- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a structured latent tokenization framework SLR that explicitly disentangles reusable reasoning patterns from instance-specific execution and represents it with latent operation tokens. SLR allows compact reusable operations to be combined with instance-specific computation, enabling interleaved latent and explicit reasoning.
Critical strengths
- The proposed SLR successfully separates reusable procedural patterns from instance-specific computations, unlike prior methods that compress heterogeneous information into a shared space.
- SLR allows precise control over compression granularity and codebook size using intuitive hyperparameters.
- Extensive evaluation across diverse multimodal reasoning benchmarks exhibits that SLR reduces mean output token length by 10%-35% while matching or exceeding standard SFT accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
- The quality of the discrete reasoning codebook relies heavily on pipeline components like automated span segmentation, decomposition prompts, and greedy leader clustering, which may introduce parsing errors or propagate noise into codebook tokens.
- Ablation studies show that randomizing operation-token assignments or removing semantic grounding leads to a sharp drop in token utility and downstream accuracy, indicating that the model's performance is sensitive to the semantic integrity of the induced primitives.
- Experiments are limited to Qwen model families, which restrict the evaluation of the method's generalization
Questions for authors
- The paradigm of SLR is similar to classical vector quantization and neuro-symbolic approaches. Can you clarify the core breakthrough of SLR over existing discrete latent reasoning methods and classical codebook compression, beyond applying a span-segmentation and clustering recipe to multimodal CoT?
- Can the learned reasoning codebooks be transferred zero-shot to other model architectures? And what is the performance of SLR on models out of the Qwen families, which is related to the generalization of the method?
- Can SLR be applied to open-ended or non-algorithmic tasks where rigid procedural primitives cannot not be cleanly segmented?
- What is the total computational cost of corpus-wide text segmentation, decomposition, and semantic clustering prior to training? Furthermore, does the lookup and decoding of codebook tokens introduce measurable inference latency overhead in practice?
3 comments
[W3] / [Q2] Generalization beyond the Qwen family
SLR is model-agnostic by construction. Its codebook is induced from reasoning traces by extracting and consolidating recurring abstract operations, independently of the target model's architecture, weights, or tokenizer. The resulting operation definitions and interleaved training data can therefore be reused across different model architectures. Applying SLR to a new model requires only adding the corresponding operation tokens to its vocabulary and training on the interleaved data using standard SFT. The operation-token embeddings are learned separately for each target model during training. In our InternVL3.5 experiments, we reuse the same codebook and data pipeline without modification, demonstrating that the induced reasoning primitives transfer across model families without requiring model-specific codebook construction.
[Q1] Clarifying the core breakthrough of SLR
Our core contribution is not simply applying span segmentation and clustering to multimodal CoT. Rather, SLR introduces a different formulation of discrete reasoning by changing what is represented by discrete tokens: instead of quantizing entire reasoning spans, it discretizes only the reusable operations underlying those spans, while keeping their instance-specific executions explicit. Consequently, no instance-specific information passes through the codebook, which allows a compact set of reusable operation tokens to represent recurring reasoning patterns.
In addition, SLR is lightweight and fully compatible with standard SFT pipelines. It introduces no additional encoder or decoder modules, no architectural changes, and has no extra reconstruction or alignment objectives. The model is trained directly with the standard next-token prediction objective over an expanded vocabulary, which makes SLR straightforward to integrate into existing training pipelines.
In summary, SLR's central contribution is a structured formulation of discrete latent reasoning that explicitly separates reusable procedural knowledge from instance-specific information. By discretizing only the former and retaining the latter in the reasoning sequence, SLR provides a compact and interpretable vocabulary of reasoning primitives that the model can learn to invoke during generation, without requiring additional architectural components or training objectives.
[Q3] Applicability beyond rigid procedural reasoning tasks
We thank the reviewer for this question. We clarify that SLR does not rely on rigid procedural boundaries for segmentation. Instead, it discovers recurring patterns across reason traces, and such patterns are not limited to algorithmic procedures. For example, non-algorithmic visual reasoning can also involve recurring operations, such as ANALYZE_SPATIAL_LAYOUT and LOCATE_TARGET_OBJECT. Moreover, these primitives are optional to the model: the model uses them when a reusable pattern applies, and otherwise continues reasoning in natural language. Thus less structured reasoning stays fully expressible.
Our evaluation already provides evidence that SLR is applicable beyond rigid procedural tasks:
- MMVP evaluates basic visual capabilities, including orientation, position, and viewpoint recognition. SLR improves accuracy by 2-3% over standard SFT while generating fewer reasoning tokens.
- MMStar covers six capability dimensions, including coarse and fine-grained perception. SLR achieves slightly higher accuracy than standard SFT on both subsets.
These results suggest that SLR is not restricted to rigid algorithmic reasoning. It can also capture recurring patterns in less procedural forms of reasoning, while retaining natural language as a fallback for steps that do not correspond to reusable primitives.
[Q4] Codebook construction cost and inference latency
Total cost prior to training. SLR introduces a one-time offline step for codebook construction. The construction pipeline makes approximately 2 LLM calls per training trace on average to decompose reasoning traces and construct the codebook. Approximately 3 short operation strings per training trace are called for embeddings using Gemini Embedding on average. All calls are independent and can be executed in parallel. Importantly, the resulting codebook and processed training data can be reused across different models and multiple training runs. The construction costs are incurred only once for each dataset, rather than being repeated for each model or training run.
[Q4] Codebook construction cost and inference latency
Latency overhead. We measure inference latency for Qwen3-VL-2B-Instruct trained with standard SFT and with SLR. Both models were evaluated on a single NVIDIA L40S GPU, using the same Hugging Face Transformers inference setup, with batch size 1, greedy decoding, and a maximum of 4,096 new tokens. We report the average tokens per sample, mean per-sample latency, and decoding throughput:
| Method | MATH-Vision | MMStar | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tokens | Latency (s) | Tokens/s | Tokens | Latency (s) | Tokens/s | |
| Standard SFT | 2405 | 94.9 | 25.3 | 387 | 15.1 | 25.6 |
| SLR | 1978 | 77.5 | 25.5 | 347 | 13.8 | 25.1 |
SLR reduces latency by 18.3% on MATH-Vision and 8.6% on MMStar, corresponding to output token reduction of 17.8% and 10.3%, respectively. Decoding throughput remains nearly identical for both models (approximately 25 tokens/s). This is expected because SLR retains the same model architecture and autoregressive decoding procedure as standard SFT, with only a small number of additional codebook tokens added to the vocabulary (less than 0.1% of the backbone model vocabulary). The inference follows the normal autoregressive next-token prediction paradigm. Therefore, the latency reductions primarily result from shorter generated sequences.
[W1] Quality of codebook construction
We agree that automated pipelines over large-scale data can introduce errors. To mitigate such noise in the final codebook, our construction pipeline includes quality-control and refinement mechanisms at both the decomposition and clustering stages. We briefly mentioned them in Sec. 4.3 and added additional details in Appendix A.
More broadly, SLR is designed as a modular framework. Its segmentation, decomposition, and clustering components can each be modified or improved as needed without changing the overall framework. Our results show the framework is effective with the current practices, despite the possibility of residual noise. This suggests that its effectiveness does not require a perfectly error-free construction process. More advanced segmentation or clustering methods can also be incorporated directly.
[W2] Semantic consistency and ablations on operation tokens
We thank the reviewer for raising this point, but we consider this ablation as supporting our approach rather than revealing a weakness. They serve as sanity checks to verify that the induced operation tokens carry meaningful, learnable semantics, rather than providing benefits merely through the introduction of additional tokens or a structured output format. Specifically, randomizing token assignments and removing semantic grounding are controlled interventions that disrupt different aspects of the intended operation-to-token correspondence. The resulting degradation is therefore expected and confirms the importance of semantically meaningful primitives.
More importantly, randomizing token assignments leads to a substantial reduction in operation-token utilization. When the same token is assigned to unrelated operations under different contexts across various training instances, there’s no longer a consistent function for the model to learn. Consequently, the model largely stops using these tokens and falls back on its standard reasoning. This behavior is informative because rather than blindly adopting arbitrary tokens, the model learns to avoid tokens that provide no consistent operation-specific information. This, in turn, demonstrates that when operation tokens are assigned meaningful and consistent semantics in the training data, the model can learn to associate them with their corresponding reasoning functions and leverage them to improve reasoning.
Crucially, semantic consistency is not an external condition on which SLR happens to depend; it is an explicit objective of our codebook induction procedure. We construct each operation token to represent a consistent, reusable reasoning function, and train the model to associate that token with the appropriate execution context. Semantic initialization provides an informative prior for the token embeddings, while the model learns to use these discrete representations during training. Deliberately breaking the operation-to-token correspondence would undermine the learnability of these discrete representations. Thus, these ablations demonstrate that SLR's gains arise from learning and utilizing semantically consistent reasoning primitives, rather than from the presence of additional tokens alone.
[W3] / [Q2] Generalization beyond the Qwen family
To directly evaluate generalization beyond the Qwen family, we conduct additional experiments on InternVL3.5-2B, an architecture from a different model family. We apply both SLR and standard SFT using the same training data, hyperparameters and evaluation settings.
SLR achieves higher accuracy than standard SFT while generating shorter responses. These results are consistent with our findings on Qwen models, demonstrating that the benefits of SLR are not specific to the Qwen family. Together with our main experiments, SLR is now validated on four backbones across two model scales (2B and 8B) and two model families (Qwen and InternVL), providing further evidence of its generalizability.