- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies error diffusion kernel design for binary defocused fringe projection. It introduces a directional balance coefficient to describe the asymmetry of error propagation along the phase gradient direction and uses this coefficient to design the GBO kernel. The method reduces directional phase bias by adjusting the diffusion kernel used during encoding, without changing the subsequent reconstruction pipeline. The authors evaluate it through simulations, real-system experiments, and additional three-step phase-shifting and dynamic examples in the appendix.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed design principle is interpretable. The authors connect the directional balance coefficient to the first moment of the diffusion kernel along the phase gradient direction. This gives the kernel parameters a clear mathematical basis and helps explain why the direction of error propagation affects phase estimation.
-
The paper includes real hardware experiments comparing several methods on the same projector and industrial camera system. The test objects include planar, spherical, and more complex surfaces. The appendix further reports point cloud errors in millimeters, connecting the results to practical 3D measurement accuracy.
-
The method is relatively easy to integrate into existing systems. It only requires replacing the diffusion kernel used during encoding, while retaining the existing phase-shifting and phase-unwrapping procedures. It also does not require training an additional reconstruction network, which makes it practical.
Critical weaknesses
-
The core theoretical derivation relies on strong approximation assumptions, including the slowly varying quantization residual and the neglect of certain contributions in the vertical direction. However, error diffusion inherently produces high-frequency, two-dimensional residuals. Without an analysis of the approximation errors, it is difficult to determine whether the derived balance condition remains valid under conditions such as weak defocus or small spatial periods.
-
The evidence supporting generalization to real-world visual scenarios remains limited. The extensive evaluations across different spatial periods and defocus levels are primarily based on Gaussian simulations, while the real-world experiments are restricted to a single hardware setup and orthogonal stripe patterns. Furthermore, the dynamic experiments lack comparisons between different binary encoding methods at the same acquisition speed, making it difficult to assess the method's generalizability across different devices, arbitrary pattern orientations, and dynamic scenes.
Questions for authors
See weakness
2 comments
Experimental Generalization
(3) Generalization
Physical Experiments
We tested GBO on another FPP system under different hardware and complex scenes. The new system uses an acA1600-20um camera with a resolution of pixels. We also redesigned the projector–camera geometry for the new system. With the new system, we measured two objects with complex geometric features: the curved dinosaur model has obvious angular undulations, multiple sharp edges, and severe self-occlusion; the building-block dog model has multiple building-block connection surfaces, protruding structures, and severe occlusion.
Moreover, we captured a multi-jointed puppet twice. The puppet has multiple human-like joints and self-occlusion near the joints. In the first capture, we covered the background with a black cloth; in the second, we left the background unisolated to evaluate the effect of background interference. The point clouds reconstructed from the corresponding 8-bit fringe patterns were used as references. The above experimental results are as follows:
Table 1: MAE/RMSE of reconstructed point clouds (mm)
| Object | FS | SOK | MK | HTF | FPC | GBO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dinosaur | 0.315/0.322 | 0.121/0.131 | 0.192/0.217 | 0.071/0.613 | 0.059/0.076 | 0.049/0.064 |
| Dog | 0.188/0.192 | 0.065/0.075 | 0.109/0.128 | 0.034/0.046 | 0.049/0.060 | 0.031/0.042 |
| Puppet (with background isolation) | 0.622/0.635 | 0.216/0.239 | 0.341/0.389 | 0.264/3.180 | 0.141/0.173 | 0.095/0.123 |
| Puppet (without background isolation) | 0.585/0.597 | 0.200/0.229 | 0.335/0.388 | 0.304/3.547 | 0.169/0.199 | 0.093/0.125 |
In the first two experiments, GBO achieved the lowest MAE and RMSE. Compared with FPC, GBO reduced the average MAE and RMSE in the two experiments by 26.78% and 22.05%, respectively. GBO therefore maintained strong error suppression despite changes in camera resolution and projector–camera geometry, even for objects with complex edges and occlusion.
In the repeated-acquisition experiments, after the background changed from isolated to non-isolated, the MAE and RMSE of the second-best FPC increased by 19.75% and 15.07%, respectively; in contrast, the MAE of GBO changed by -1.37%, and its RMSE increased by only 1.26%. GBO achieved the lowest MAE and RMSE in both captures. Compared with FPC, the average MAE and RMSE in the two captures were reduced by 38.60% and 33.10%, respectively. This shows that GBO still has good measurement stability when background interference changes.
Dynamic Experiments
In real dynamic measurement, the object's motion trajectory, initial position, and final state are difficult to repeat completely across different experiments; therefore, the measurement results of different methods are easily affected by differences in motion states. Moreover, under the current high-speed measurement conditions, 8-bit sinusoidal fringes cannot provide a synchronized reference at the same speed as binary methods owing to projection-speed limits.
To achieve fairer and repeatable comparisons among different binary encoding methods, we further built a Blender-based dynamic simulation system. This system can precisely control the object's motion trajectory, motion speed, and measurement timing and can obtain the corresponding true geometric information. The projector resolution was set to pixels, the camera resolution was set to pixels, and the projector-camera geometry configuration was also adjusted. The experiment used the actual projector's maximum projection frame rate of 4225 frames/s, and the average object motion speed was approximately 73.25 mm/s. All methods were compared under identical motion trajectories, speeds, projection frame rates, defocus configurations, and system parameters.
The three dynamic scenes are as follows: a watch with a transparent glass surface and localized reflection interference; a lion-head model with obvious hair texture, rich details, and self-occlusion; and a cup with severe specular reflection and obvious interreflection.
The experimental results are as follows:
Table 2: MAE/RMSE of dynamic experiments (mm)
| Object | FS | SOK | MK | HTF | FPC | GBO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Watch | 0.112/0.117 | 0.042/0.050 | 0.082/0.105 | 0.047/0.458 | 0.033/0.042 | 0.026/0.034 |
| Lion | 0.099/0.106 | 0.037/0.048 | 0.065/0.079 | 0.046/0.635 | 0.036/0.046 | 0.028/0.038 |
| Cup | 0.105/0.169 | 0.038/0.066 | 0.075/0.136 | 0.309/2.259 | 0.030/0.136 | 0.023/0.056 |
GBO achieved the lowest MAE and RMSE in all three dynamic experiments. Compared with FPC, the average MAE and RMSE in the three dynamic experiments were reduced by 22.35% and 31.86%, respectively. These results demonstrate that GBO provides stable error suppression and maintains good performance in scenes involving transparent media, complex textures, self-occlusion, and specular reflection.
We again thank you for the constructive comments. We hope that the above response can fully address your concerns and help improve your assessment of our work.
Theory and Modeling
We thank you for your constructive comments on the theory, experiments, and generalization. We have conducted further quantitative analyses and experiments to address the concerns raised; our responses follow below.
(1) Theoretical Validity
The theoretical approximation in this work is based on previous studies and the simulation analysis in the paper. The original binarization residual does contain high-frequency, two-dimensional spatial components. However, it should be noted that the fundamental mechanism of binary defocused fringe projection is to suppress high-frequency quantization errors through the projector's optical low-pass filtering. Therefore, sufficient defocusing is a necessary condition for binary defocused fringe projection. The multi-period and multi-defocus simulations in Fig. 7 further show that shorter fringe periods require less defocusing, while GBO maintains good performance even at small fringe periods.
As shown by the Fourier decomposition in Fig. 4(b), the main phase error of the FS algorithm originates from the fundamental sinusoidal error component, whose amplitude is approximately 26.7 times that of the largest higher-order harmonic shown. Furthermore, we further analyzed the influence of the residual two-dimensional error after filtering on phase recovery. Specifically, we removed the fundamental Fourier component obtained from the decomposition in Fig. 4(b) from the defocused fringes in Fig. 4(a), retained the remaining two-dimensional residual, and calculated the resulting phase error using the following equation: Δϕ(x,y)=NB2∑n=1Nsin(ϕ+2πNn)ΔIn(x,y). The phase error induced by the remaining two-dimensional residual is approximately 0.00673 rad, which is only 11.67% of the phase error induced by the fundamental component. This ratio further decreases as the defocus level increases. This indicates that the fundamental error component along the x-direction is the dominant factor.
These error characteristics are also consistent with the relevant analyses in Chen et al. (2026) and You et al. (2022b). Therefore, our theoretical analysis focuses on the low-frequency error components that remain after optical filtering and have a major influence on the final phase recovery. We also acknowledge the need for further investigation of higher-order phase errors and will address them in future work.
(2) Gaussian and Fringe Orientation
Gaussian Defocus
This work uses a Gaussian PSF to approximate the optical defocus effect of the projector. This modeling approach has been widely adopted in related studies. For example, You et al. (2022b), Shan et al. (2023), and Chen et al. (2026) all used a Gaussian PSF to describe the projector's optical defocusing process. The effectiveness of existing research results ensures the reliability of this assumption.
Furthermore, simulation experiments are also widely used in existing studies to analyze and optimize binary projection methods. This is because the error of this method originates from the residual intensity error after binary fringes pass through the projector's optical filtering; it is an inherent error on the projection side, rather than an error introduced by a specific object or acquisition scene. Therefore, simulation analysis targeting this error mechanism can provide a direct theoretical reference for practical measurement. On this basis, Fig. 7 further presents systematic simulation results under different fringe periods and defocus levels, verifying GBO's error suppression capability and applicability over a wide parameter range.
Fringe Orientation
In real measurement, horizontal and vertical fringes are the two simplest and most common configurations in FPP. Their phase variation directions align with the image-coordinate axes used in camera–projector calibration, facilitating direct mapping between phase and projector pixels. Other orientations generally require additional coordinate transformations or phase mapping. Therefore, horizontal and vertical fringes better meet the needs of high-speed measurement for algorithmic simplicity and computational efficiency. Moreover, most of the comparison methods in the experiments in this paper are also designed for horizontal fringes. Therefore, this paper mainly validates the directional balance criterion for these two standard orientations. This criterion is constructed based on the relationship between the first moment of the diffusion kernel and the fringe phase gradient direction. Its simple constraint provides a theoretical basis for extension to other orientations. We will analyze other orientations in future work.