- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EGNav addresses the ambiguity of failed observations in zero-shot goal-oriented navigation by maintaining a task-conditioned memory of direct, contextual, and negative evidence. It uses visibility-aware belief updates and a unified policy to balance memory revisitation against frontier exploration. Experiments demonstrate improvements over several zero-shot baselines, with ablations supporting the complementarity of direct and contextual repair.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies a meaningful failure mode in zero-shot navigation.
-
The framework is reasonable.
-
Experiments across multiple navigation tasks and benchmarks show consistent improvements.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty appears incremental. Revisiting previously explored locations is not a new concept in embodied navigation, as prior methods such as 3D-Mem already leverage stored scene memories to guide subsequent exploration. Although EGNav explicitly frames revisitation as evidence repair and introduces visibility-aware evidence updates, the paper does not sufficiently establish that this formulation constitutes a substantial advance over existing memory-guided exploration and verification mechanisms.
-
The ablations do not fully establish the value of the proposed evidence-management mechanism. EGNav lacks a direct comparison with a simpler revisitation baseline that retains memory-guided revisits but removes accumulated evidence modeling and information-gain-based ranking. Such a comparison is necessary to determine whether the gains stem from the proposed evidence-management mechanism or primarily from enabling revisitation.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses. I'm willing to raise my score if the concerns are adressed.
4 comments
Follow-up Regarding Our Rebuttal for Submission #24757
Dear Reviewer av5r,
We hope you are doing well. Thank you again for your thoughtful comments and helpful suggestions.
We have posted a detailed response to your concerns. In particular, we clarified the methodological contributions beyond memory-guided revisitation and added a controlled comparison with a nearest-first revisitation baseline to isolate the benefits of evidence management. The additional results have been incorporated into the revised manuscript.
We would welcome your thoughts on whether these explanations and experiments adequately address your concerns. We remain happy to answer any further questions during the author–reviewer discussion period !
Best regards,
The Authors of Submission #24757
Response by Reviewer av5r
The rebuttal has clarified the intended contribution of EGNav as an integrated evidence-management framework for zero-shot goal-oriented navigation. The additional experiments convincingly demonstrate that this framework provides benefits beyond simple memory-guided revisitation. However, the contribution appears to lie primarily in the task-specific integration of existing concepts, including spatial memory, visibility-aware evidence accumulation, belief estimation, and information-gain-based candidate selection. This integration is useful and addresses a meaningful practical problem. But I still think the methodological novelty beyond the proposed system-level framework remains relatively modest.
However, I appreciate the effort and will raise my overall rating.
Thank You for the Updated Assessment
Dear Reviewer av5r,
Thank you very much for your thoughtful reassessment and for raising your overall rating ! We sincerely appreciate the time and care you have devoted to reviewing our work and considering the additional experiments and clarifications. Your constructive feedback has been valuable in helping us strengthen the paper and better articulate its contributions.
Best regards,
The Authors of Submission #24757
Rebuttal for Reviewer av5r
W1. Methodological Novelty Beyond Memory-guided Revisitation
We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment! We would like to clarify that EGNav differs from 3D-Mem in how stored spatial memories are represented, updated, and utilized for goal-oriented navigation. EGNav builds upon the memory-guided exploration paradigm by introducing an explicit evidence-management framework to address the ambiguity of failed observations under partial observability. Specifically, EGNav introduces three complementary designs:
1.Task-conditioned evidence memory: We maintain direct, contextual, and negative evidence associated with stored spatial candidates, enabling the agent to distinguish between observed targets, contextually supported hypotheses, and insufficiently verified locations.
2.Visibility-aware belief updates: We accumulate positive and negative evidence according to observation reliability, preventing missed detections under limited visibility from prematurely excluding potential targets.
3.Unified memory-repair policy: We jointly consider accumulated belief, expected information gain, and navigation costs to determine whether to revisit uncertain candidates or explore new frontiers.
Together, these designs enable EGNav to more effectively utilize stored 3D memories by reasoning about whether a candidate has been sufficiently verified, rather than simply whether its location has been explored. The key contribution therefore lies in managing and repairing uncertain goal evidence through a unified navigation policy. Furthermore, our existing comparison with 3D-Mem on GOAT-Bench Val-Unseen (Table 2) shows that EGNav improves SR/SPL from 28.8/15.8 to 39.1/23.7, providing additional empirical evidence of the effectiveness of our framework. We also introduce two additional controlled experiments in the following response to further demonstrate that the improvements arise from our evidence-management mechanisms rather than memory revisitation alone.
Q2. Contribution of Evidence Management Beyond Revisitation
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion! To directly distinguish the benefits of simple memory revisitation from our proposed evidence-management mechanisms, we introduce an additional baseline, Memory + Nearest-first Revisit. This baseline just revisits the nearest eligible memory candidate without accumulated evidence modeling or information-gain-based ranking. Unsuccessfully revisited candidates are temporarily excluded until new relevant observations become available, and frontier exploration resumes when no eligible candidates remain. We compare this new baseline with EGNav and the existing component ablations from our original manuscript, including variants without visibility weighting or information gain.
As shown above, simple memory revisitation improves SR/SPL from 58.8/22.5 to 60.4/23.1, confirming the benefit of revisiting stored candidates. EGNav further improves SR by 2.4 points and SPL by 2.0 points over this baseline, demonstrating that its improvements cannot be attributed solely to memory revisitation. Furthermore, our existing ablation results provide additional evidence for the proposed mechanisms. Removing visibility weighting reduces SR/SPL to 61.5/23.8, while removing information gain reduces them to 61.1/23.2, despite retaining memory revisitation. Together, these results demonstrate that EGNav benefits not only from revisiting stored candidates, but also from visibility-aware evidence updating and information-gain-based candidate selection.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their valuable suggestions. We have incorporated the new results into the revised manuscript and would be happy to address any further questions and continue the discussion!