- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper attempted to solve an existing challenging task - 4D reconstruction- but not the first one attempting to address such problems. It is more likely to be a technical work rather than a research paper because it combines a lot of existing work. For example, it uses VGGT-Omega for camera parameter estimation and GMOS for motion segmentation. Why not consider Monst3r? The title is very confusing. In the title, the authors say single-image, but it is a monocular video. I have more concerns about the experiments and baselines, and I discuss these in the following sections.
Critical strengths
- The discussion in the paper is clear.
- The figure is very clear.
- The analysis, motivations, and objectives in the introduction make sense to me.
Critical weaknesses
- Table 1 is very confusing. It is misleading to compare the proposed method with other method categories. The proposed method is not the first to attempt to solve these 3 tasks. The authors should compare their proposed method with specific methods instead of general categories.
- This paper is a technical project instead of a research paper. The authors integrated a lot of methods into their framework. Therefore, I did not see enough contribution. The authors should rethink the motivation and the objective.
- This whole framework combines too many works. I am curious about the latency. In Table 7, I don't see any 4D reconstruction baselines. Besides, I do believe the motivations of several other baselines are not aligned with the authors' motivations. For example, can the proposed methods achieve the same goal with Neoverse? So, I would like to see more latency comparisons if the authors believe the latency is not a problem compared with other 4D reconstruction methods.
- The 3 testing datasets are definitely not enough. Each datasets only cover several cases, which cannot support the authors' claims. Davis dataset is a very good evaluation set for concrete demonstration.
- The baselines are not enough. The authors should compare their method with more related baselines, instead of doing so as I mentioned in No. 3.
- Given that the authors integrated a lot of existing works, it is better to do ablation studies to verify the contribution of each.
Questions for authors
Please see the critical weaknesses.