- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the conditional flow matching framework for quantum circuit generation and prompt-aware quantum transformer to improve conditional generation quality. The paper improves the generation speed and accuracy compared to prior state of the art.
Critical strengths
The paper is the first to apply conditional flow matching for quantum circuit generation, and shows strong performance improvement over other ML-based works.
Critical weaknesses
The evaluation performs only on small circuits. The experimental settings for unitary compilation is not clear. What unitary is tested for performance should be clarified. Although the paper shows good results on entanglement generation, unitary synthesis remains a more important task for quantum circuit synthesis. It is not clear the evaluation settings for other non-ML works. For example, the performance of Qiskit may depend on the random seed and different optimization passes.In addition to Qiskit, BQSKit, MQT, and Synthetic are all advanced quantum circuit synthesis tools that should be included into comparison.
Questions for authors
- Can you provide some background introduction to entanglement generation and explain why it is relevant or important to the quantum circuit generation?
- Why for unitary synthesis, the circuit size is limited to 3 qubits based on Table 7?
- One motivation for using ML-based method for quantum circuit synthesis is the classical method does not scale to large circuits. How do we argue that the ML-based method can have better scalability?
- How to justify the use of SRV for accuracy? SRV only characterize the entanglement level of a circuit but two circuits with the same entanglement level can have complete different functionality.
- How do we ensure the generated circuits are feasible? If the generated circuit is not correct, do we have post processing procedure to revise the circuit? For the large circuit, how does one verify the circuit correctness?
9 comments
Response to Reviewer ef2X (2/6)
Q1: Can you provide some background introduction to entanglement generation and explain why it is relevant or important to the quantum circuit generation?
Response.
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this puzzle. We will add this part to our appendix to help other readers who are confused about the field. Your confusion will greatly help us improve our manuscript understanding.
Entanglement generation is a natural task for quantum circuit design because applications often require a specific pattern of correlations. In the recent work, Roh et al. (2025) experimentally prepared a photonic cluster state with three-dimensional connectivity, a resource for fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation; Arlt et al. (2026) illustrated this connection by automatically generating circuits for families of entangled states, including GHZ states, and verifying their outputs at a system size beyond those used for training.
What we want to emphasize is that a target entanglement pattern can often be realized by many different circuits, yet their depths and two-qubit gate counts can vary substantially. Identifying resource-efficient circuits for a prescribed entanglement pattern is therefore an important objective in quantum circuit synthesis. A dedicated optimizer may find a particularly compact implementation, but a trained generative model can amortize the search cost across targets and sample many candidates in parallel. Within a fixed time budget, this gives us a pool of circuits to screen: we can verify which candidates realize the requested entanglement pattern and select among them for low depth or few two-qubit gates. That's the reason why we propose the flowQC method that can fasten the path of circuit synthesis.
[1] Roh, Chan, Geunhee Gwak, Young-Do Yoon, and Young-Sik Ra. “Generation of three-dimensional cluster entangled state.” Nature Photonics, vol. 19, 2025, pp. 526–532.
[2] Arlt, Sören, Haonan Duan, Felix Li, Sang Michael Xie, Yuhuai Wu, and Mario Krenn. “Meta-designing quantum experiments with language models.” Nature Machine Intelligence, vol. 8, 2026, pp. 148–157.
Response to Reviewer ef2X (3/6)
Q2: Why for unitary synthesis, the circuit size is limited to 3 qubits based on Table 7?
Response.
We chose three qubits to enable a direct comparison with the unitary-synthesis benchmark of Fürrutter et al. (2024), using the same gate set and 12-gate limit. Unitary synthesis imposes a stricter correctness criterion than SRV-conditioned generation: a circuit must reproduce the target transformation on every input state, up to global phase, whereas the entanglement task constrains only the output prepared from . Scaling our current implementation is also more demanding because the unitary encoder takes a dense matrix with complex entries per target. Our 12-qubit results therefore apply to entanglement generation, and the scalability of unitary synthesis beyond three qubits remains to be evaluated.
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. In future work, we will investigate how well our approach scales to unitary synthesis beyond three qubits.
[1] Fürrutter, F., Muñoz-Gil, G. & Briegel, H.J. Quantum circuit synthesis with diffusion models.Nat Mach Intell 6, 515–524 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s42256-024-00831-9
Response to Reviewer ef2X (1/6)
Weakness
Response.
Thanks for pointing out this distinction that can help our manuscript more reliable. We will add experimental setting for unitary compilation in the rebuttal version.
qs_decomposition(U)with its default settings. The evaluator enforced the time budget.QSearchSynthesisPasswithSimpleLayerGenerator, a native {U3,CX} gate set, an internal synthesis threshold of 10−10.LEAPSynthesisPasswith the same layer generator, native gate set, internal threshold.59a0cc6. We used the six-gate pool listed above, one search thread per target, the implementation’s fixed search seed of 0, and a first-solution stopping rule.Response.
Then we added advanced quantum circuit synthesis tools such as BQSKit, MQT and Synthetic. The results help establish flowQC's balanced performance across reliability, sampling speed, and cir Cuit compactness to diffusion baselines and competitive QCS performance more broadly.