- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The proposed FlickerDiff first estimates an uncertainty map from the flicker-corrupted image, which is then used to control the noise distribution in flow-matching and guide the FiLM modulation for restoration.
Critical strengths
The experimental results show that FlickerDiff outperforms existing methods on the BurstFlicker-S dataset across all metrics. Ablation studies further demonstrate the effectiveness of each component.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The contribution appears to be mainly a combination of existing components. FlickerDiff integrates uncertainty estimation, spatial noise scaling, FiLM modulation, adversarial training, and a NAFNet-style refiner on top of an 8B pretrained model. Meanwhile, post-fusion contributes most of the PSNR improvement in the component ablation study. In Table 15, adding the uncertainty map and FiLM improves PSNR by only 0.641 dB, whereas post-fusion achieves a much larger gain of 1.786 dB. This indicates that the final reconstruction performance may rely heavily on the additional refinement module rather than the proposed uncertainty-guided generation process.
(2) Most compared diffusion-based methods, such as PiSA-SR, OSEDiff, ResShift, and SinSR, were originally designed and trained for SR tasks. However, the paper does not clearly describe how these methods are adapted to flicker degradation, including the training data, loss functions, and fine-tuning strategies. Without these details, it is difficult to determine whether the comparisons are conducted under a fair setting. Moreover, the pretrained HiDream-O1 backbone contains 8B parameters, which is substantially larger than the backbones used in these competing methods.
Questions for authors
The proposed method uses an uncertainty map to modulate the noise distribution and compares it with fixed noise. However, is noise injection necessary in this single-step flow-matching setting? Existing single-step diffusion-based methods, such as OSEDiff, directly take the low-quality input without adding noise. The inferior performance of fixed noise may result from inappropriate noise magnitude or the limited number of inference steps, rather than from the fixed-noise strategy itself. Therefore, it would be valuable to clarify the motivation for introducing noise in a single-step flow-matching framework and whether uncertainty-guided noise modulation provides benefits beyond simply reducing excessive noise in relatively certain regions.