- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the lack of group-relative learning signals when all sampled responses to a difficult problem are incorrect. The authors identify “hinted reward shift,” where sustained optimization of hint-conditioned trajectories may limit improvement in unassisted reasoning. They propose HATCH, a single-policy framework that jointly trains original solving, reference-conditioned hint generation, and hinted re-solving. HATCH adaptively reduces the contribution of hinted-solve advantages and projects out components of hint-generation gradients that oppose the combined solution-side gradient. Experiments on three backbones and nine mathematical benchmarks show improvements over GRPO, QuESTA, and HiLL.
Critical strengths
-
The paper provides useful diagnostics of hint-assisted training. The advantage statistics, gradient-angle measurements, and experiments with different hint counts illustrate a potential trade-off between early learning gains and later unassisted performance. These observations motivate studying how auxiliary learning signals should be regulated.
-
HATCH achieves higher average no-hint accuracy than the evaluated baselines across all three backbones. The Online Hints ablation also provides evidence that explicitly optimizing hint generation contributes to performance. Removing this objective reduces Qwen3-8B accuracy from 53.76% to 50.16%, although the limited number of ablation runs warrants caution.
Critical weaknesses
-
The comparisons do not sufficiently establish the contribution relative to closely related methods. SAGE [1] and NuRL [3] are cited, but neither is evaluated directly. SAGE is particularly relevant because it generates reference-conditioned hints using the current policy and adapts hint strength. HATCH should distinguish its explicit hint-generation objective and loss weighting from these mechanisms. HiLL [2] is already included, and HATCH explicitly adopts its transfer-aware hint reward. The additional contribution beyond this reward therefore needs clearer isolation. Guide-GRPO [5] and BHA [6] are also relevant to the central motivation because they address learning across guided and unguided conditions through different mechanisms. GHPO [4] and HDPO [7] would provide further context. Direct comparisons with the closest alternatives, supported by faithful implementations and comparable budgets, would strengthen the claimed advance.
-
The ablations do not cleanly isolate the sources of improvement. Appendix C.1 states that Offline Hints uses one hint per query, whereas HATCH uses four. This comparison changes both the hint source and the amount of assisted training. Furthermore, each ablation uses a single training run, while HATCH reports a three-run average. The Online Hints comparison is more informative, but repeated runs are needed to assess its reliability. The fixed-weight result of 44.96% demonstrates that keeping β=1 performs poorly in this configuration. It does not establish that adaptive annealing is superior to a well-tuned constant weight. Comparisons with several constant weights and matched hint counts would better separate the effects of hint generation, weighting, and projection.
-
The evidence for the proposed mechanism is suggestive rather than conclusive. Larger mean absolute advantages do not directly establish larger gradient contributions, which also depend on trajectory counts, token weighting, and policy derivatives. Likewise, nearly orthogonal gradients do not by themselves demonstrate harmful interference. Increasing the number of hints also changes the amount and composition of training. The observed degradation is therefore consistent with the proposed explanation, but does not uniquely identify it. Scalar weighting can reduce the influence of hinted updates without converting them into updates of the no-hint objective. Similarly, projection uses a reference gradient that still includes hinted solving. The paper should clarify these limits and provide stronger evidence linking the measured dynamics to improved unassisted performance.
-
The scope of the self-improvement claim needs clarification. HATCH generates hints conditioned on ground-truth answers and reference solutions, and relies on a verifier for outcome feedback. Its learning signals therefore depend on externally supplied supervision, even though one policy performs both hint generation and solving. The experiments demonstrate improved unassisted performance after reference-supervised training. The paper should clarify that “self” refers to the shared policy and its jointly trained roles, rather than independence from external solution information. Without this distinction, the framing risks overstating the autonomy of the learning process.
[1] Self-Hinting Language Models Enhance Reinforcement Learning
[2] Learning to Hint for Reinforcement Learning
[3] Nudging the Boundaries of LLM Reasoning
[4] GHPO: Adaptive Guidance for Stable and Efficient LLM Reinforcement Learning
[5] Adaptive Guidance Accelerates Reinforcement Learning of Reasoning Models
[6] Mitigating Distribution Sharpening in Math RLVR via Distribution-Aligned Hint Synthesis and Backward Hint Annealing
[7] HDPO: Hybrid Distillation Policy Optimization via Privileged Self-Distillation
Questions for authors
-
Appendix A.2 describes the handling of thinking content during hint extraction. Please specify the thinking settings for original solving, hint generation, hinted re-solving, and evaluation. What fraction of responses reaches the 8,192-token limit in each setting?
-
Appendix A.3 describes the leakage detector, and Appendix D.2 reports its flagged-hint rate. Have you assessed false negatives through manual inspection, particularly for paraphrased answers or revealing intermediate computations? Are flagged hints and their associated re-solves excluded from policy updates?
-
Table 3 reports model-specific values of κ and γ, and Appendix C.2 describes validation-based selection. What search ranges and tuning budgets were used? How sensitive are results to κ and the EMA update coefficient, and how well do these settings transfer across backbones?
-
What are the realized β values at the selected checkpoints for each model? Could you disable hinted-solve updates at different training stages to distinguish their early contribution from their continuing contribution later in training?
-
Figure 5 provides a GPU-hour comparison with HiLL, and Appendix E reports component timings. Could you also report end-to-end cost and accuracy under matched compute budgets against GRPO? Please clarify the hinter initialization and training configuration used in the HiLL implementation.
-
Do the gains extend beyond pass@1 to larger values of k? A modest pass@k evaluation would help assess whether HATCH improves solution coverage as well as single-sample accuracy.
-
Can you conduct experiments using more frontier LLMs, such as Qwen3.5, MiniCPM5?
10 comments
3. Mechanism validation and gradient interference (Weakness 3)
Advantage statistics and gradient contributions. Mean absolute advantage does not directly measure total gradient contribution. We therefore complement it with token-averaged gradient comparisons on the same questions at the same model state, sampling eight responses per condition and retaining questions with mixed outcomes under both conditions.
| Model | Mean cosine | Cosine range | Angle from mean cosine (degrees) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-8B | 0.059478 | 0.01705--0.1059 | 86.59 |
Directional differences persist after controlling question identity, motivating us to treat hinted solving as a distinct auxiliary objective and regulate its contribution through online weighting. This weighting scales the auxiliary gradients rather than converting them into gradients of the unassisted objective.
Directional differences and harmful interference. The benefit of gradient correction is supported by controlled ablations from S5.3 (line417-428) and Appendix C.1 (line847-859), not inferred from near-orthogonality. The diagnostic compares original and hinted solving, whereas projection removes only hint-generation components opposing the combined solution-side gradient. We share PCGrad’s conflict-removal rule, but investigate role-specific correction of auxiliary-learning conflicts in self-teaching. We have added the citation and discussion. The below ablations show that hint-generation learning improves over Online Hints, our projection yields further gains, and reverse projection and an original-only reference perform worse.
| Qwen3-8B variant | Accuracy (%) |
|---|---|
| Online Hints, no hint-generation learning | 50.06 |
| Hint-generation learning without projection | 51.39 |
| Projection with original-only reference | 51.03 |
| Reverse projection | 49.15 |
| HATCH, combined solution-side reference | 53.76 |
4. Clarification of self improvement (Weakness 4)
In our work, we study self-improvement by training a single policy to learn from both solving and teaching based on external information. Existing works in other areas such as SISL [1] and PLD [2] also explore self-improvement while relying on external solution or verifier information. In HATCH, solving outcomes improve both solution behavior and hint generation, closing a feedback loop between learning and teaching.
[1] Self-Improving Skill Learning for Robust Skill-based Meta-Reinforcement Learning, ICLR 2026 [2] Self-Improving Vision-Language-Action Models with Data Generation via Residual RL, ICLR 2026
5. Thinking settings and generation limits (Question 1) For Qwen3-1.7B and Qwen3-8B, thinking is enabled in original solving, hint generation, hinted re-solving, and evaluation. Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct does not use this thinking mode. All compared methods use the same settings within each backbone, with a maximum prompt length of 4,096 tokens and a generation limit of 8,192 tokens. For hint injection, the thinking block is stripped from the generated text; this extraction is distinct from disabling thinking during generation. These have been stated in Appendix A.2 (line720-737). In the reported training statistics, HATCH's average at-limit response rate is approximately 40%, compared with approximately 50% for the baselines. These aggregate rates show that its accuracy gains are obtained under the same response-length constraint, with fewer responses reaching the cap.
6. Leakage detection and treatment (Question 2)
The detector checks for the reference answer and answer-revealing patterns, as described in Appendix A.3. Its flagged-hint rate fluctuates around 5%. We also manually inspect 100 sampled hints and observe almost no missed answer leakage. This provides a complementary check for cases that literal matching may miss, although it does not establish a zero false-negative rate. Flagged hints receive a hint-generation reward of and re-solves retain correctness-based rewards.
7. Parameter selection and sensitivity (Question 3)
The parameters control different aspects of the schedule: sets its overall scale, while controls how strongly the weight responds to changes in rollout composition. We select configurations using the held-out 200-problem validation set. The main configurations are for Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct, for Qwen3-1.7B, and for Qwen3-8B. To examine local sensitivity, we vary while fixing , and vary while fixing , on Qwen3-8B. Accuracy is the three-run mean of the macro average over the same nine no-hint benchmarks.
| Sensitivity comparison | Accuracy (%) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed | 5 | 4 | 49.93 |
| Fixed , main configuration | 5 | 5 | 53.76 |
| Fixed | 5 | 6 | 50.56 |
| Fixed , lower | 4 | 5 | 50.49 |
| Fixed , main configuration | 5 | 5 | 53.76 |
| Fixed , higher | 6 | 5 | 44.65 |
The EMA update coefficient is 0.1 in the main configuration. In our additional checks, increasing this coefficient above 0.1 produces small accuracy variations over the tested settings. The method is evaluated across backbones with model-specific and ; this supports applicability across models, rather than transfer of one universal parameter pair without retuning.
8. Realized weights and stage-specific removal of hinted-solving updates (Question 4)
The mean realized at the selected checkpoints across three runs is 0.705 for Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct, 0.206 for Qwen3-1.7B, and 0.259 for Qwen3-8B. We set after selected cutoff steps while retaining hint generation and re-solving for hint rewards. Results average three runs, with the no-cutoff baseline taken from the main HATCH experiment. These results support a continuing contribution from hinted-solving feedback, rather than attributing all benefits to early assisted exploration.
| Qwen3-8B continuation | Hinted-solve cutoff step | No-hint accuracy (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Continue data-driven online weighting | No cutoff | 53.76 |
| Earlier cutoff | 50 | 49.13 |
| Later cutoff | 150 | 52.16 |
9. Pass@k results (Question 6)
We extend evaluation to pass@16 and pass@32. Results are averaged equally across the same nine benchmarks. HATCH exceeds the strongest compared baseline, HiLL, by 2.54 pp at pass@16 and 2.19 pp at pass@32.
| Method | pass@1 (%) | pass@16 (%) | pass@32 (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| GRPO | 47.58 | 63.73 | 66.82 |
| HiLL | 49.44 | 69.27 | 72.84 |
| QuESTA | 49.07 | 68.51 | 70.93 |
| HATCH | 53.76 | 71.81 | 75.03 |
10. Evaluation on additional backbones (Question 7)
HATCH outperforms GRPO and HiLL on both Qwen3.5-2B and MiniCPM5-1B, extending the comparison to other recent backbones. The table reports average accuracy over the same nine mathematical benchmarks. On Qwen3.5-2B, HATCH improves over GRPO and HiLL by 5.52 and 3.55 pp, respectively; the corresponding gains on MiniCPM5-1B are 1.72 and 1.51 pp.
| Method | Qwen3.5-2B (%) | MiniCPM5-1B (%) |
|---|---|---|
| GRPO | 36.03 | 23.89 |
| HiLL | 38.00 | 24.11 |
| HATCH | 41.54 | 25.62 |
All the additional results have been added to the paper.
Thank you for the detailed review and for recognizing the value of our diagnostics and improvements in unassisted reasoning. We clarify our contributions and provide additional baseline comparisons, controlled ablations, and broader evaluations to address your concerns.
1. Clarification of contribution and distinctions from related methods (Weakness 1)
We focus on hinted reward shift, which prior hint-based methods do not explicitly address. SAGE and NuRL explore self-generated hints but do not examine this shift. HiLL, Guide-GRPO, BHA, and GHPO seek to make hint construction more effective, without explicitly addressing how sustained hinted feedback can shift optimization toward assisted solving. HDPO instead combines GRPO with privileged self-distillation, addressing a different research problem. We have added the relevant citations and discussion to the paper (lines 126–138).
We additionally evaluate the two closest methods SAGE and NuRL on Qwen3-8B using the same setting. The table reports macro-average accuracy over the nine benchmarks, averaged over three independent runs.
HATCH exceeds SAGE and NuRL by 4.54 and 5.71 percentage points, respectively. These results complement the methodological distinction with direct comparisons to online and offline self-hinting; the controlled ablations below further examine which aspects of HATCH contribute to its gains.
2. Further multi-seed ablation and computational fairness (Weakness 2 and Question 5)
We provide further multi-seed ablations that support our design. The two tables below report Qwen3-8B results averaged over three independent training seeds, using the same setting as the main experiments.
Additional rollouts and matched hint counts. We increase GRPO's original rollouts from 8 to 32, extend HiLL to retain four hinted-solve groups, and compare against four fixed external hints per query. Each retained hint has eight re-solves.
Neither increasing GRPO rollouts nor matching HATCH’s four-hint setting with HiLL or external hints closes the performance gap. We have also added GRPO to Figure 5 (middle), alongside HiLL and HATCH, to compare accuracy against the same end-to-end cumulative GPU-hour axis. At a matched budget, HATCH achieves a best-so-far no-hint accuracy of 51.2%, exceeding HiLL’s 50.3% and GRPO’s 47.5%. Together with the larger-rollout and matched-hint-count controls above, this provides complementary evidence that the observed gains are not explained solely by additional trajectories.
Constant weights and predefined schedules. We also provide ablations on different weights under the same self-teaching framework from S5.3 (line415-464) and Appendix C.1 (line846-860). The results support our design of adaptive annealing. A carefully chosen time schedule may work well for a particular training setting, but it prescribes the same weight at a given step regardless of the policy's learning state. HATCH instead uses the balance between solve-none and solve-partial groups to adjust assistance as training evolves.
For HiLL settings, hint generation and reasoning use Qwen3-8B initialization. The common learning rate, optimizer, decoding parameters, and length limits are specified in Appendix A.2. The main comparison uses best-hint selection; the additional four-hint variant retains four hinted-solve groups, with eight re-solves per hint.