- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces ForesightNav, a long-horizon planning framework for multi-object navigation. The method integrates an online semantic 3DGS map, persistent candidate maintenance (PCQ), and belief-aware long-horizon planning (BLP), enabling the selection of current target instances while accounting for subsequent navigation costs. Experiments on HM3D-MON report improved performance, particularly for longer goal sequences. Additional results on GOAT-Bench show that persistent candidate maintenance without BLP achieves higher success rates than the compared non-privileged methods.
Critical strengths
-
The paper considers how selecting the current target instance affects the navigation cost of subsequent goals, which is important for long-horizon multi-object navigation.
-
ForesightNav achieves better results on 3-MON and 4-MON than the compared methods. The ablation studies and stage-wise success analysis also suggest that PCQ and BLP are beneficial, especially in later navigation stages.
Critical weaknesses
-
PCQ shares some similarities with existing methods such as LagMemo. Although the ablation study shows improvements from PCQ and BLP, the differences from existing approaches could be explained in more detail.
-
ForesightNav outperforms ApexNAV on 3-MON and 4-MON, but the gains are relatively small, while it performs worse on 2-MON. The lack of variance or confidence intervals makes it difficult to assess the reliability of these improvements.
Questions for authors
-
How often does BLP select a different target instance from a greedy strategy, and how do these choices affect navigation performance?
-
Do the compared methods have access to the same goal information in HM3D-MON? Could the authors also report the number of evaluation episodes and the variance or confidence intervals of the results?