- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper aims to address a very specific question: is it possible to generate images directly using a shallow quantum circuit, bypassing the need for a classical neural network decoder? The authors propose SQGen, a method that embeds the multi-scale structure of Quantized Tensor Trains (QTT) directly into the quantum circuit and employs latent modulation to control the output, while performing the training process on a classical computer.
Critical strengths
The experimental design is comprehensive and effectively validates the roles of the various design components. In addition to image generation experiments on MNIST and Fashion-MNIST, the paper incorporates synthetic targets with well-defined structures to specifically evaluate the model's ability to capture multi-scale spatial structures and latent-conditioned variations. However, the experiments did not include comparisons with recent methods; only internal baseline ablation studies were conducted. Therefore, I am not inclined to accept the paper.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experimental comparison is not sufficiently strong.
-
The architectural novelty relative to prior QTT-based quantum circuit designs is not sufficiently clarified. And the practical cost of decoder-free generation is insufficiently analyzed.
These obvious weaknesses incline me toward a weak rejection.
Questions for authors
- While a decoder-free approach eliminates the need for a CNN, it introduces costs associated with shot complexity and probability estimation; this issue becomes particularly pronounced as resolutions increase.
2.I believe it is necessary to compare the proposed method against recent quantum image generation approaches, such as QIREN [1], QINR-QGAN [2], OQIDDM [3], and RQ-QGAN [4], to more convincingly demonstrate the effectiveness and competitiveness of the proposed quantum circuit design.Comparisons with decoder-free or coordinate-conditioned image generation methods are also required. Use classical QTT + LM to isolate the respective contributions of "QTT itself" and the "quantum" aspect; Additionally, include a resource-matched generic QCBM + LM to isolate the topological inductive bias.
- The circuit architecture of SQGen appears closely related to the QTT-based structured quantum circuits introduced in TNQE [5]. In particular, both methods employ a multiscale QTT organization, promote the bond dimension to ancillary bond qubits, and construct local circuit blocks acting jointly on the bond register and scale-wise physical qubits. I would therefore like the authors to clarify how much of the circuit architecture is newly introduced in SQGen compared with TNQE, and which architectural components are specific to the generative setting.
[1] Jiaming Zhao, Wenbo Qiao, Peng Zhang, and Hui Gao. Quantum implicit neural representations. In Proceedings of the 41st International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML), Proceedings of Machine Learning Research, 235:60940–60956, 2024.
[2] Han Qi, Yihan Xu, Hao Wang, Abdullah Gani, and Lip Yee Por. RQ-QGAN: Recurrent quantum generative adversarial network with QLSTM-inspired hidden states. The Journal of Supercomputing, 82:475, 2026.
[3] Jiale Zhang, Xilong Che, Yuzhe Fan, Shun Peng, Geng Chen, Quangong Ma, and Juncheng Hu. Denoising diffusion models with optimized quantum implicit neural networks for image generation. Future Generation Computer Systems, 173:107875, 2025.
[4] QuanGong Ma, ChaoLong Hao, NianWen Si, Geng Chen, Jiale Zhang, and Dan Qu. Quantum adversarial generation of high-resolution images. EPJ Quantum Technology, 12:3, 2025.
[5] Guang Lin, Toshihisa Tanaka, and Qibin Zhao. Structured Unitary Tensor Network Representations for Circuit-Efficient Quantum Data Encoding. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), 2026.