- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This is an empirical study where the authors adopt an established graph neural ODE approach, namely AdvGNODE, to predict temperature changes in server liquid cooling. They study how missing flow information affects the predictions and whether estimating this flow can improve the results.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
As this is an empirical paper, in the assessment I will evaluate the paper based on the importance of the problem, the practical impact of the results, and whether the approach can be useful for related problems. I believe the paper does not sufficiently address these points:
-
Regarding the problem, although temperature prediction for liquid cooling is interesting, the authors only evaluated their approach in simulation; real-world validation or deployment would strengthen the paper significantly. Also, although the paper is motivated by control, in the end, the authors only evaluate forecasting. This makes it less convincing that the results would be useful for control problem in practice.
-
Regarding the approach, this seems to be a straightforward application of an existing method to their problem. The results show how missing flow affects prediction in their simulation, but these insights seem limited to their specific problem, and what values could they bring to broader related problems remains unclear.
Questions for authors
None
Response: simulation scope, forecasting vs control, novelty.
Thank you for the review.
Simulation only. A real limitation, stated in Section 7. Branch-level flow measurements around valve events are not publicly available for the real Frontier system, so we use the public transient model of its cooling plant (ExaDigiT, distributed with LC-Opt), which makes the study reproducible. We now also report a second plant with nonlinear (equal-percentage) valves, where the same conclusions hold: ESTIMATED is within 0.001 K of TRUE-FLOW on the siblings at 60 s, and FROZEN and COMMAND are about 20× worse.
Control versus forecasting. The use case is forecasting inside a controller, before an action is taken. We now show that the forecast error changes decisions: ranking the 49 test closures by the predicted temperature change, Spearman correlation with the truth on the struck channel is 0.998 (ESTIMATED), 0.931 (COMMAND) and −0.16 (FROZEN); on the siblings 0.983, 0.435 and 0.611.
Novelty and broader value. Please see the general response. We do not claim a new architecture; the new experiments show what a network needs to learn the redistribution, which applies to any flow network with unmeasured actuation.