acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Learning to Hint for Reinforcement Learning

Abstract

Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) often suffers from advantage collapse in reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards: when all rollouts in a group receive the same reward, their relative advantages vanish. Hint-based methods address all-incorrect groups by adding guidance that induces mixed outcomes and recovers a learning signal. However, creating a learning signal under the hinted input does not necessarily improve the no-hint policy used at test time. To this end, we propose **Hi**nt **L**earning for Reinforcement **L**earning (HiLL), a framework that learns to generate hints by considering both signal creation and signal transfer. HiLL trains a hinter alongside the reasoner, generating hints conditioned on the question, an incorrect rollout from the current reasoner, and a reference solution available only during training. We introduce *hint reliance*, which measures how strongly correct hinted trajectories depend on the hint by comparing their likelihoods with and without it. We derive a theoretical transfer bound relating hint reliance to hinted and no-hint success probabilities. Motivated by this result, we construct a transfer-weighted hinter reward that favors hints that recover informative GRPO groups while penalizing high hint reliance. Experiments across eight benchmarks with two backbone LLMs show that HiLL outperforms GRPO and hint-based baselines. Ablations further show that transfer weighting reduces hint reliance and improves no-hint performance, demonstrating the value of transfer-aware hint learning for RL.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
LLM, RLVR, Hint Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_rA25OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies RLVR for difficult reasoning problems. When all rollouts in a GRPO group are incorrect, the group has zero relative advantage and provides no learning signal. The paper proposes HiLL method, which trains a separate hinter to generate hints for these groups. The hinter conditions on the question, an incorrect rollout, and a reference solution available only during training. Candidate hints are scored by both their ability to create mixed outcomes and their reliance. The selected hints are used to update the reasoner, while the hinter is trained with GRPO. Experiments show that HiLL improves over GRPO and several hint based baselines. In addition, ablations suggest that transfer weighting reduces hint reliance and improves no hint performance.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies an important distinction between creating a GRPO learning signal and transferring that signal to the no-hint policy.
  2. The transfer weighted reward is a reasonable way to combine these two goals.
Critical weaknesses
  1. It is unclear why the proposed hinting pipeline is preferable to direct process supervision or other ways of using the same reference solutions.
  2. The main transfer criterion is indirect. Lower hint reliance does not necessarily imply better learning after the reasoner update. The paper does not provide enough evidence that this metric is a reliable measure of future no-hint improvement.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the benefit of using a separate learned hinter instead of direct process supervision, fixed teacher hints, or self generated hints under the same compute and supervision budget?
  2. Does hint reliance predict improvement in the no hint policy after training?
  3. How sensitive is HiLL to the quality of the training-only reference solutions? Does it still work with incomplete or noisy reference solutions?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to Reviewer rA25

Thank you for your review and for recognizing the distinction between creating a GRPO learning signal and transferring it to no-hint reasoning. We clarify the existing budget comparisons and provide an additional analysis of subsequent learning.


Response to W1 and Q1 (benefit of a separate learned hinter)

Our paper already compares HiLL with teacher-generated scaffolds through Scaf-GRPO [2] and self-generated hints through SAGE [1]. HiLL achieves higher average no-hint performance on both reasoner backbones (Table 1). The key difference is learning what hint to generate for the reasoner's current failure. Scaf-GRPO uses teacher-generated scaffolds at predefined levels, while SAGE periodically refreshes self-generated hints and adapts their strength. HiLL instead trains a separate hinter conditioned on the reasoner's failed rollout, using the resulting mixed-outcome signal and hint reliance to optimize the generated guidance.

To control for model initialization and training cost, Table 2 of our paper further compares HiLL and SAGE under the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct initialization and training configuration, alongside compute-matched GRPO:

MethodAIME24AIME25AMC23MATH-500MinervaOlympiadGPQAMMLU-ProAvg.Time
GRPO (G=32G=32)10.111.8832.3454.6019.6621.7825.5739.6425.703.89×3.89\times
SAGE9.481.4632.8154.9520.2521.5027.5138.6925.834.15×4.15\times
HiLL11.041.6735.1656.0921.3322.6628.1841.0227.143.88×3.88\times

All methods use 500 training steps, with time measured relative to GRPO (G=8G=8). HiLL outperforms SAGE at comparable cost and GRPO at matched compute, supporting the benefit of learning failure-conditioned, transfer-aware hints rather than simply using additional rollouts or self-generated guidance.

The separate-policy design is also supported by Appendix D.3, where direct parameter sharing causes interference in hint generation, including increasingly long hints and continuations into full solutions. The HiLL w/o TW ablation further isolates the benefit of the transfer-aware reward within the same learned-hinter framework.

Finally, unlike direct process supervision, HiLL uses reference solutions to guide exploration rather than as imitation targets. The reasoner learns from its own rollouts using verifiable correctness rewards, without requiring costly step-level supervision. This allows the hinter to learn useful guidance while preserving the reasoner's on-policy RLVR objective.


Response to W2 and Q2 (hint reliance and subsequent no-hint improvement)

We directly examine this connection through controlled reasoner updates, in addition to the full-training transfer-weighting ablation.

For eight questions, we construct paired hints with identical mathematical content and comparable lengths. We vary the usage instruction, independently confirm the reliance difference, and screen pairs for comparable hinted success rates. Each condition starts from the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct model and receives eight matched GRPO updates. We then evaluate 64 fresh responses per updated question without hints.

Training conditionNo-hint accuracy improvement (percentage points)
Lower-reliance framing+4.10
Higher-reliance framing+2.54
No-hint training+1.95

Lower-reliance guidance yields greater observed no-hint improvement despite identical mathematical information. This directly connects differences in measured reliance to subsequent learning after hint removal, complementing the end-to-end evidence from the transfer-weighting ablation.


Response to Q3 (reference-solution quality)

HiLL follows the reference-guided RLVR setting used by SAGE [1] and Scaf-GRPO [2]. Unlike direct imitation, reference solutions are used only to condition the hinter, while the reasoner learns from its own rollouts with correctness independently verified against ground-truth answers. Candidate hints must produce informative mixed-outcome groups to receive positive rewards. We therefore expect HiLL to be less sensitive to imperfect references than methods that directly imitate reference trajectories. We leave systematic evaluation with incomplete or noisy references as a future extension.


[1] Liao et al. Self-Hinting Language Models Enhance Reinforcement Learning. arXiv 2026.

[2] Zhang et al. Scaf-GRPO: Scaffolded Group Relative Policy Optimization for Enhancing LLM Reasoning. ICLR 2026.

Thank you for the clarifications and the additional controlled update analysis, which address several of my concerns. Could you clarify how the eight questions and paired hints were selected, and whether this selection was completed before observing the subsequent no hint improvements?

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-Up Reply to Reviewer rA25

Thank you for your reply and for acknowledging that our rebuttal addressed several of your concerns.

Regarding your follow-up question, yes, the eight questions and paired hints were selected before any training updates or subsequent no-hint evaluations.

We first selected math questions of moderate difficulty and constructed reference-derived hints. For each question, we kept the content of the mathematical guidance fixed while varying its framing, either encouraging the reasoner to derive the key result independently or to directly reuse the provided intermediate steps. We then measured hint reliance using 128 fresh responses per framing from the initial reasoner and selected pairs with a verified reliance difference (at least 0.02, with the lower bound of the 95% bootstrap confidence interval above zero), while requiring comparable hinted success rates, hint lengths, and response lengths.

Among 48 candidate questions, 14 satisfied these predefined criteria. We selected the first eight qualifying pairs in a fixed shuffled order to form one training batch. Therefore, selection was based entirely on pre-update measurements, without observing or using subsequent no-hint improvements. We hope this clarification addresses your remaining concern.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Kind Reminder to Reviewer rA25

Dear Reviewer rA25,

As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would like to follow up on whether our further clarifications have addressed your remaining question. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Best,
Authors

Reviewer_yBSnOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes an interesting framework that jointly trains a hint generator and a reasoning model to primarily address sparse in-correct rollout issue in vanilla GRPO type approaches. When the reasoner fails on every sampled attempt i.e for harder questions, the hinter generates candidate hints using the question, a failed attempt, and a reference solution. Each hint is rewarded for producing mixed correct/incorrect outcomes while limiting the successful solutions’ dependence on the hint. The reasoner trains on the answer group associated with the highest-reward hint, using binary correctness rewards, while the hinter trains through GRPO over all candidate hints. At inference, the reasoner operates without hints. Experimental result show positive

Critical strengths
  1. The approach recognizes that recovering successful rollouts is insufficient if those successes depend heavily on guidance unavailable at inference which is an interesting finding also pointed in prior works [1,2]
  2. The hint-reliance measure compares successful trajectories’ likelihoods with and without hints, which is crucial to understand if those trajectories are learnable or not by the student [1,2]
  3. The reasoner learns to solve problems, while the hinter learns to generate guidance that creates useful training groups.
  4. Experiments show improved average performance

References

  1. Privileged Information Distillation for Language Models https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.04942
  2. Pedagogical RL: Teaching Models to Teach Themselves from Privileged Information https://noahziems.com/pedagogical-rl
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper would strongly benefit from a detailed comparison of its motivation, reward design, and training procedure with these closely related approaches [1,2]. In particular, the connection to Pedagogical RL’s use of a multiplicative reward combining correctness and learnability deserves explicit discussion to clarify the distinct contribution of this approach.
  2. A concern is that early in training, privileged hints may enable success primarily by revealing critical solution information. Mixed correct/incorrect outcomes alone do not exclude such shortcuts. If the leakage check or reliance penalty fails to identify them, these trajectories may enter the reasoner’s training data; if they are consistently rejected or strongly penalized, useful learning signals may become sparse. The paper should examine how often these situations arise and how training escapes them. The other possibility is training on leaked trajectories which is even harmful.
  3. An extremely important aspect is that averaging log-probability differences across an entire trajectory may dilute dependence concentrated in a few critical tokens, particularly for long reasoning traces as shown in [2]. Consequently, a low average reliance score need not establish that a solution is free of privileged-information leakage. A discussion of this limitation would highly strengthen the paper.
  4. Limited qualitative evidence of reduced leakage- Examples of generated hints and corresponding solver trajectories from early and late training would help establish whether the hinter learns to provide transferable guidance. These examples should distinguish strategic guidance from hints that supply essential intermediate results or otherwise reveal the solution especially for reasoning or thinking models.
  5. Broader discussion and, where applicable, empirical comparisons with methods such as SDPO, OPSD, Pedagogy, pi-distill and related self-distillation approaches are needed. These comparisons would help isolate the benefits of learning a hint generator over alternative ways of exploiting training-only information.
  6. The hinter’s reward depends on a changing reasoner, while the reasoner’s training distribution depends on a changing hinter. This coupling raises questions about optimization stability and the relative timescales of the two updates. Analysis or ablations involving update frequencies, learning-rate ratios, or temporarily frozen policies would clarify the importance of these dynamics and their relationship to bilevel formulations.
  7. A key concern is insufficient evaluation on thinking models. Experiments with dedicated thinking models are needed to assess whether the method remains effective for longer reasoning traces, where reliance on privileged information may be harder to detect. In addition to final accuracy, these experiments should report independent leakage measurements and ablate the reliance penalty and leakage checks.

References

  1. Privileged Information Distillation for Language Models https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.04942
  2. Pedagogical RL: Teaching Models to Teach Themselves from Privileged Information https://noahziems.com/pedagogical-rl
Questions for authors

Mentioned in Weakness section

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to Reviewer yBSn (Part 1/2)

Thank you for your review and for recognizing the distinction between hinted success and learning that transfers to no-hint reasoning. We address the comparisons with prior work and the concerns about privileged guidance, local dependence, and training dynamics.


Response to W1 and W5 (relationship to privileged-information learning)

Thank you for pointing us to π\pi-Distill [1] and Pedagogical RL [2]. These methods share the motivation of learning from training-only privileged information, but optimize different guidance mechanisms and learner updates.

MethodLearned guidance mechanismLearner update
π\pi-DistillPrivileged trajectory-generating teacher optimized for reward and proximity to the studentJoint teacher-student objectives with shared parameters
Pedagogical RLPrivileged trajectory-generating teacher optimized for correctness and spike-aware learnabilitySurprisal-gated imitation of teacher trajectories
HiLLFailure-conditioned hint generator optimized for signal creation and low hint relianceVerifier-based GRPO on the reasoner's own hinted rollouts

Pedagogical RL's multiplicative reward scores a teacher-generated trajectory. HiLL instead scores a hint through the group of reasoner trajectories it induces. This distinction matters for GRPO because maximizing hinted correctness can produce all-correct groups with zero relative advantages. HiLL explicitly combines mixed-outcome signal creation with dependence on the hint.

Our contribution is therefore not privileged information or co-training alone. It is learning what guidance to generate according to both the learning signal it creates and the reasoner's dependence on that guidance.

Section 2 already discusses SDPO and OPSD [3,4], which provide privileged token-level supervision on student-generated trajectories. HiLL learns the training-time input guidance while retaining verifier-based reasoner updates. We will expand the discussion of [1,2] to make these distinctions explicit.


Response to W2 and W4 (privileged information, learning signals, and qualitative evidence)

Training-only privileged information is intentional in hint-based RL, and its presence does not by itself establish harmful learning. POPE and GHPO explicitly use oracle or ground-truth solution prefixes [5,6], Scaf-GRPO includes concrete intermediate calculation steps [7], and SAGE generates hints from reference solutions [8]. The relevant question is whether this guidance improves reasoning after it is removed.

HiLL directly targets excessive dependence through a learned hint policy and a reasoner-dependent reward. Tables 1–2 evaluate the reasoner without hints, while HiLL w/o TW retains the same reference access and hinting procedure but removes reliance weighting. This comparison supports the contribution of the transfer-aware objective rather than privileged information alone.

The concern about insufficient learning signals is already examined in Figure 2 of our paper. On both backbones, HiLL and HiLL w/o TW substantially reduce the all-incorrect ratio compared with GRPO, while HiLL maintains lower reliance. Thus, transfer weighting preserves useful signal creation while improving no-hint performance. It guides hint selection and hinter training, rather than multiplying the reasoner's correctness rewards or imposing an additional reliance-based rejection threshold.

We also provide actual early- and late-training examples from the recorded HiLL run. The last column summarizes excerpts from successful hinted rollouts.

Training stageQuestionGenerated hint excerptRecorded reasoner continuation
Early, step 1Three players roll a die. What is the probability that C exceeds both A and B?“Fix C's roll first, and compute the probability that both A and B roll a strictly smaller number than C. Then average this probability over all possible values of C's roll.”Computes the conditional probabilities for each possible roll of C, averages them, and obtains 55/216.
Late, step 451The first 60 balls contain 56 red balls. Subsequent groups of 18 contain 14 red balls. Four-fifths of all balls are red. Find the red-ball count.“Try a number that makes 56 plus 14 times something equal to four-fifths of the total, where the total grows in steps of 18…”Sets up the red-ball balance equation, solves for 20 subsequent groups, and obtains 336 red balls.

The early example supplies a conditioning strategy, while the late example supplies an equation-level relation. Neither hint states the final answer, and the reasoner performs the remaining computation. These examples illustrate why useful guidance need not exclude all intermediate information. The quantitative evaluation tests whether learning remains useful after that guidance is removed.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to Reviewer yBSn (Part 2/2)

Response to W3 (dependence concentrated in a few tokens)

We examine both average and peak-token dependence on all 48 confirmation questions using a fixed Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct checkpoint. Each question has identical mathematical hint content under two usage framings, with 128 sampled responses per framing.

Hint-usage framingMean normalized reliancePeak-token dependence
Check the approach and supply justification0.0897.37
Directly reuse the provided reasoning0.1088.40

Peak-token dependence is the within-question median of the largest ordinary-token log-likelihood difference among successful responses, averaged across questions. The framing with lower mean reliance also has lower peak-token dependence on 41 of the 48 questions. Thus, the observed reduction is not restricted to the trajectory average. It is accompanied by reduced dependence at the most affected tokens.

The probability bound also accounts for trajectory length. For constant successful-trajectory length, it becomes:

p≥phexp⁡(−L0ρc(q,h)).p\ge p_h\exp(-L_0\rho_c(q,h)).

Therefore, the bound does not interpret a small per-token average independently of trajectory length. Our claim is that reliance is useful for guiding hint learning, rather than a certificate that every token is independent of the hint. Moreover, [2] studies student surprisal, whereas HiLL measures hinted-versus-unhinted likelihood differences. The empirical comparison above directly examines local dependence for the quantity used by HiLL.


Response to W6 (coupled optimization and stability)

HiLL uses separate parameters for the two policies and computes candidate rewards before updating either policy. Consequently, candidate hints within an iteration are evaluated against the same reasoner state. Figure 2 tracks the resulting signal recovery and reliance throughout training, while Appendix D.1 reports variability across independent training runs.

Appendix D.3 further tests direct parameter sharing between the two roles. Both configurations improve reasoner training accuracy, but the shared policy increasingly repeats hints and continues into full reasoning solutions. During steps 101–150, its average hinter output reaches 753 tokens, compared with 139 for the separate hinter. This experiment identifies a concrete source of role interference and supports the separate-policy design, rather than leaving the interaction between the two roles unexamined.

The suggested update-frequency and learning-rate sweeps could be useful extensions. However, W6 identifies no instability or unsupported result in our current evaluated configuration. We therefore respectfully disagree that the absence of these additional sweeps constitutes a critical weakness of our paper.


Response to W7 (dedicated thinking models)

Our model choice follows established hint-RL evaluations. SAGE evaluates the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct and Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct backbones [8], while Scaf-GRPO also evaluates Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct and Qwen2.5-series models [7], enabling direct comparisons with relevant baselines.

Importantly, our HiLL experiments already include long reasoning trajectories. Based on our training logs, the estimated median length of correct hinted trajectories increases from approximately 330 to 2,200 tokens for Llama and from 560 to 2,300 tokens for Qwen between steps 1 and 451. The late-stage 90th percentiles reach approximately 4,600 and 4,300 tokens, respectively. Our experiments therefore already examine hint reliance on extended reasoning traces, and our W3 analysis further evaluates dependence concentrated in individual tokens.

Dedicated thinking models would broaden the evaluation to another model category. While this is a useful extension, we believe our existing experiments and token-level analysis already address the concern about measuring hint dependence in lengthy reasoning.


[1] Penaloza et al. Privileged Information Distillation for Language Models. ICML 2026.

[2] Chakraborty et al. Pedagogical RL: Teaching Models to Teach Themselves from Privileged Information. Blog Post.

[3] Hübotter et al. Reinforcement Learning via Self-Distillation. ICML 2026.

[4] Zhao et al. Self-Distilled Reasoner: On-Policy Self-Distillation for Large Language Models. ICML 2026.

[5] Qu et al. POPE: Learning to Reason on Hard Problems via Privileged On-Policy Exploration. arXiv 2026.

[6] Liu et al. GHPO: Adaptive Guidance for Stable and Efficient LLM Reinforcement Learning. arXiv 2025.

[7] Zhang et al. Scaf-GRPO: Scaffolded Group Relative Policy Optimization for Enhancing LLM Reasoning. ICLR 2026.

[8] Liao et al. Self-Hinting Language Models Enhance Reinforcement Learning. arXiv 2026.

Reviewer_yBSnOpenReview ↗

Response to rebuttal by authors

Dear authors,

Thank you for your detailed response to some of my concerns. However, my key concerns were the effect of cheating and leakage with thinking models (which are most of the frontier models) and how this approach can mitigate? Also, i understand that the problem of leakage is much less severe with instruct models and hence most self-distillation methods work and non for thinking models, so the comparison is crucial. Also, using hint vs un-hinted as the reward is fine, my main concern was naive averaging which is the main concern. I will maintain my score for now

Reviewer_1ta8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

HiLL jointly trains a hinter and a reasoner to recover informative groups for all-incorrect questions. The hinter uses failed rollouts and training-only reference solutions. Its reward combines signal creation with a hint-reliance penalty based on trajectory likelihoods with and without hints. Evaluation measures the reasoner without hints.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses the important distinction between success under guidance and learning that transfers to no-hint inference. Same-initialization and approximately matched-compute comparisons, two training runs, and bootstrap analysis make the empirical support more convincing.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Proposition 1 is a relation between success probabilities at fixed policy parameters, rather than a guarantee of no-hint improvement after an update. The practical hinter reward also omits length terms appearing in the bound. The relation between the theorem, the heuristic reward, and actual learning transfer should be stated more narrowly (pp. 5, 13–14).
  2. Transfer weighting produces shorter hints, leaving simpler length or information-content regularization as alternative explanations. Length- and information-matched controls would better isolate hint reliance. Statistical claims also need qualification: the question-pooled interval is positive, while the benchmark-macro interval narrowly includes zero (pp. 9, 16–17).
Questions for authors
  1. Does hint reliance predict subsequent no-hint improvement when hinted success rate and hint length/information content are controlled?
  2. How does transfer weighting compare with a simple hint-length penalty, and how tight is the transfer bound on the observed trajectory-length distributions?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to Reviewer 1ta8

Thank you for your review and for recognizing the importance of no-hint transfer, as well as our same-initialization, compute-matched, and statistical comparisons. We provide the following clarifications and additional results.


Response to W1 (theoretical guarantee and practical reward)

In our paper, Proposition 1 explicitly considers fixed reasoner parameters, and Section 4.4 introduces the reward as motivated by the transfer bound. The proposition characterizes hinted and no-hint success, while the training benefit of the objective is evaluated empirically.

The theorem also directly analyzes the normalized reliance used in training. Eq. 5 defines its population expectation:

ρc(q,h)=Eτ∼Qh[ρ(τ;q,h)∣τ∣](Eq. 5)\rho_c(q,h)=\mathbb{E}_{\tau\sim Q_h}\left[\frac{\rho(\tau;q,h)}{|\tau|}\right]\qquad\text{(Eq. 5)}

and Eq. 8 estimates the same quantity:

ρ^c(q,h)=1∣C∣∑τ∈Cρ(τ;q,h)∣τ∣(Eq. 8)\hat\rho_c(q,h)=\frac{1}{|C|}\sum_{\tau\in C}\frac{\rho(\tau;q,h)}{|\tau|}\qquad\text{(Eq. 8)}

Thus, length normalization is present in both the analysis and the practical estimator. The additional harmonic-length and dispersion factors characterize the probability bound, while the reward combines normalized reliance with signal creation. This distinction is already reflected in our formulation, rather than a claim that Eq. 9 directly maximizes every factor in Eq. 7.


Response to W2 and Q2 (hint-length regularization)

We conduct an additional 500-step experiment replacing transfer weighting with a direct hint-length penalty:

Rlength(q,h)=s(p^h;G)exp⁡(−λ∣h∣).R_{\mathrm{length}}(q,h)=s(\hat p_h;G)\exp(-\lambda |h|).

We calibrate λ\lambda on pilot hints to match the typical scale of HiLL's reliance penalty. This reward is used for both hinter training and candidate selection, retaining the same candidate-generation, validation, and reasoner-update procedures. Both policies are initialized from Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct.

MethodAIME24AIME25AMC23MATH-500MinervaOlympiadGPQAMMLU-ProAvg.
HiLL w/o TW8.230.9430.4754.4320.2820.7125.0239.4224.94
Length penalty7.711.8830.4753.0020.3621.2725.8839.6225.02
HiLL11.041.6735.1656.0921.3322.6628.1841.0227.14

Results are Average@16 accuracies (%) after 500 training steps.

HiLL improves over the length-penalty baseline, supporting the benefit of transfer-aware hint learning beyond the tested length regularizer.


Response to W2 (statistical interpretation)

Appendix D.1 already reports both the positive question-pooled confidence interval and the benchmark-macro interval that includes zero for matched-compute experimental results. Our claims concern higher observed average performance, not significance on every benchmark or aggregate. We will make this existing qualification more visible.


Response to Q1 (hint reliance and subsequent no-hint improvement)

We conduct a controlled study on eight questions with paired hints containing identical mathematical content and comparable lengths. We vary the usage instruction, independently confirm the reliance difference, and screen pairs for comparable hinted success rates before training.

Each condition starts from the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct model and receives eight matched GRPO updates. We evaluate 64 fresh responses per updated question without hints.

Training conditionNo-hint accuracy improvement (percentage points)
Lower-reliance framing+4.10
Higher-reliance framing+2.54
No-hint training+1.95

The lower-reliance framing yields greater observed improvement after hint removal despite identical mathematical guidance. This provides empirical support for the requested connection, complementing the full-training transfer-weighting ablations.


Response to Q2 (empirical transfer bound)

Appendix A derives the bound first with the exact inverse-length correction and then with the explicit dispersion correction:

Bexact=phexp⁡(−ℓHρc−ΔL),Bdisp=ph1+c1/L 2exp⁡(−ℓHρc).B_{\mathrm{exact}}=p_h\exp(-\ell_{\mathrm H}\rho_c-\Delta_L),\qquad B_{\mathrm{disp}}=\frac{p_h}{1+c_{1/L}^{\,2}}\exp(-\ell_{\mathrm H}\rho_c).

We quantify the additional slack introduced by the second step:

BdispBexact=exp⁡(ΔL)1+c1/L 2.\frac{B_{\mathrm{disp}}}{B_{\mathrm{exact}}}=\frac{\exp(\Delta_L)}{1+c_{1/L}^{\,2}}.

Across 44 diagnostic question–hint pairs at a fixed length-penalty reasoner checkpoint, the explicit bound retains a median 93.6% of the exact-correction bound estimate, with the middle 50% ranging from 89.5% to 96.1%. This shows that the explicit length-dispersion relaxation introduces modest additional slack. The full probability bound remains conservative in this diagnostic because the derivation also drops the KL term between successful-trajectory distributions.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Kind Reminder to Reviewer 1ta8

Dear Reviewer 1ta8,

As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would like to follow up on our rebuttal, where we provided:

  • Clarification of our theoretical transfer bound and the practical objective.
  • The requested hint-length penalty baseline comparison.
  • A controlled study of subsequent no-hint improvement.
  • The requested analysis of bound tightness.

We would appreciate it if you could let us know whether they have addressed your concerns.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Best,
Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.