- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Interlude, a method that inserts recurrent hidden-state computation into the textual reasoning process of Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct. The model switches between textual and latent segments using boundary tokens, allowing subsequent text to access latent states through self-attention. Training uses 50K teacher-generated examples constructed from VCR and VIRL-39K, combining textual cross-entropy loss, stage-dependent semantic-window supervision, and a geometric margin constraint defined relative to the visual and textual centroids. Across six multimodal benchmarks, Interlude achieves an Overall score of 68.7, outperforming the original backbone (63.9), standard CoT fine-tuning on the same data (65.1), and SwimBird (66.5). Ablation studies show that removing the intermediate-modality constraint or semantic guidance, or disabling latent segments at inference time, reduces the Overall score to 66.9, 66.2, and 66.4, respectively.
Critical strengths
- Table 2 shows that Interlude outperforms the original backbone across all six benchmarks, with improvements of 10.7 and 5.5 percentage points on HallusionBench and ERQA, respectively, demonstrating broad and substantial performance gains.
- The ablation studies further validate the practical contributions of both supervision objectives and the latent segments: the full model consistently outperforms variants without the intermediate-modality constraint, without semantic guidance, or with latent segments disabled during inference.
Critical weaknesses
- The geometric analysis does not sufficiently support the proposed mechanism. The intermediate-modality constraint explicitly introduces a margin loss that encourages latent states h to align more closely with the intermediate reference r than with either modality centroid. Consequently, the observed increase in effective dimensionality and changes in the orthogonal component may simply be optimization artifacts induced by L_{imc}, rather than evidence that the model meaningfully exploits under-saturated representational capacity to preserve useful visual information. The authors should demonstrate that these additional dimensions encode task-relevant visual information that contributes to downstream performance, rather than merely reflecting noise or geometric redistribution induced by the loss function.
- The experimental comparisons lack sufficient fairness. Interlude is trained on a specially constructed dataset of 50K high-quality teacher-supervised examples, whereas the competing baselines rely on their respective training corpora, introducing differences in data quality and supervision strategies. Although the SFT experiment using the same training data provides partial supporting evidence, I recommend reproducing representative baselines under a unified backbone, training dataset, and computational budget to better isolate and validate the advantages of the proposed method itself.
Questions for authors
Under the same backbone, 50K training examples, training budget, and number of latent reasoning steps, how does the proposed geometric constraint compare with direct visual alignment and a fixed midpoint target?
4 comments
Q1. Controlled comparisons with direct visual alignment and a fixed midpoint
Experimental setup. All variants use the same backbone, 50K training samples, training budget, and number of latent reasoning steps. We compare five geometric-supervision configurations:
- Interlude: Uses the two-sided margin in Eq. (7), with the stage-dependent in Eq. (6): 0.75 for the abstract stage, 0.50 for the bridging or unified stage, and 0.25 for the concrete stage.
- Without IMC: Removes geometric supervision while retaining the latent architecture and semantic supervision.
- Direct visual alignment: Directly minimizes the cosine distance between latent states and the retrieved visual anchors.
- Fixed-midpoint target: Fixes in Eq. (6) and directly minimizes the cosine distance between latent states and the text–visual midpoint.
- Fixed-midpoint two-sided margin: Also fixes , but applies the two-sided margin in Eq. (7) instead of directly pulling latent states toward the midpoint.
| Configuration | MMStar | HallusionBench | V*Bench | ERQA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interlude | 72.1 | 71.8 | 86.9 | 48.3 |
| Without IMC | 72.1 | 71.2 | 83.8 | 44.0 |
| Direct visual alignment | 70.5 | 70.0 | 84.3 | 46.5 |
| Fixed-midpoint target | 69.8 | 69.3 | 83.8 | 45.5 |
| Fixed-midpoint two-sided margin | 70.1 | 69.8 | 84.8 | 46.0 |
Removing IMC leaves only semantic-anchor supervision and degrades performance overall, particularly on the two visually intensive benchmarks, ERQA and V*Bench. Directly aligning latent states with visual anchors or a fixed text–visual midpoint also underperforms the full IMC objective. These results suggest that simply introducing a fixed alignment target is insufficient to obtain consistent gains and may interfere with semantic supervision.
Using a two-sided margin at the same fixed midpoint improves performance over direct midpoint alignment, but still falls short of Interlude with its stage-dependent schedule. Together, these comparisons support the proposed design as a more effective way to balance semantic supervision and geometric manifold supervision among the configurations tested.
Thank you again for the time and effort you have devoted to reviewing our work. If our responses have addressed your concerns, we would sincerely appreciate your reconsideration of the score. We would be grateful for the opportunity to share this work with the community and inspire future research.
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you again for your time and thoughtful feedback. With two days remaining in the rebuttal period, we would greatly appreciate it if you could review our responses and additional experimental results when you have a chance. We hope these address your concerns, and we would be happy to clarify any remaining questions.
Thank you for your consideration.
[11 hours Remaining] Could you confirm whether our responses have addressed your concern? Thanks!
Dear Reviewer wbcn,
As the rebuttal discussion phase will end in 11 hours, we would like to express our sincere gratitude for your engagement so far. We kindly remind you that after November 18 (AoE), we will no longer be able to respond to any further questions.
We hope that our responses have addressed your concerns during the author-reviewer discussion phase. If there are any remaining issues or clarifications needed, please let us know at your earliest convenience.
Thank you again for your time and consideration!
Best regards,
Authors of paper #45355
Thank you for your positive assessment of our method and your valuable feedback. We address each of your comments below.
W1. Insufficient evidence that the additional dimensions encode useful visual information
Thank you for highlighting the need for a more direct connection between geometric changes and effective reasoning. We agree that an increase in effective dimensionality alone does not establish whether the additional representational capacity is useful. We therefore investigate this interpretation through visual-alignment analyses, interventions on latent content, and controlled comparisons of geometric objectives.
Section 6 provides two relevant observations. Figure 5(b) shows that the component orthogonal to the principal word-embedding subspace exhibits a 0.202 increase in cosine similarity with visual representations, whereas the change for the component within that subspace is −0.002. Figure 7(b) further shows that the analyzed post-training directions align more strongly with the visual subspace than with the principal word-embedding subspace. Thus, the expansion of the representation distribution is accompanied by stronger visual alignment, supporting the use of representational space beyond the dominant textual directions.
To examine whether subsequent reasoning actually uses latent content, we conduct intervention experiments on V*Bench, replacing only the states at the specified positions.
Cross-sample swapping replaces the specified latent segment with states from the corresponding positions of another question. At each latent step, the random-perturbation control matches both the resulting state norm and the perturbation distance induced by the corresponding swap. All conditions preserve the text prefix preceding the intervention, the latent slots, and the number of reasoning steps per segment.
Perturbing latent segments at different positions consistently reduces performance, with a larger degradation when both the first and last segments are perturbed. These results indicate that the model’s reasoning relies on information encoded in the latent states. Cross-sample swapping also causes larger performance drops than matched random perturbations, further suggesting that the latent states encode input-specific information that influences subsequent predictions.
The analyses in Section 6 characterize the visual structure of the expanded representations, while the intervention experiments establish a connection between latent content and task performance. Together, these complementary findings support the interpretation that intermediate-modality supervision helps the model learn latent representations useful for visual reasoning, beyond merely inducing geometric changes.
W2. Fairness of comparisons across different training conditions
Thank you for pointing out this limitation. Our cross-method comparisons do not control for differences in training data and computational budgets. A key consideration is that reproducing methods such as LVR, Monet, and SwimBird requires constructing method-specific supervision, including region annotations, intermediate auxiliary images, and specialized reasoning sequences. These data-construction procedures are themselves integral components of the respective methods. Even when starting from the same raw samples, differences in teacher models, annotation granularity, and filtering criteria can affect the quality of the reconstructed supervision and, consequently, the comparison results.
We therefore retain each method’s data-construction and training protocol for an overall comparison, rather than reconstructing its specialized supervision ourselves. Among the latent-reasoning methods compared, SwimBird and Interlude share the same Qwen3-VL-8B backbone, providing a more direct comparison with respect to the underlying model. Nevertheless, a shared backbone alone does not eliminate differences in training data or compute.