkpoint. Patient-level aggregation accounts for repeated projections, and the four Dice comparisons attain the minimum possible two-sided exact p-value, 2/16 = 0.125. Appendix D.2 reports the statistical protocol and finite-sample resolution.
ASOCA tests reconstruction with 32 training patients / 64 reference volumes, compared with 800 ImageCAS training cases, and detailed arterial and venous structures. Its AVDNet-derived masks and reconstruction targets come from the same volumes, maintaining input–target consistency for this synthetic task. The revised Section 4.6 identifies the reference provenance, patient count, and overlap–boundary tradeoff.
We hope the controlled fusion results and patient-level analysis address your questions about attribution and reliability. Thank you again for helping us strengthen the evidence and its presentation.
Reply to Reviewer anyZ (3/3)
References
- Shen W, Jia Y, Wu Y. 3D shape reconstruction from images in the frequency domain[C]//2019 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2019: 4466-4474.
- Wang W, Xia Q, Yan Z, et al. AVDNet: Joint coronary artery and vein segmentation with topological consistency[J]. Medical Image Analysis, 2024, 91: 102999.
- Cafaro A, Dorent R, Haouchine N, et al. Two projections suffice for cerebral vascular reconstruction[C]//International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024: 722-731.
- Zhu Y, Wang Y, Di C, et al. Sparse and transferable three-dimensional dynamic vascular reconstruction for instantaneous diagnosis[J]. Nature Machine Intelligence, 2025, 7(5): 730-742.
- Wang Y, Banerjee A, Choudhury R P, et al. DeepCA: Deep learning-based 3D coronary artery tree reconstruction from two 2D non-simultaneous X-ray angiography projections[C]//2025 IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV). IEEE, 2025: 337-346.
- Fu X, Li Y, Tang F, et al. 3dgr-car: Coronary artery reconstruction from ultra-sparse 2d x-ray views with a 3d gaussians representation[C]//International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024: 14-24.
Reply to Reviewer anyZ (1/3)
Dear Reviewer anyZ,
Thank you for recognizing the ImageCAS improvements and the value of the fixed-capacity and GT-amount ablations. Your comments helped us strengthen the fusion comparison and examine ASOCA at the patient and boundary levels. We address each weakness with its corresponding question below.
Reply to W1 and Q1: Contribution and the standard-fusion control
Concern: Thickness prediction has precedents, and the occupancy prior predicts the full target; does the proposed fusion improve upon a comparably supervised coarse-to-fine model?
The requested nearly parameter-matched CONCAT control shows a 1.15-point Dice advantage for our fusion with the same intermediate supervision and residual refinement. FULL retains the paper checkpoint, and CONCAT uses the same split, seed 42, and training settings. The evaluation covers 100 ImageCAS cases and 500 paired projections.
FULL/CONCAT have 13,883,723/13,876,379 parameters and 651.839/621.036 GFLOPs per paired sample, under the same counting convention. The parameter difference is 0.053%. The FLOPs reflect 34 versus 17 channels in the first refiner convolution. FULL uses [VR,VR⊙G,P,U], whereas CONCAT uses [VR,P]; both retain the refiner backbone, amount and prior losses, and prior-logit residual. Here G=0.1+0.9P and U=P(1−P).
FULL's Dice gain is 1.15 points, with case-paired 95% CI [0.89, 1.41] and improvement in 86/100 cases. With comparable reported amount FG-MSE and slightly lower prior Dice, its larger 1.92-versus-0.68-point refinement gain supports more effective use of the branch information. FULL recovers 21.01% versus 7.88% of prior false negatives and removes 30.45% versus 13.04% of prior false positives. The complete reconstruction and correction results, including harmful edits, are in Tables 13–14. (Changes and additions are marked in blue in the revised manuscript.)
A matched-capacity representation control also favors amount. We replace amount with ray-depth centroid while retaining prior supervision, fusion, residual refinement, and loss settings. Both variants have 13,883,723 parameters and 651.839 GFLOPs per pair.
These are case-level mean ± SD after averaging five pairs per case. FULL improves Dice by 1.150 points (95% CI [0.873, 1.419]; 82/100 cases). The advantage is already present in prior Dice, while Centroid has a slightly larger refinement gain. Together with the original fixed-capacity loss ablation, these controls test supervision, representation choice, and fusion. Complete Centroid results are in Table 15; Section 4.3 summarizes the findings.
The conceptual contribution is the decomposition-guided choice and use of supervised intermediate representations. The ray-wise identity yv=Avrayαvray specifies amount and normalized allocation. BiAAR learns amount maps and a shared occupancy prior, then uses amount-conditioned features and prior-guided spatial weighting for refinement. The prior is supervised by the full occupancy target and retains allocation and amplitude information; the learned decoder consumes these cues directly.
As you noted, Shen et al. (CVPR 2019) provide an important thickness-prediction precedent. They predict thickness and sine/cosine-weighted maps, construct Fourier slices, and reconstruct through an inverse 3D Fourier transform. BiAAR combines calibrated lifting with occupancy-based allocation guidance and learned spatial fusion. We clarify the formulation-to-implementation correspondence in Section 3.1, with the prior-weighting derivation in Appendix C.3.