- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DiG-Nav learns soft weights over the remaining goal categories and uses their weighted representation to condition a continuous-action policy. Training combines PPO with an auxiliary value objective from short latent rollouts. At deployment, the actor generates actions directly. The paper reports results on Gibson, Matterport3D, and Flightmare, together with real quadrotor demonstrations.
Critical strengths
+Learning goal priorities together with actions is a sensible approach to unordered multi-object navigation. +The method achieves higher mean episode success than the strongest compared baseline by 3.1, 5.3, and 4.2 percentage points across the three simulation settings. The MP3D ablations also support the usefulness of learned allocation and the imagined-value objective.
Critical weaknesses
-The allocation objective needs a clearer justification. In Eq. (8), shifting weights toward a high-value goal can increase the score even if the imagined trajectory stays unchanged. Summing future values can also count the same confirmation reward several times. I understand that this is an auxiliary objective, but its connection to completing all goals remains unclear. The ablations show that it helps performance, without separating the benefit of better actions from the effect of reweighting predicted values. -The policy has no explicit memory of past observations or explored areas. The completion mask records confirmed goals, but cannot retain the location of a goal seen earlier and not yet confirmed. Different exploration histories can therefore produce the same input but require different decisions. This is a substantial limitation for partially observed multi-object navigation, and its practical impact is not evaluated. -The baseline adaptations and evaluation settings lack important details. PONI needs a category-selection module, while EGO-Planner and FUEL need semantic search and goal ordering. Appendix E.3 describes their roles but does not explain how these modules were implemented and trained. Scene splits, episode budgets, and the actual reward and auxiliary-loss coefficients are also missing. These details matter for assessing and reproducing the comparisons.
Questions for authors
- Can you test a variant where the imagined-value objective does not update the allocation scorer, while PPO still trains it and the remaining training setup stays unchanged? This would help isolate the contribution of this gradient.
- Please explain how the baselines were adapted to multi-goal navigation, especially their category-selection and goal-ordering modules. Please also provide the scene splits, evaluation episode counts, episode budgets, and reward and auxiliary-loss coefficients.
Thank you for the additional experiments. The both-route detachment control directly addresses my request: the reported ESR difference of 67.1% versus 63.7% supports a contribution from imagined-value updates to allocation. The occlusion probe also quantifies the practical impact of the memory limitation. These results address substantial parts of my review.
My main remaining concern is the baseline comparison. The response explains the roles of PONI, EGO-Planner, and FUEL, but the actual category-selection and goal-ordering rules, training sources, scene splits, episode counts and budgets, and reward/loss coefficients remain unspecified. These details are needed to assess whether the compared systems were configured appropriately.
I also note from the response to Reviewer kGYY that the hard selector performs close to the full method: ESR is 66.3% versus 67.1%, while mSPL is 58.9% versus 58.8%. This limits the evidence for a clear advantage of soft differentiable allocation over hard selection. Uncertainty estimates for the new controls would help interpret these differences.
The rebuttal strengthens the empirical support, but the comparison details remain important to my assessment. I will keep my score unchanged for now.