- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ConQuER adds class conditioning to a pretrained IQP generator by learning per-condition phase offsets on K chosen supports. The offsets add to the backbone phases, so the result is one IQP circuit. Training uses conditional MMD^2. A shared/private split of offsets cuts parameters and lets a new condition be added with q new values.
Critical strengths
- The composition is exact. Zero offsets recover the backbone. Adding a condition leaves existing conditional distributions unchanged.
- Table 1 reports postselection, full fine-tuning and a classical AR model next to the method, with sampling cost per returned sample.
Critical weaknesses
-
Simple baselines beat the method. Postselection on the frozen backbone gives lower MMD^2 on Blobs (0.0042 vs 0.0105) and Shapes20 (0.0073 vs 0.0242). A 290-parameter classical AR model beats the 3,136-parameter controller on Shapes20 (MMD^2 0.0123 vs 0.0242, hit 89.8% vs 64.5%). Zeroing the backbone phases gives a higher mode hit (81.7% vs 79.2%) at modestly worse MMD^2, so the pretrained backbone adds little.
-
The method is per-condition sparse phase fine-tuning, as the paper notes for M G_base. The stated reason to stay in the IQP family is the scalable classical MMD estimator. Yet all experiments are at 16 to 20 qubits with full probability vectors. Blobs uses all 65,535 supports and a Hellinger projection that needs the full state. Nothing is shown at a size where IQP structure matters.
Questions for authors
Clarifications:
- Table 8: the 1,232-parameter shared controller beats the 6,272-parameter independent table that contains it (0.0098 vs 0.0147). Is optimizer variance as large as the reported effects? Please give multi-seed results for Tables 2 and 8.
- Appendix E.1 says the Blobs test split was accessed during development. Which numbers does this affect?
- Can you show one experiment beyond exact simulation?
4 comments
rebuttal for Q2
The note in Appendix E.1 refers to the fixed 10,000-sample Blobs test split (Appendix B.1) used across the Blobs evaluations, which had been evaluated during earlier development iterations (while checkpoint selection within each run used the validation split; MNIST and Shapes20 are unaffected). To eliminate any potential test-reuse bias, we generated a completely new, independent 10,000-sample Blobs test set with a fresh seed and re-evaluated all locked Blobs checkpoints without retraining or reselection.
Every method ranking holds on the independent test set. Most unfiltered configurations move by about 1–2%: main ConQuER MMD² changes from 0.010494 to 0.010598, Table 8 shared vs independent changes from 0.009838/0.014669 to 0.009953/0.014826, and Table 2 extension obtains 0.011187 vs 0.011676 (winning 18/24 pairs vs 19/24). The frozen + postselection reference moves by about 13% (0.00420 → 0.004747) but remains the lowest MMD² among the compared methods. The revision replaces all Blobs distributional numbers with those on the independent test set.
rebuttal W2/Q3
When , our composition is indeed algebraically equivalent to conditional sparse phase adaptation; keeping the composed circuit strictly within the IQP family is what enables polynomial-time stochastic MMD estimation once n exceeds the limit of exact state-vector simulation. To demonstrate this beyond exact simulation, we trained and evaluated ConQuER on MNIST-3/5 at 16, 36, and 64 qubits using 1Q+2Q backbones and purely stochastic IQP MMD estimation (without state vectors, probability enumeration, or Hellinger projection). At 36 and 64 qubits (2^36 and 2^64 states), full state-vector simulation is infeasible; 16 qubits is included as a reference.
Table 2. Non-full-state resolution scaling on MNIST-3/5. MMD² in 10-3; mean ± s.d. across three pipeline seeds.
| Resolution / qubits | K | Frozen MMD² | Factorized params | Factorized MMD² | Direct params | Direct MMD² |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 × 4 / 16 | 136 | 36.808 ± 0.525 | 1,380 | 2.273 ± 0.140 | 272 | 2.059 ± 0.094 |
| 6 × 6 / 36 | 392 | 17.994 ± 0.135 | 3,940 | 1.496 ± 0.123 | 784 | 1.523 ± 0.107 |
| 8 × 8 / 64 | 784 | 15.078 ± 0.063 | 7,860 | 1.436 ± 0.091 | 1,568 | 1.439 ± 0.055 |
At 36 and 64 qubits, ConQuER reduces conditional MMD² by 91.7% and 90.5% on CPU, directly validating the scalability motivation of preserving IQP structure.
rebuttal for W1
(W1) Baselines and Pretrained Phases
Postselection vs. pre-measurement control. Table 3 compares unfiltered ConQuER against frozen-backbone postselection across all three tasks.
Table 3. Conditional quality and raw-sampling cost (N_raw is condition-averaged 1/acceptance probability; Blobs uses the independent test set).
| Task | Frozen + postselection (MMD² / Raw draws) | ConQuER, unfiltered (MMD² / Raw draws) |
|---|---|---|
| MNIST-3/5 | 0.01761 / 2.07 | 0.00227 ± 0.00020 / 1.00 |
| Binary Blobs | 0.004747 / 8.02 | 0.010598 / 1.00 |
| Shapes20 | 0.00729 / 4.01 | 0.02416 / 1.00 |
| If postselection is additionally applied on top of ConQuER, raw draws drop from 8.02 to 1.28 on Blobs (MMD² 0.020672; 0.02079 under the sharing checkpoint triplet) and from 4.01 to 1.56 on Shapes20 (MMD² 0.01546). |
On MNIST-3/5, where classifier boundaries are imperfect, unfiltered ConQuER achieves both an 87% lower MMD² than postselection (0.00227 vs 0.01761) and zero rejection overhead (1.00 vs 2.07 draws). On the synthetic tasks, postselection achieves lower MMD² at the cost of 8.02× and 4.01× raw circuit draws.
Classical AR and backbone structure. While the from-scratch 290-parameter classical AR model beats the submitted ConQuER configuration on Shapes20 (0.01233 vs 0.02416), pairing ConQuER with a 1Q+2Q frozen IQP backbone (changing both the backbone and support dictionary; exploratory) lowers MMD² to 0.003821 on Shapes20 (outperforming AR) and 0.001222 on Blobs, while solving the distinct problem of adapting a frozen quantum generator rather than training a classical model from scratch.
Zero-phase ablation. In Table 6, zeroing the backbone phases raises mode hit (81.70% vs 79.16%) because hit only counts total probability mass inside a mode's Voronoi region, ignoring within-mode distribution shape. On MMD²—which measures full within-mode distributional fit—retaining the pretrained phases reduces error by 25% (0.009882 vs 0.013223 on the independent test set), even though the zero-phase run still benefits from reusing the support dictionary discovered on the pretrained backbone.
rebuttal for Q1
We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback. We provide multi-seed results and optimization diagnostics for Tables 2 and 8, an independent test-set re-evaluation, 64-qubit experiments beyond exact simulation, and baseline trade-off comparisons.
For Q1 No—the reported effects are not artifacts of optimizer variance. Because Blobs uses a full-batch, exact-PMF objective, controller seeds vary initialization rather than sampling noise. Repeating both studies across five initialization seeds on each of the three backbones (Table 1) shows that the Table 8 sharing advantage (0.0049 at seed 0; 0.0044 across five seeds) is 3.0–7.3× the independent s.d. at seed 0 and 2.7–6.5× for the five-seed mean, while the shared controller itself has an initialization s.d. ≤ 2.7 × 10⁻⁵.
Table 1. Multi-seed comparisons on the independent Blobs test set.
Expanding the fitted shared solution into its exact 6,272-parameter representation confirms that the independent model can represent it, but cold-start optimization in the unconstrained 6,272-parameter space plateaus at a higher training MMD² (0.014051 vs 0.010086 for shared), and continuing optimization of all 6,272 parameters from the shared solution does not improve validation fit. Thus, coordinate-wise sharing acts as a structural constraint that improves optimization stability on the fixed 784-support dictionary, rather than implying extra representational capacity.