- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Traditional methods and standard physics-informed neural networks for modeling fluid flow networks are often prohibitively expensive or suffer from ill-conditioning due to their reliance on penalty losses. To address this, the authors propose a novel framework based on the "representation-then-projection" principle, which structurally embeds physical laws directly into the neural formulation using fixed neural bases and non-overlapping domain-decomposition.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses the uniquely challenging and novel problem of rapidly and accurately evaluating nonlinear edgewise hyperbolic laws coupled across large-scale fluid flow networks, which has direct applications to critical systems like biological vasculature and pipeline infrastructure.
-
The proposed framework demonstrates remarkable accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper's central motivation regarding the optimization problem being "prone to ill-conditioning, particularly for hyperbolic systems" is not discussed or justified anywhere in the text.
-
Dataset visualization is missing.
-
It is unclear how the datasets were generated (by the authors or from existing works), how many trajectories and frames are included, and how the datasets were split.
-
The authors only compare their method with two very old baselines. This comparison is insufficient to determine how the proposed model performs compared to recent state-of-the-art approaches.
-
The highlighted strong performance in unseen boundary conditions for both interpolation and extrapolation is not justified by any experiment, and there are no boundary errors or boundary residuals provided.
-
Experiments and experimental settings are insufficient, as evaluations are only conducted on two datasets with the same geometry. Model performance remains unclear regarding long rollout stability, scalability to large domains, and generalization to different geometries.
-
Many variables are undefined, making the paper difficult to read. For example, in equation 4.2, is not defined, and the construction of and is unexplained.
-
The proposed method shows an orders-of-magnitude improvement over the baselines, requiring an analysis of whether the baselines are simply too weak or poorly trained, as the pressure and momentum evolution in Figure 3 shows the baselines completely diverging from the ground truth.
-
The authors' claim that "Such losses act only as optimization surrogates during training, with no guarantee that their reduction reduces solution error" disagrees with many findings from existing PINNs papers and requires justification.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
Response to Reviewer (Revised PDF & Additional Experiments)
We thank the reviewer for the feedback. Most of the concerns raised are already addressed in the manuscript, and we have uploaded a revised PDF with additional experiments (highlighted) to resolve the remaining points:
We hope these clarifications and additional experiments address your concerns.