- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents RIS (Retrieve, Integrate, and Synthesize), a spatial-semantic grounded framework for latent visual reasoning in multimodal large language models. The paper identifies three challenges in prior latent reasoning methods: weak grounding of latent representations, bypassing of latent states during answer generation, and incompatibility between latent reasoning states and vocabulary-aligned decoding. To address these issues, the authors construct a 96K-sample grounded reasoning dataset and introduce spatial-semantic supervision, a progressive attention bottleneck, and language transition tokens. Experiments on five visual reasoning benchmarks show improvements over several latent reasoning baselines. Additional analyses investigate latent diversity, attention patterns, and the functional influence of intermediate latent representations.
Critical strengths
-
The method addresses an important limitation of latent visual reasoning. Rather than treating latent tokens as implicitly useful merely because they can be generated, the paper explicitly considers visual grounding and the possibility that the answer decoder bypasses intermediate states. The proposed spatial-semantic supervision and progressive attention mechanism provide a coherent response to these problems. This is particularly valuable given the growing evidence that latent token generation does not necessarily imply effective latent reasoning.
-
The empirical evaluation extends beyond standard accuracy comparisons. The paper includes comparisons with representative latent reasoning approaches, supervision ablations, latent representation analyses, and inference-time interventions. These experiments provide more evidence about the behavior of latent states than a conventional benchmark-only evaluation. The 96K grounded reasoning dataset is also a potentially useful contribution.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is somewhat incremental relative to recent grounded latent reasoning approaches. Prior work, including LVR, Monet, LDPVR, and ReaLVR, has already explored latent visual states, visual evidence grounding, intermediate supervision, and the relationship between latent trajectories and answer generation. RIS combines these ideas in a structured manner, but the paper does not fully establish which individual mechanism represents a qualitatively new advance beyond these developments. A sharper comparison with closely related visual-evidence supervision methods would strengthen the novelty claim.
-
The proposed manifold-compatibility explanation is not yet fully isolated from the effects of additional supervision and information-flow restrictions. Spatial-semantic labels, attention constraints, and language transition tokens may independently improve optimization and answer generation without necessarily establishing the proposed manifold-level interpretation. Although the paper provides useful intervention analyses, a stronger controlled comparison with explicit grounded reasoning under matched supervision and information accessibility is needed to distinguish the claimed latent mechanism from these alternative explanations.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors compare RIS against an explicit grounded reasoning baseline trained with the same GLSD examples, region annotations, and intermediate semantic targets, while controlling the visibility of visual evidence during answer generation? This would help separate the benefit of latent reasoning from the benefit of additional grounding supervision.
-
How much of the improvement remains when the progressive attention bottleneck is replaced by a less restrictive attention configuration while keeping the same supervised latent slots? In particular, can the authors distinguish genuine information integration from reliance induced by architectural information restrictions?
-
What quantitative evidence establishes manifold compatibility beyond latent similarity and entropy measurements? For example, can the authors show that the transition tokens improve latent-to-language consistency independently of their additional token-level supervision?
-
How sensitive are the results to the correctness of the automatically generated reasoning steps and bounding boxes, particularly for multi-object or relational questions?
5 comments
Q1. Explicit grounded reasoning under matched supervision and matched visibility
Qwen2.5-VL-7B+GLSD is trained on the same 80K GLSD examples, with the same bounding boxes, region descriptions and visual information, written as explicit text steps and learned by next-token prediction. To also match answer-stage visibility, we add Qwen+GLSD+Bottleneck. Its training sequences follow the GLSD format used in Phase 1: the explicit grounded trace , then the full answer , then the final answer . The trace is generated with full access to the image and question. We then apply the same bottleneck as RIS to and : they can attend to the trace but not to the image or question tokens. This baseline therefore matches RIS in supervision content and in what the answer can see, and differs only in whether the intermediate reasoning is carried by explicit text or by continuous latents. All models use the same backbone, data and number of optimization steps.
| Reasoning carrier | Grounding | Answer-stage bottleneck | V* | HR4K | HR8K | MMVP | BLINK | Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Explicit text | ✓ | ✗ | 78.25 | 70.58 | 64.70 | 66.80 | 56.25 | 67.32 |
| Explicit text | ✓ | ✓ | 80.27 | 71.16 | 66.23 | 69.58 | 58.04 | 69.06 |
| Continuous latents | ✗ | ✓ | 74.06 | 64.24 | 60.87 | 66.53 | 50.56 | 63.25 |
| Continuous latents (RIS) | ✓ | ✓ | 83.75 | 73.23 | 68.52 | 73.55 | 60.60 | 71.93 |
The third row is the joint grounding ablation reported to Reviewer LsiH (Q3).
The bottleneck alone improves explicit reasoning by 1.74, so part of RIS's gain over vanilla SFT comes from restricting answer-stage access. With supervision and visibility both matched, however, RIS still exceeds the explicit baseline by 2.87, on all five benchmarks. Conversely, latents without grounding fall 5.81 below the explicit baseline. Latent reasoning therefore helps only when it is grounded, and with grounding it outperforms the same supervision expressed as text.
Q2. Effect of bottleneck strength on accuracy and latent dependence
We keep all slots, supervision and training settings fixed and only lower the final masking probability ρ in Phase 3 (originally annealed from 0.3 to 1.0) to 0.75 and 0.50. At inference, each variant applies a stochastic mask with its final ρ; results are averaged over 3 runs. w/o Mask corresponds to ρ = 0 throughout.
| Final ρ | V* | HR4K | HR8K | MMVP | BLINK | Avg. | Gain over Qwen+GLSD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 (RIS) | 83.75 | 73.23 | 68.52 | 73.55 | 60.60 | 71.93 | +4.61 |
| 0.75 | 82.60 | 72.45 | 67.35 | 72.15 | 58.95 | 70.70 | +3.38 |
| 0.50 | 81.45 | 71.35 | 65.95 | 70.75 | 57.80 | 69.46 | +2.14 |
| 0 (w/o Mask) | 68.14 | 65.83 | 59.36 | 67.74 | 51.76 | 62.57 | -4.75 |
Relaxing the bottleneck retains 73% and 46% of RIS's gain over Qwen+GLSD. Part of the improvement is therefore induced by the restriction, and we will state this explicitly. The sharp drop between ρ = 0.5 and ρ = 0 indicates that even partial masking is enough to force the latents to carry information during training, whereas never-masked latents remain uncalibrated and interfere with prediction (see our response to Reviewer 6T3c, Q1 and the per-phase ablation).
To separate genuine integration from induced reliance, we repeat the answer-level interventions of Table 6 on the relaxed models. Entries are accuracy drops relative to each model's own unperturbed accuracy.
| Final ρ | Unperturbed | Remove latents | Latent-path masking | Cross-example shuffle | Within-example shuffle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 71.93 | −5.64 | −5.26 | −7.53 | −7.08 |
| 0.75 | 70.70 | −2.72 | −2.28 | −4.79 | −3.92 |
| 0.50 | 69.46 | −0.90 | −0.82 | −2.64 | −2.52 |
Two patterns emerge:
- Dependence on the presence of latents is largely induced by the bottleneck. As ρ decreases, removing the latents costs progressively less (5.64 to 2.72 to 0.90), since the answer can increasingly draw on the inputs directly.
- Sensitivity to latent content persists. At ρ = 0.5, replacing the latents with another example's costs about three times as much as removing them (2.64 vs. 0.90), and shuffling their order costs nearly as much. If the latents were merely tolerated by a model that could bypass them, wrong latents would be no more harmful than absent ones. Instead, the answer actively reads and integrates instance-specific, ordered latent content even when it is not forced to.
The bottleneck thus determines how much the answer relies on the latents, while the content effect shows that what it relies on is genuinely integrated evidence.
W1. Novelty relative to related works
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and the precise questions. We first address the novelty concern, then each question.
We agree that latent visual states, evidence grounding and intermediate supervision have each been explored. What RIS adds is explicitly controlling how evidence reaches the answer, which prior methods leave unconstrained, and grounding each latent slot at the step level:
RIS differs in three respects:
The controlled experiments below isolate each of these: grounding vs. no grounding at matched data (Q1), latent vs. explicit reasoning at matched supervision and matched answer-stage access (Q1), the strength of the bottleneck (Q2), and the transition pathway at matched supervision (Q3). We will add LDPVR and ReaLVR to the related work with this comparison.