- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies 2D CAD drawing completion, where the goal is to infer missing primitives and their attributes from an existing sketch with geometric constraints. The authors construct a 200K-sketch instruction-prompt dataset from SketchGraphs, encode sketches as text sequences, and fine-tune LLMs with instruction prompts in a two-stage pipeline: first predicting the missing primitive type, then generating its attributes such as coordinates or radius. They also introduce an uncertainty-aware module based on adversarial perturbations and confidence features to estimate prediction reliability. Experiments show strong primitive classification, more limited but meaningful attribute prediction, and improved reliability estimation over several confidence baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a useful problem: applying LLMs to 2D CAD drawing completion. Representing CAD sketches as text sequences and fine-tuning LLMs with instruction prompts is a relevant direction for connecting structured CAD data with language-model reasoning.
- The uncertainty-aware component is a valuable addition. In CAD applications, it is not enough to generate a completion. The system should also estimate whether the prediction is reliable. The paper’s use of adversarial perturbations and confidence features for reliability estimation is interesting and meaningful for building more reliable CAD assistance systems.
Critical weaknesses
- The CAD completion results are not fully convincing. Primitive-type classification is strong, but attribute prediction is much weaker, especially at the sketch level. Since usable CAD completion depends on accurate attributes, this limits the strength of the paper’s main claim.
- The experimental validation does not fully support the broader claim about LLM reasoning for CAD. The main comparisons are mostly with generic graph-learning baselines, rather than methods more directly designed for CAD sketch completion, parametric sketch inference, or CAD generation. As a result, it is unclear whether the proposed LLM-based formulation is stronger than existing CAD-focused approaches.
Questions for authors
- The main comparisons are mostly with generic graph-learning baselines for primitive classification. Could the authors clarify why more directly related CAD sketch completion, parametric sketch inference, or CAD generation methods are not included as main baselines?
- How is the train/test split constructed from SketchGraphs? In particular, is there any check for near-duplicate sketches or highly similar templates across the split? This is important for assessing whether the reported performance reflects generalization rather than memorization of common sketch patterns.