acceptodds
Desk rejected at ICLR 2027

Error Self-Compensation Phase Retrieval for Binary Fringe Projection Profilometry

Desk rejected at ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Error-diffusion-based binary-defocusing fringe projection enables high-speed 3D measurement, but systematic phase errors introduced during binarization can degrade reconstruction accuracy. To address this problem, we propose EDFv2, a unified Error Diffusion Fusion framework for arbitrary-step phase-shifting fringe projection. EDFv2 exploits the complementary phase errors generated by forward and inverse diffusion kernels and redesigns the binarization process according to the phase-shifting configuration. For three-step phase shifting, each fringe is binarized twice with complementary kernels to achieve effective error cancellation. For phase-shifting schemes with more steps, the binarization flow is reorganized to preserve the same compensation mechanism for both even- and odd-step configurations. Since the proposed strategy operates only during binary-pattern generation, it introduces no additional computational overhead during phase reconstruction. Experiments under different phase-shifting steps, fringe periods, and defocus levels demonstrate that EDFv2 consistently reduces binarization-induced phase errors while retaining the high-speed advantage of binary projection.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Binary Defocusing, Phase-Shifting Profilometry, Error Compensation, Complementary Diffusion, High-Speed 3D Measurement

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_of87OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an Error Self-Compensation (ESC) framework to resolve the inevitable phase bias caused by the pattern binarization process in binary fringe projection profilometry (FPP).

Existing correction methods were limited as they required additional pattern projections or relied on empirical post-processing.

The authors mathematically analyzed that the forward and reverse Floyd-Steinberg (FS) error diffusion processes induce symmetrical phase biases.

Based on this, by introducing reverse-diffused fringes, they resolved the rank deficiency of the linear system caused by binarization error terms, successfully recovering an unbiased wrapped phase without additional projections or post-processing.

This framework is applicable to phase-shifting schemes exceeding three steps, and a double-binarization strategy is adopted to compensate for errors in the under-constrained three-step phase-shifting case.

Experimental results show the proposed ESC method reduced the point cloud MAE and RMSE by up to 84.8% and 80.3%, respectively.

Critical strengths

There is no measurement time delay or computational overhead, as it does not require additional pattern projections or complex post-processing to suppress phase errors.

Experiments on various object surface geometries demonstrated overwhelming reconstruction accuracy, reducing the point cloud MAE by up to 84.8% and RMSE by up to 80.3% compared to the existing FS method.

It proved robustness by maintaining continuous and stable reconstruction performance without phase jumps even under varying projector defocus levels and in dynamic measurement environments with rotating objects.

The numerical stability of the two possible mathematical phase recovery solutions (ESC and ESC') was carefully analyzed, successfully eliminating the unstable solution that amplifies noise due to a small denominator and identifying the practically stable solution.

Critical weaknesses

Since the proposed compensation framework relies entirely on the 'forward-reverse symmetry' of the phase bias inherent to a specific diffusion kernel (Floyd-Steinberg), it is not verified whether this symmetry and compensation principle hold true for other types of error diffusion kernels.

Although ESC effectively cancels the primary phase bias caused by binarization, residual errors stemming from non-ideal binarization effects or higher-order errors still exist, leaving room for further improvement in compensation accuracy.

Questions for authors

If computational constraints in specific hardware require the use of an error diffusion kernel other than the FS kernel (e.g., Sierra-Lite), how can the current ESC framework be expanded or modified by analyzing the bias characteristics of that kernel?

Since the mathematically stable ESC formula was adopted through numerical stability analysis, are there extreme conditions where side effects (e.g., noise amplification) could still occur even in the stable ESC solution, such as when measuring objects with extremely fine, high-frequency geometric structures?

While the mathematical proof provides a near-perfect closed-form solution, the empirical verification through data has its limitations for the following reasons: First, the validation is entirely dependent on the Floyd-Steinberg (FS) diffusion kernel environment, leaving it unverified whether this compensation principle holds true for other kernels. Second, in real-world measurements, non-ideal binarization effects and higher-order sensor errors inevitably intervene, resulting in residual physical noise that is not completely canceled out. Lastly, the experiments were conducted in strictly controlled laboratory settings, which may not fully represent extreme real-world edge cases.

Reviewer_ceNZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Error Self-Compensation (ESC) for reducing binarization-induced phase errors in binary fringe projection profilometry. Unlike prior methods that improve binary patterns or compensate phase errors through additional projection, calibration, or post-processing, ESC exploits the opposite phase biases of forward and reverse Floyd–Steinberg error diffusion to cancel errors during phase retrieval. Experiments show substantially improved 3D reconstruction accuracy without additional projected patterns or post-processing.

Critical strengths

The paper presents a simple and effective approach to reducing binarization-induced phase errors in binary fringe projection profilometry. Its key strength is exploiting the complementary phase biases of forward and reverse Floyd–Steinberg error diffusion to improve reconstruction accuracy without additional projections or post-processing. The method is theoretically motivated, supports both multi-step and three-step phase shifting, and is validated across different defocus conditions and object geometries with consistent improvements over existing methods.

Critical weaknesses

The experimental evaluation does not clearly report or systematically vary the depth range of the measured objects. Although several object geometries are evaluated, it remains unclear whether the method maintains its accuracy for general 3D objects with substantially larger depth variations.

Figure 1 provides little additional insight, as it illustrates a well-known motion-induced error in fringe projection profilometry rather than the specific problem or key idea addressed by the proposed method

The relevance of this work to ICLR is somewhat unclear. The paper primarily focuses on a specialized 3D reconstruction problem in fringe projection profilometry and proposes a signal-processing-based phase compensation technique, with limited connection to machine learning or representation learning. The work may therefore be more naturally aligned with specialized 3D vision or computer vision venues such as 3DV.

Questions for authors

.

Reviewer_3ScgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses systematic phase bias introduced by Floyd–Steinberg (FS) error diffusion in binary-defocusing fringe projection profilometry. It proposes error self-compensation (ESC), which combines forward- and reverse-diffused patterns within a phase-shifting sequence to cancel the bias under an equal-and-opposite error model. The paper develops a five-step formulation, describes extensions to other step numbers, introduces double binarization for three-step acquisition, and compares the stability of two phase solutions

Critical strengths

The method offers a practical improvement with limited changes to the measurement pipeline. ESC changes the binarization direction of selected patterns and uses fixed linear combinations during phase recovery, without increasing the corresponding phase-shift pattern count. This makes it potentially attractive for existing high-speed measurement systems where additional acquisition or iterative correction would be costly.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The substantial contribution beyond the closest prior work Chen et al. (2026) is insufficiently established. The submission acknowledges the four-step relationship, but does not clearly establish the significance of its remaining contributions: general-step derivation, elaboration of double binarization, and stability analysis. The absence of a direct EDF comparison accounting for acquisition cost further weakens the evidence for a substantial advance.

  2. The simulation evaluation is too limited to establish the method’s operating range. The existing simulations examine bias symmetry and illustrate the stability of the two phase solutions, but do not provide a systematic quantitative evaluation across diverse conditions. A broader simulation study should vary defocus, fringe period, image noise, surface reflectance, and ambient illumination, with comparisons against strong baselines. Such controlled experiments are important for identifying when ESC provides substantial benefits, how sensitive it is to model mismatch, and where compensation breaks down.

Questions for authors
  1. Clarification of novelty: Which specific results go beyond Chen et al.’s EDF, including its proposed three-step double-binarization extension? What evidence establishes the practical value of the general-step formulation relative to EDF when acquisition cost is considered?

  2. Validation of robustness: Can you provide controlled ablation or sensitivity experiments that independently vary object surface reflectance and ambient illumination while holding geometry and acquisition settings fixed? Reporting phase and reconstruction errors, together with fringe modulation or signal-to-noise ratio, would help establish whether ESC’s advantages persist under changes in these conditions.

  3. Clarification of experimental conditions: How are “slight,” “moderate,” and “strong” defocus in Section 5.2 quantitatively defined and calibrated? Please report a measurable characterization, such as the estimated point-spread-function width or an equivalent calibrated blur metric, together with the procedure used to obtain it. Qualitative Gray-code edge images alone make these conditions difficult to reproduce and compare.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.