- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies RLVR for difficult reasoning problems. When all rollouts in a GRPO group are incorrect, the group has zero relative advantage and provides no learning signal. The paper proposes HiLL method, which trains a separate hinter to generate hints for these groups. The hinter conditions on the question, an incorrect rollout, and a reference solution available only during training. Candidate hints are scored by both their ability to create mixed outcomes and their reliance. The selected hints are used to update the reasoner, while the hinter is trained with GRPO. Experiments show that HiLL improves over GRPO and several hint based baselines. In addition, ablations suggest that transfer weighting reduces hint reliance and improves no hint performance.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies an important distinction between creating a GRPO learning signal and transferring that signal to the no-hint policy.
- The transfer weighted reward is a reasonable way to combine these two goals.
Critical weaknesses
- It is unclear why the proposed hinting pipeline is preferable to direct process supervision or other ways of using the same reference solutions.
- The main transfer criterion is indirect. Lower hint reliance does not necessarily imply better learning after the reasoner update. The paper does not provide enough evidence that this metric is a reliable measure of future no-hint improvement.
Questions for authors
- What is the benefit of using a separate learned hinter instead of direct process supervision, fixed teacher hints, or self generated hints under the same compute and supervision budget?
- Does hint reliance predict improvement in the no hint policy after training?
- How sensitive is HiLL to the quality of the training-only reference solutions? Does it still work with incomplete or noisy reference solutions?
4 comments
Thank you for the clarifications and the additional controlled update analysis, which address several of my concerns. Could you clarify how the eight questions and paired hints were selected, and whether this selection was completed before observing the subsequent no hint improvements?
Follow-Up Reply to Reviewer rA25
Thank you for your reply and for acknowledging that our rebuttal addressed several of your concerns.
Regarding your follow-up question, yes, the eight questions and paired hints were selected before any training updates or subsequent no-hint evaluations.
We first selected math questions of moderate difficulty and constructed reference-derived hints. For each question, we kept the content of the mathematical guidance fixed while varying its framing, either encouraging the reasoner to derive the key result independently or to directly reuse the provided intermediate steps. We then measured hint reliance using 128 fresh responses per framing from the initial reasoner and selected pairs with a verified reliance difference (at least 0.02, with the lower bound of the 95% bootstrap confidence interval above zero), while requiring comparable hinted success rates, hint lengths, and response lengths.
Among 48 candidate questions, 14 satisfied these predefined criteria. We selected the first eight qualifying pairs in a fixed shuffled order to form one training batch. Therefore, selection was based entirely on pre-update measurements, without observing or using subsequent no-hint improvements. We hope this clarification addresses your remaining concern.
Kind Reminder to Reviewer rA25
Dear Reviewer rA25,
As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would like to follow up on whether our further clarifications have addressed your remaining question. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Best,
Authors
Reply to Reviewer rA25
Thank you for your review and for recognizing the distinction between creating a GRPO learning signal and transferring it to no-hint reasoning. We clarify the existing budget comparisons and provide an additional analysis of subsequent learning.
Response to W1 and Q1 (benefit of a separate learned hinter)
Our paper already compares HiLL with teacher-generated scaffolds through Scaf-GRPO [2] and self-generated hints through SAGE [1]. HiLL achieves higher average no-hint performance on both reasoner backbones (Table 1). The key difference is learning what hint to generate for the reasoner's current failure. Scaf-GRPO uses teacher-generated scaffolds at predefined levels, while SAGE periodically refreshes self-generated hints and adapts their strength. HiLL instead trains a separate hinter conditioned on the reasoner's failed rollout, using the resulting mixed-outcome signal and hint reliance to optimize the generated guidance.
To control for model initialization and training cost, Table 2 of our paper further compares HiLL and SAGE under the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct initialization and training configuration, alongside compute-matched GRPO:
All methods use 500 training steps, with time measured relative to GRPO (G=8). HiLL outperforms SAGE at comparable cost and GRPO at matched compute, supporting the benefit of learning failure-conditioned, transfer-aware hints rather than simply using additional rollouts or self-generated guidance.
The separate-policy design is also supported by Appendix D.3, where direct parameter sharing causes interference in hint generation, including increasingly long hints and continuations into full solutions. The HiLL w/o TW ablation further isolates the benefit of the transfer-aware reward within the same learned-hinter framework.
Finally, unlike direct process supervision, HiLL uses reference solutions to guide exploration rather than as imitation targets. The reasoner learns from its own rollouts using verifiable correctness rewards, without requiring costly step-level supervision. This allows the hinter to learn useful guidance while preserving the reasoner's on-policy RLVR objective.
Response to W2 and Q2 (hint reliance and subsequent no-hint improvement)
We directly examine this connection through controlled reasoner updates, in addition to the full-training transfer-weighting ablation.
For eight questions, we construct paired hints with identical mathematical content and comparable lengths. We vary the usage instruction, independently confirm the reliance difference, and screen pairs for comparable hinted success rates. Each condition starts from the same Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct model and receives eight matched GRPO updates. We then evaluate 64 fresh responses per updated question without hints.
Lower-reliance guidance yields greater observed no-hint improvement despite identical mathematical information. This directly connects differences in measured reliance to subsequent learning after hint removal, complementing the end-to-end evidence from the transfer-weighting ablation.
Response to Q3 (reference-solution quality)
HiLL follows the reference-guided RLVR setting used by SAGE [1] and Scaf-GRPO [2]. Unlike direct imitation, reference solutions are used only to condition the hinter, while the reasoner learns from its own rollouts with correctness independently verified against ground-truth answers. Candidate hints must produce informative mixed-outcome groups to receive positive rewards. We therefore expect HiLL to be less sensitive to imperfect references than methods that directly imitate reference trajectories. We leave systematic evaluation with incomplete or noisy references as a future extension.
[1] Liao et al. Self-Hinting Language Models Enhance Reinforcement Learning. arXiv 2026.
[2] Zhang et al. Scaf-GRPO: Scaffolded Group Relative Policy Optimization for Enhancing LLM Reasoning. ICLR 2026.