- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the coexistence of flicker-banding and moiré artifacts in screen-captured images, examines their joint removal, and proposes a unified restoration framework, CLEAR. The authors construct MIRAGE, a dataset containing 3,000 pairs of real captured images covering three degradation categories: flicker-banding only, moiré only, and compound degradations. Built on the PiSA-SR backbone, the method combines ISP-based RAW-domain banding simulation, a frequency-domain segmentation and weighted recomposition module (FS), and a multi-level wavelet loss (MWL). The experimental results show that CLEAR outperforms the compared methods on all six metrics. Comparisons with cascaded single-task models and component ablations further support the need for joint processing and the effectiveness of the individual components.
Critical strengths
- A practically relevant problem formulation and dataset contribution. The coexistence of moiré and flicker-banding is an important restoration scenario in screen photography. The paper compares cascaded single-task models in both processing orders, providing direct evidence for the need for joint processing. MIRAGE covers three degradation categories, six content categories, and five smartphones, giving the work value as a dataset contribution in addition to the proposed model.
- Targeted modeling of compound degradations and innovative component designs are well supported by ablation results. I find CLEAR’s technical contributions worthy of recognition. ISP-based RAW-domain banding simulation incorporates considerations of the imaging process into the method design. FS uses cumulative spectral-energy quantiles to determine segment boundaries, constructs frequency bands with smooth Butterworth masks, and combines task priors with spectral statistics to initialize recomposition weights. MWL constrains residual artifacts in the output through multi-scale, orientation-sensitive subband supervision, complementing frequency-domain processing of the input. The design and complementary roles of these components constitute a meaningful methodological contribution to joint banding and moiré removal.
Critical weaknesses
- The parameter definitions and configuration of the core method are incomplete. FS is one of the paper’s main technical contributions, yet the paper does not explain the choice of six frequency segments, specify the data over which the spectral statistics are computed, or clarify whether the segment boundaries and recomposition weights are fixed, computed per image, or trainable. A weight initialization formula alone does not specify how the module actually operates. The description of MWL also omits the decomposition depth used in training, the subband weights, and the weighting relative to the other loss terms. A four-level decomposition visualization is not a substitute for the training configuration.
- The evaluation of practical applicability is incomplete. The paper does not report inference time, peak GPU memory usage, or the strategy for processing high-resolution images, nor does it analyze representative failure cases. Consequently, the reported results are insufficient to assess the method’s deployment costs and reliability on challenging inputs.
Questions for authors
- FS parameter determination: Why are six frequency segments used? Are the spectral statistics used to determine the boundaries computed over the entire training set or for each input? After initialization, are the segment boundaries and recomposition weights fixed, recomputed per image, or optimized during training? Please specify the actual procedure, key parameter values, and the rationale for their selection; the current description is insufficient to reproduce the module.
- MWL training configuration: How many wavelet decomposition levels are used during training? What are the weights of the LL, LH, HL, and HH subbands, and the relative weights of MWL, pixel loss, and perceptual loss? How were these values determined? The paper provides only the loss formulation and decomposition visualization, without the complete configuration needed to specify the actual training objective.
- Deployment costs: What are CLEAR’s per-image inference time and peak GPU memory usage under specified hardware, input resolution, and batch size? Are original high-resolution photographs processed as complete images or in tiles? The paper emphasizes practical applicability but does not report the corresponding resource requirements. Please provide these measurements and the inference strategy actually used.
- Failure cases and operating limits: What are CLEAR’s main failure modes? Please provide representative failure cases, analyze whether residual banding, moiré, or detail loss occurs, and identify the method’s operating limits.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer PMM8 (Part 2)
Q3-3: Inference time, peak GPU memory, and the high-resolution inference strategy.
A3-3:
Thank you for asking us to clarify the deployment costs and high-resolution inference strategy. (1) Test setup and resource requirements. We evaluate CLEAR on an RTX 4090 48GB using FP16 and batch size 1. For a complete image at 4096 × 3072, inference takes 173.18 s and uses 46.83 GiB of GPU memory. Table 9 also reports the parameter count and FLOPs. (2) High-resolution inference. To process images at their native resolution, we use tiled inference in latent space. This follows the same strategy used in diffusion-based image restoration methods such as OSEDiff [2]. We process overlapping 64 × 64 latent tiles with an overlap of 32 latent pixels. We then combine the predictions using Gaussian weights in the overlapping regions to reduce tile-boundary artifacts and reconstruct the full-resolution image. The reported runtime and memory usage correspond to this tiled inference setup. Appendix A.4 provides the settings and resource measurements.
Table 9. CLEAR complexity and inference efficiency at 4096 × 3072 on RTX 4090 48GB.
| Model | Params (M) | FLOPs (T) | Time (s) | GPU (GiB) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CLEAR | 1292.00 | 478.98 | 173.18 | 46.83 |
[2] Rongyuan Wu, Lingchen Sun, Zhiyuan Ma, and Lei Zhang. One-Step Effective Diffusion Network for Real-World Image Super-Resolution. In NeurIPS, 2024.
Q3-4: Representative failure cases, residual artifacts, detail loss, and operating limits.
A3-4:
Thank you for asking about failure cases and the limits of our method. (1) Observed errors. Appendix A.9 and Figure 13 show two examples under severe banding. The first retains band boundaries on the road, while the second has blurred details. (2) Causes and limitations. These examples illustrate two limitations. First, extremely dark bands can erase visible scene structures, leaving too little information for accurate correction and causing residual banding. Second, under poor capture conditions, severe banding and moiré may coexist with blur and other degradations. Even after the target artifacts are removed, these other degradations can leave the output quality low. Recovering blurred details is beyond the scope of this paper, which focuses on banding and moiré removal. We nevertheless recognize these outputs as practical failure cases and will explore how to address such additional degradations in future work.
Call for further discussion with Reviewer PMM8
Dear Reviewer PMM8,
Thank you for your time and thoughtful feedback. In our rebuttal, we have provided the following details and evidence in response to your concerns:
- FS configuration and design rationale, including spectral statistics, frequency boundaries, recomposition weights, and the choice of six bands.
- The complete MWL training configuration, including decomposition depth, subband weights, loss weights, and the rationale for these choices.
- Inference costs and high-resolution processing details, including runtime, GPU memory usage, and the tiled inference strategy.
- Representative failure cases and limitations, with an analysis of residual artifacts and detail loss.
As we approach the midpoint of the rebuttal discussion period, we would appreciate your feedback on whether these responses address your concerns. If you have any remaining questions or suggestions, we would welcome the opportunity to discuss them.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
Authors
Response to Reviewer PMM8 (Part 1)
Q3-1: FS configuration, spectral statistics, parameter updates, and the choice of six frequency segments.
A3-1:
Thank you for asking us to clarify the FS settings. (1) Statistics and boundaries. We average smoothed grayscale log-power profiles across the training dataset. After reducing the DC peak, we apply radial compensation. We then divide the cumulative energy into six equal parts to set the band boundaries. (2) Weights and updates. We first compute the energy of each frequency band using the same training images. We apply log(1 + E) to each energy value E, then use min-max normalization to obtain normalized energies. We multiply these by the negative energy scale, apply the exponential function, and divide by the sum across bands to obtain statistical weights. We combine these weights with preset prior weights based on the frequency characteristics of flicker-banding and moiré. The resulting weights control each band's contribution when the frequency bands are recombined. The boundaries and weights remain fixed during training and inference. They are neither recomputed for each input nor learned by the optimizer. (3) Key settings. We use six bands, Butterworth order 2, energy scale 2.2, and prior balance 0.45. Appendix A.7 and Table 12 provide the remaining values and implementation details. (4) Choice of six bands. We chose six bands empirically based on our observations of the spectra of real images with flicker-banding and moiré. This number was not derived from an exact calculation. Our design mainly needs to distinguish low-, mid-, and high-frequency regions. We observed flicker-banding mainly in the low and middle frequencies. Within the high frequencies, we further distinguish the range where moiré appears from the frequencies above it. Six bands provide enough separation for this purpose. Too few bands can group degradation components with normal image structures, making them harder to distinguish. Too many bands can make the statistically estimated weights more sensitive to random variation. We therefore use six bands as an empirical balance between sufficient frequency separation and stable weight estimation. Table 4 shows the benefit of FS with this setting.
Table 4. Effect of FS and MWL.
Q3-2: MWL decomposition depth, subband weights, loss weights, and their selection.
A3-2:
Thank you for pointing out these missing details. (1) Decomposition depth. We use four levels of Haar decomposition during training, consistent with the figure in the paper. At each level, we decompose the LL output from the previous level. (2) Subband weights. We assign weight 1 to each LL, LH, HL, and HH subband at all four levels. LL supervises coarse luminance, while LH, HL, and HH supervise directional details. We average squared errors within each subband over the batch, channels, and spatial positions, then sum the sixteen subband losses. (3) Overall loss. The pixel MSE, perceptual LPIPS, and MWL weights are 1, 2, and 0.1, respectively. Pixel and MWL losses are used from the start; perceptual loss starts after 5,000 steps. (4) How we chose the settings. We chose four decomposition levels and equal subband weights to supervise flicker-banding across multiple scales and directions. We observed that four levels clearly reveal the directional features of flicker-banding. This already meets our design goal, so we consider further decomposition unnecessary for this purpose. We regard the features at each level and in each subband as equally important and therefore assign them equal weights. These choices follow our empirical observations and design goals, rather than exact calculations or a systematic parameter search. The overall MWL weight of 0.1 was also set empirically. Table 4 shows that MWL improves all three reported metrics with these settings. We will explore more refined designs and systematic parameter selection in future work. Appendix A.7 provides the implementation details, loss weights, and training schedule.
Table 4. Effect of FS and MWL.