acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Latent Rule Reasoning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Rules are reusable abstract relations or constraints across different contexts. Inferring and applying rules to unseen cases across various tasks remains challenging for specialized models and Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs). We propose **Latent Rule Reasoning (LRR)**, which integrates sequential rule induction and execution within an LVLM’s continuous latent space. LRR induces rule representations from visual context and applies them under query conditions to form target-state representations for answer generation. We further introduce **Latent Rule Self-Distillation (LRSD)**, in which the same LVLM uses complete visual observations available only during training to guide rule induction from inference-time inputs. Training first grounds rule representations and develops target prediction using rule-annotated examples, then incorporates cross-view rule consistency to jointly learn from examples with and without explicit rule annotations while retaining answer supervision. Our experiments reveal that LRR achieves an improvement of 10.70% on VisuLogic and a gain of 6.75% on SpatialEval, demonstrating the effectiveness of latent rule reasoning on various in-distribution, out-of-distribution, and general visual understanding tasks.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
Latent Rule Reasoning, Large Vision-Language Models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_uaSZOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses visual rule induction and execution in large vision-language models. It proposes Latent Rule Reasoning (LRR), which sequentially generates continuous rule representations and target-state representations before producing an answer. Latent Rule Self-Distillation (LRSD) trains this framework using complete visual observations to guide reasoning from incomplete inputs, together with rule reconstruction, target-feature alignment, and answer supervision. Experiments on abstract visual reasoning and general visual understanding benchmarks demonstrate performance improvements and provide evidence of transfer beyond the fine-tuning benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework is well motivated and closely aligned with the problem structure. Separating rule induction from rule execution provides a clear organization for latent reasoning, while distinct supervision objectives encourage the intermediate representations to capture relations and their visual consequences. This constitutes a meaningful framework-level contribution.
  2. The training approach coherently combines semantic grounding with cross-view self-distillation. Sections 3.3–3.4 connect rule representations to explicit rule descriptions and target representations to fixed visual features, then introduce consistency learning to incorporate examples without explicit rule annotations. This provides a practical approach to learning from different levels of supervision.
  3. The empirical evaluation is comprehensive, covering in-distribution abstract reasoning, cross-benchmark transfer, and general visual understanding. Tables 1–3 show consistent improvements over the backbone and competitive results against the evaluated methods, with a particularly notable advantage on SpatialEval. The component, latent-length, and model-scale analyses in Tables 4–6 further strengthen the empirical case and help establish the contributions and limitations of the design.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The connection between the intended roles of the latent representations and their learned behavior could be clearer. Although rule reconstruction and target alignment provide meaningful supervision, Figure 4 primarily presents rule descriptions and final predictions without establishing how these descriptions relate to the student’s inference-time representations. Individual latent tokens need not have directly interpretable meanings, but clarifying the provenance of the displayed rules and any existing evidence of the two stages’ functional specialization would strengthen the mechanistic interpretation. This is an explanatory limitation rather than a fundamental flaw.
  2. Some hyperparameters and implementation details are not fully documented in Section 4 and Appendix B. Additional information about the training-data mixture, rule-annotation coverage, loss weights, and the rule decoder and token pruner would make the method easier to reproduce. These appear to be straightforward documentation issues that could be addressed with a compact implementation summary.
  3. A few reporting details require clarification. The benchmark named VASR in the text appears as VAP in Table 2, without an explanation of their relationship. The tables also do not indicate whether results come from single or multiple runs. This matters particularly for small margins, such as the 0.11-point advantage over the strongest comparator on MMBench. Consistent naming and a clear statement of the reporting protocol would improve precision without changing the broader positive findings.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the source of the rule descriptions in Figure 4: dataset annotations, manual explanations, or outputs from the rule decoder? If they are model-generated, do they use complete-view teacher representations or student representations generated under inference conditions?
  2. Could the authors provide a brief implementation summary covering the training-data mixture, rule-annotation coverage, loss weights, and the configurations of the rule decoder and token pruner?
  3. Does VAP in Table 2 refer to VASR? Please also clarify whether Tables 2–3 report single-run results or averages over multiple runs, and summarize any already available variability estimates.
Reviewer_kKmHOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Latent Rule Reasoning, which divides continuous latent reasoning into rule induction and execution. It uses self-distillation, where a teacher branch sees the complete image during training and guides a student branch with incomplete input. Evaluation covers abstract visual reasoning and general visual understanding, mainly using Qwen3-VL-8B, with additional 4B results. However, the experiments do not directly test the physical dynamics or multi-view 3D settings used in the motivation. The technical contribution beyond existing latent reasoning and distillation methods remains unclear, and the comparisons and ablations are not sufficient to establish it.

Critical strengths

The paper includes almost all experiments with Qwen3-VL-8B to study the effects of different loss terms, training stages, and latent token budgets.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main contribution is not clearly established. Hidden-state feedback and latent self-distillation are already explored in Coconut and CODI, but neither is discussed. The paper also does not show that its two latent stages learn and execute reusable rules, rather than useful task features. A single-stage latent baseline with the same supervision and token budget is missing.

  2. The training description and comparisons leave important doubts. LRSD is described as on-policy learning with student prefixes, but there are some conflict between text and algorithm and equations. The paper also does not clearly establish fair experiment setting across all models/baselines. These issues make the method difficult to reproduce and the source of its gains difficult to judge.

Questions for authors
  1. How does LRR differ from Coconut (COLM26, released in 2024, over 900 citations) and CODI (EMNLP25, over 300 citations)? Coconut already feeds hidden states back as input embeddings, and CODI already uses self-distillation to train latent reasoning. Neither is discussed in the paper. What is the main technical contribution beyond adding rule and target supervision to these existing ideas?

  2. How is LRSD different from existing distillation methods that give the teacher extra information during training? Here, the teacher sees the correct target, while the student does not. Please explain what is new beyond using a complete image as the teacher input.

  3. What evidence shows that the model learns reusable rules and then executes them? In Figure 4, “the statue stands beside the border of the island" is an image description, not a reusable rule. Can the learned rule representation be transferred to another example with the same rule?

  4. Is the separation between rule induction and rule execution necessary? Table 5 changes both latent lengths together.

  5. Why is LRSD described as on-policy self-distillation using student prefixes? Equation (12), Algorithm 1, and Appendix A.4 use teacher-generated prefixes instead. Which version is actually implemented?

  6. What does the variational formulation add to the actual training method? The implementation uses deterministic mean trajectories, while the ELBO includes expectations over random latent prefixes. Appendix A.5 states that replacing these prefixes with their means does not follow from the Gaussian KL identity.

  7. Why does Table 3 omit strong published systems such as DeepEyes? Comparing methods added to one backbone is useful, but it does not show how LRR compares with the best existing systems. Please include these results and state the differences in model size, training data, and inference budget.

  8. The introduction motivates the method with physical dynamics and multi-view 3D consistency. Which experiments directly test these abilities? General spatial questions do not establish these capabilities.

Reviewer_do8AOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This submission describes two techniques: Latent Rule Reasoning (LRR) and Latent Rule Self-Distillation (LRSD). LRR is the architecture which uses latent reasoning in a vision-language model to autoregressively feedback final layer hidden states for specially trained rule and prediction embeddings. These special rule and prediction embeddings are trained with LRSD, which uses teacher forced inputs between a ground-truth privileged teacher model for both the rule and target embeddings. LRSD then enforces a rule consistency loss to train the student-teacher rule induction without supervised annotations.

Critical strengths

This approach is a novel combination of many existing systems such as recurrent latent reasoning, student-teacher training, and rule induction. The submission engages with the prior work in this field and provides a meaningful synthesis of the ideas into a unique solution.

The work of rule induction and distillation is well motivated. The overall approach to the problem is reasonably well executed and robustly described.

The paper performs a comprehensive analysis on its approach on a wide variety of benchmarks, including text-only and multimodal tasks. They evaluate out of distribution performance on 5 different abstract reasoning benchmarks and 6 general image understanding tasks. The analysis includes strong ablations against related approaches.

Critical weaknesses

Table 1 reports results on RAVEN/I-RAVEN similarly to the original CRD paper (DECOMPOSITION OF CONCEPT-LEVEL RULES IN VISUAL SCENES, Shi et al ICLR 2026), except it omits its headline results on QWEN-VL-CRD which outperform LRR. This invalidates the claim of LRR as the best results on this benchmark.

I find it difficult to parse exactly what roles LRR and LRSD have, it seems to me there is an inconsistency with how these terms are used. LRR is presented as the latent architecture, and LRSD is presented as the self-distillation. But section 3.4 doesn't describe purely self-distillation, it describes using 'complete rule annotations'. So this is more appropriately a form of supervised finetuning with a self-distillation component. Additionally, the opening of the Method section describes LRSD as an on-policy self-distillation technique, but the central approach uses ground truth privileged teacher-forced training which is off-policy.

Table 4 shows that the vast majority of the performance comes from the supervised grounding term K_TP. This indicates that the self-distillation is responsible for maybe only 1-2.8 percentage points, despite claimed as a main contribution.

I am concerned that this system does not actually learn and execute rules in the way it is described. The training only encourages producing the same hidden vector from the incomplete view as from the complete view. Nothing constrains the model to actually execute these rules with the result tokens. It is possible that the learned rules simply produce the answer or some complete-view shortcut. There doesn't seem to be any analysis that would indicate that the rules and results are actually what is being produced besides the qualitative results in Figure 4, which doesn't describe how the rules were derived or if they are from the label set.

The main baseline 'Qwen3-VL-8B + Standard SFT' is underspecified. This must be described, at least in the appendix. It's especially unclear because the '0 rule +0 target' condition does not match the standard SFT results, which indicates that there is some other undocumented difference between the standard SFT construction and the proposed method in the 0+0 condition.

Figure 2 is a bit confusing in regards to where the output is, because the arrows seem to indicate from the top row to the bottom row, but the bottom row is labeled 'input embeddings'. I think these lines are backwards.

Questions for authors

Table 4 suggests that K_RC provides only a modest incremental gain, whereas rule reconstruction and target grounding account for most of the improvement. Please provide matched controls that separate additional supervision from the recurrent latent architecture and from self-distillation. This is the main concern with the analysis.

Why does Table 1 omit the original Qwen-VL-CRD result of 89.4/89.3 on RAVEN/I-RAVEN, as well as SRAN and CLAP-NP, despite reproducing many other values from the CRD paper and claiming the highest accuracy? Please explain any protocol differences, include the omitted results if comparable, and clarify why the Qwen3-VL+CRD reimplementation differs so substantially from the published result.

Please clearly separate the LRR architecture, supervised grounding objective, and LRSD-specific self-distillation term. Does LRSD denote only K_RC, or the entire objective including answer CE, rule CE, and target MSE?

How is LRSD on-policy? Equation 12 and Algorithm 1 condition the student on teacher-generated latent prefixes, and the appendix explicitly describes teacher-distributed prefixes. Is the student ever trained on its own latent trajectory?

What evidence shows that Z^R is causally used to produce Z^E, and that Z^E is used to produce the answer? Please report latent interventions and quantitative rule/target decoding metrics. Also clarify whether the rule descriptions in Figure 4 are model-generated or ground-truth annotations. Could the complete-view teacher exploit direct matching between the restored target and the answer candidates? Please report a control removing candidates from the teacher or independently permuting candidate order.

Please fully specify the Standard SFT baseline and explain why it differs from the 0+0 latent condition.

Please revise Figure 2 to distinguish hidden-state outputs, input embeddings, and the direction of recurrent feedback.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.