acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PATH-GRPO: Placement-Aware Teacher Hinting for Data-Scarce Multi-Turn Agents

Abstract

Training a language-model agent with reinforcement learning (RL) is hard when training tasks are few and most attempts fail. With so few tasks, a supervised warm start before RL has little to learn from. Group-relative methods such as GRPO learn from reward differences within a group of attempts, so a group in which every attempt fails gives no learning signal. Most existing hint methods for such groups study single-turn reasoning, where the hint can only go in the prompt. In a multi-turn agent, a hint can enter at any turn, so where it enters becomes a design choice. We introduce PATH-GRPO (Placement-Aware Teacher Hinting with GRPO). When every attempt fails, a teacher chooses a restart turn, reads the reference solution, and writes an insight that explains how to find the answer. The policy retries from that turn, and we remove the insight before the update (stripping), so that the update sees the same inputs as evaluation, where the policy gets no help. With only 90 AppWorld tasks and 45 TravelPlanner queries, PATH-GRPO improves over GRPO at both 4B and 9B, on AppWorld Test-Challenge scenario goal completion (+13.2 and +9.2 points) and TravelPlanner leaderboard test success (+29.1 and +4.5). Our extensive ablations show that placement matters: on the main metrics, placing the insight at a teacher-chosen restart turn scores higher than placing it in the prompt or at a random turn. For these turn-level retries, both stripping the insight and letting the insight-generator teacher read the reference solution also yield higher scores on these metrics.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
grpo, hint-grpo, agent, appworl, travelplanner, dead-group-grpo

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 17%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.75 over 4 reviews, above 83% of the others.
Reviewer_LcmiOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to train multi-turn agents with few tasks when repeated failures leave GRPO without useful reward signals. It proposes PATH-GRPO, where a teacher chooses a restart turn and then uses the reference solution to write a corrective hint. The agent retries from that turn, and the hint is removed before the model update to encourage learning without teacher assistance. Experiments show that PATH-GRPO outperforms GRPO, with targeted turn-level hints working better than global hints.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an important problem: how to train multi-turn agents with few tasks and sparse outcome rewards. This matters because repeated failures can leave GRPO without useful reward signals, making learning especially difficult when successful trajectories are scarce.

Critical weaknesses

W1: The placement experiments also change both the hint location and its content, making it difficult to attribute their effects.

W2: The paper lacks enough discussions and comparisons with process-reward methods, such as StepSearch[1] and IGPO[2]. A suitable comparison would clarify whether teacher-guided retries offer advantages over existing ways of handling sparse rewards.

[1] StepSearch: Igniting LLMs Search Ability via Step-Wise Proximal Policy Optimization,EMNLP 2025.

[2] Information Gain-based Policy Optimization: A Simple and Effective Approach for Multi-Turn Search Agents,ICLR 2026

Questions for authors

Q1. The AppWorld SFT baseline uses synthetic tool responses and reference programs that the agent cannot directly execute. Comparing against verified, executable teacher demonstrations would help clarify whether its poor performance comes from limited data or mismatched training examples.

Q2. The paper does not report how often hint removal fails or hint text remains in the training context. It would be useful to report these rates and check whether the gains remain after filtering such cases.

Q3. Equal trajectory counts do not imply equal training cost, since PATH-GRPO requires teacher calls and environment replay. A comparison under the same total budget would clarify whether it offers advantages over giving GRPO more rollouts.

Reviewer_562zOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary
  • This paper proposes a training method to improve the early-stage learning efficiency of GRPO and enhance the final performance of multi-turn agents.
Critical strengths
  • The paper proposes a method to improve the early-stage learning efficiency of multi-turn agents when none of the trajectories in a group produces a correct answer, a situation referred to as a dead group in the paper.
  • In such cases, the method invokes an external teacher LLM to determine how to formulate and use a helpful prompt (insight) and where to insert it within the multi-turn interaction. The proposed approach is relatively simple yet clearly motivated. The authors also evaluate the method using models of different sizes and compare it with various generation configurations, providing evidence of its effectiveness.
  • On the AppWorld and TravelPlanner benchmarks, the proposed method improves Goal Completion by approximately 13 percentage points over vanilla GRPO with the Qwen3-4B model.
  • The proposed method appears particularly beneficial for reinforcement learning with smaller models or on tasks where the initial policy has not been sufficiently trained through SFT or similar approaches, yielding greater improvements during early training.
Critical weaknesses
  • The approach requires frequent calls to a relatively large teacher model during reinforcement learning. Although the paper states that the teacher is invoked only for dead groups, which primarily occur during early training, Figure 1(a) shows that approximately 77.8% of groups are dead groups at the beginning of training. Dead groups also remain relatively frequent up to around 70–80 steps. This suggests that the method may introduce substantial delays during training, but the associated overhead is not sufficiently analyzed.
  • Although the paper argues that the method is particularly effective for smaller models or tasks with insufficient initial training through SFT or similar approaches, its generalizability remains unclear. Further experiments on benchmarks where these conditions do not necessarily hold would help establish the range of settings in which the proposed method is effective.
Questions for authors
  • The paper reports the number of tokens consumed by the external teacher. It would also be helpful to provide an analysis of the resulting training-time overhead, including the additional latency introduced by teacher calls.
  • If results on additional benchmarks are available, presenting them would help clarify the generalizability of the proposed method and the range of tasks to which it can be effectively applied.
Reviewer_J9C4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies RL for multi-turn agents in data-scarce settings where most GRPO groups fail completely (dead groups). The authors propose PATH-GRPO: when the first half of a rollout group fails, an external teacher (Claude) selects a restart turn from the failed trajectory and writes a procedural insight using the reference solution. The agent retries from that turn with the insight, and the insight is stripped from the context before computing a mixed-policy shaping loss. Experiments on AppWorld (90 tasks) and TravelPlanner (45 queries) with 4B and 9B models show improvements over vanilla GRPO and single-turn hinting baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. Studying where guidance should enter in multi-turn agent trajectories and whether it should be stripped before the gradient update is a practical problem, and the empirical comparison in Table 2 clearly shows that stripping helps turn-level hints while hurting global hints.

  2. The method achieves solid gains over vanilla GRPO in a challenging low-resource regime (90 AppWorld tasks and 45 TravelPlanner queries) where standard SFT and RFT warm starts struggle.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty seems somewhat limited, as the core algorithmic components are largely assembled from existing methods, while many closely related works on turn-level branching and rollout allocation for multi-turn agent RL are overlooked, not limited to [1-6]. Specifically, the insight-stripping mechanism and the mixed-policy shaping loss in Eq. (3) are directly adopted from LUFFY and LTE, and the main change is moving the hint from the initial prompt to an intermediate turn. Meanwhile, resuming from intermediate turns to create mixed-outcome groups and improve credit assignment in multi-turn agentic RL has already been widely explored through prefix continuation and tree-structured rollouts [1-6], yet none of these methods are discussed or empirically compared. Without comparing against these turn-level branching and rollout-allocation frameworks, it is unclear how much of the gain comes from the proposed teacher-hinting pipeline versus simply branching at intermediate turns.

  2. The method relies on strong privileged assumptions that narrow its applicability and complicate the fairness of the comparison. First, generating the turn-level insight requires both a strong proprietary teacher (Claude Sonnet 4.6, whose tokens equal 28.9%-35.0% of the student policy's training tokens on TravelPlanner) and ground-truth reference solutions for every training task (plus the full candidate database on TravelPlanner). In contrast, baselines such as GRPO and LTE do not have access to Claude Sonnet 4.6 or full reference solutions during RL. Second, on AppWorld, selecting a teacher-chosen restart turn improves over a random turn or midpoint turn by only 1.3 and 1.5 points in Table 2 (44.4 vs. 43.1 and 42.9), making the necessity of the separate teacher-selector call less convincing on this benchmark.

[1] Tree Search for LLM Agent Reinforcement Learning

[2] Branching Policy Optimization: Sandbox-Native Language Agent Reinforcement Learning

[3] TRACE: A Unified Rollout Budget Allocation Framework for Efficient Agentic Reinforcement Learning

[4] VinePPO: Refining Credit Assignment in RL Training of LLMs

[5] AT2PO: Agentic Turn-Based Policy Optimization via Tree Search

[6] Improving Sampling Efficiency in RLVR through Adaptive Rollout and Response Reuse

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors discuss the connection and differences between PATH-GRPO and recent turn-level branching / rollout-allocation methods for agentic RL [1-6], and compare with at least one turn-level branching baseline that does not rely on an external teacher?

  2. In Table 2, on AppWorld, the teacher-chosen restart turn (44.4) is only 1.3-1.5 points higher than a random turn (43.1) or midpoint turn (42.9). Why does the choice of restart turn matter so much less on AppWorld than on TravelPlanner?

  3. Since PATH-GRPO relies on Claude Sonnet 4.6 and ground-truth reference solutions (consuming up to 35% of policy tokens on TravelPlanner), what happens if the student model itself (self-teacher) is used to select the turn and generate the insight?

6 comments

Is the pdf updated to the lastest version?

Thank you for reading our rebuttal and for the reminder. We have uploaded a revised PDF.

We were waiting for the training runs of the teacher-free branching baseline (Q1) to finish before we updated the PDF. Since you asked, we have updated it now with everything except that training result. All new text and tables are in blue, so the changes are easy to find.

We will post the branching-baseline comparison as soon as the training runs finish, and we will add it to the PDF then.

Follow-up on Q1: teacher-free branching baselines.

As promised, we trained two of the branching methods you cited: Tree-GRPO and AT²PO. We used TravelPlanner and the 4B policy. All methods use the same policy, environment, verifier, and number of rollouts (16 per task).

The revised PDF shows the full curves (Appendix M, Figure 6). The table shows every evaluation from step 240 to the latest one.

TravelPlanner validation final success (pass@4, %):

Training stepGRPOTree-GRPOAT²POPATH-GRPO (ours)PATH-GRPO vs best baseline
2407.39.312.741.2+28.5
2647.915.219.642.5+22.9
2889.617.823.541.7+18.2
31211.119.532.642.3+9.7
33611.9(not reached yet)36.443.7+7.3
36012.0(not reached yet)33.947.0+13.0
38412.8(not reached yet)37.049.9+12.8
40817.8(not reached yet)40.355.7+15.3

What the results show:

  • Branching helps. Both branching methods score higher than GRPO.
  • The teacher's insight helps much more. PATH-GRPO scores higher than both branching methods at every evaluation from step 144 on.
  • PATH-GRPO learns faster. It reaches 30% about 100 steps before AT²PO.

This matches our earlier reply. At the first step, every TravelPlanner group is dead. Branching can only reuse the policy's own attempts, so it has no success to start from. Without new information, extra retries rescue only 0.3% of these dead groups.

These runs take longer than the discussion period. We will add the full-length TravelPlanner runs and the AppWorld runs to the camera-ready version.

Reviewer_pR4zOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

PATH-GRPO improves multi-turn agent training when limited training data and unsuccessful rollouts leave GRPO without a useful learning signal. A teacher selects a restart turn and uses a reference solution to write a procedural hint, which guides a retry and is removed before training on the resulting trajectory. Experiments on AppWorld and TravelPlanner with 4B and 9B models show improvements over GRPO and the evaluated hint-based and supervised baselines.

Critical strengths

Overall, the concept is clear and addresses a practical problem in multi-turn agent training. Below are the main strengths from my perspective.

  • Well-motivated approach to unsuccessful rollout groups: I particularly like the focus on groups where every attempt fails and GRPO consequently receives no reward contrast. These groups may still contain useful exploration, so restarting near a consequential mistake and providing targeted guidance is a sensible approach. Separating the teacher’s turn selection from its reference-informed hint generation is also interesting. The method gives the student another opportunity to produce a successful trajectory while ultimately evaluating it without assistance. Although guided retries and hint stripping already exist, studying how these choices interact in multi-turn environments is a useful contribution.
  • Promising results on challenging agent tasks: The improvements are substantial, particularly for the 4B model on TravelPlanner. Its leaderboard test success increases from 27.1% with GRPO to 56.2% with PATH-GRPO, compared with 43.6% for the NuRL adaptation. The method also improves the 9B model and the reported AppWorld results. I appreciate that the main comparisons use shared task pools and rollout budgets, and that evaluation requires the policy to act without the teacher. These results provide meaningful evidence that the guided trajectories can improve the policy’s subsequent independent behavior.

There are also other points that I appreciated:

  • Teacher-size ablation: The Haiku experiment shows that most of the improvement does not depend on the default Sonnet teacher.
  • Presentation: The method description, algorithm, and concrete hint examples make the training procedure easy to understand.
  • Appendix: The explanations of dataset construction, scoring, teacher usage, and implementation limitations are helpful.
Critical weaknesses

Despite the aforementioned strengths, there are two concerns that limit how confidently I can interpret the main results and the conclusions drawn from the ablations.

  • The reported pass@4 needs a standard evaluation counterpart: Appendix H computes the reported score by resampling four observed attempts with replacement, giving an expected task score of (1-(1-\bar r)^4). This differs from the usual empirical success-within-four-attempts calculation. For example, a task with one successful attempt among four contributes approximately 0.684 under your estimator, although it was successfully solved within the four collected attempts. This is not simply a constant rescaling and can affect relative rankings, particularly when methods differ in how successes are distributed across tasks. I appreciate that the distinction is disclosed, but it affects the main AppWorld results and most ablations. Please also report standard pass@4 from the existing attempts, explain the corresponding scenario-level aggregation, and show whether the main conclusions remain unchanged. The TravelPlanner leaderboard pass@1 results provide separate evidence that is unaffected by this concern.
  • The placement comparisons do not cleanly isolate placement: Global and turn-level guidance differ in more than where the hint is inserted. They also change the diagnosis, hint content, and whether an existing trajectory prefix is retained. Figure 3 illustrates this particularly clearly: the global and turn-level hints address different errors. Table 9 also shows considerably different hint lengths, such as 274 versus 60 estimated tokens on AppWorld. I appreciate that you describe these as comparisons of complete strategies, but the central emphasis on placement would benefit from stronger isolation. I would suggest a teacher-selected restart baseline without a hint, together with a comparison that holds the guidance content and length as similar as possible across insertion positions. This would help distinguish the benefits of placement from those of more targeted guidance and retaining useful earlier exploration.

There are some additional points that I would like to phrase as questions below.

Questions for authors

As mentioned above, there are some further points that I would like to phrase as questions to the authors.

1) Construction of the SFT baseline: Appendix D.1 states that the AppWorld reference programs use helpers and data unavailable to the agent, are not executed, and receive synthetic observations. Could the near-zero SFT performance therefore reflect a mismatch between the demonstrations and the agent’s actual execution environment, rather than insufficient training data alone? The RFT-hinted baseline is useful, but I would appreciate either an SFT comparison using executable demonstrations or a narrower interpretation of what the reference-SFT results establish.

2) Stripping and fallback behavior: How often does stripping fail, causing a guided retry to retain its hint and use the approximate clipped-loss fallback? Appendix K also states that residual-copy checks log matches without rejecting trajectories. Reporting these frequencies would help establish how consistently the implemented training procedure uses insight-free inputs.

3) Closely related multi-turn baselines: You already discuss methods such as R3L, PivoARL, and ToolAnchor. Could you explain why the main comparisons focus on adaptations of single-turn hint methods, and whether a comparison against a suitable multi-turn retry method is feasible? This would help clarify the additional benefit over approaches that already choose intervention or restart points.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of the rebuttal and revision

We thank all four reviewers. They agree on the problem: when there are few training tasks, many GRPO groups of a multi-turn agent fail completely, so they give no learning signal.

We uploaded a revised PDF. All new text, tables, and figures are in blue.

New results

QuestionReviewersAnswer
Does teacher-free branching work as well?J9C4No. We trained Tree-GRPO and AT²PO. PATH-GRPO stays higher at every evaluation from step 144 on, and leads AT²PO by 15.3 points at step 408 (Appendix M).
Do more retries without a teacher help?J9C4, Lcmi, pR4zRarely. Unguided retries rescue 13.9% (AppWorld) and 0.3% (TravelPlanner) of dead groups. Guided retries rescue 53.3% and 13.8% (Table 17).
Is a strong closed teacher needed?J9C4No. All six teachers beat GRPO by at least 7.3 points. The small open gpt-oss-20b matches Claude Sonnet on AppWorld (Table 7).
Does the position matter, or only the text?pR4z, LcmiThe position matters. The same insight text rescues 27.5% of AppWorld dead groups at the chosen turn, and 8.0% in the prompt (Table 16).
Standard pass@4?pR4zPATH-GRPO still has the highest AppWorld Test-Challenge score at both scales (Table 15).
Does stripping fail?pR4z, LcmiRarely: at most 0.54% of guided retries. Removing them does not change which dead groups are rescued (Table 18).
What does guidance cost?562z, LcmiIt adds 0.7% to 33.3% to the training-step time. With equal training time, PATH-GRPO still wins in all four settings (Table 19).
Do SFT baselines do better?pR4z, LcmiNo. Training on executed and verified trajectories (RFT, RFT-hinted) also stays below PATH-GRPO (Section 4.2).

Changes in the revised PDF

  • Appendix L: the additional analyses above.
  • Appendix M: the teacher-free branching baselines.
  • Table 7: four open-weight teachers.
  • Related work on branching, rollout allocation, and process rewards.
  • Clearer text on baseline fairness, the SFT result, and why the turn choice matters less on AppWorld.

We are happy to answer more questions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.