- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an interesting theory for estimating transparent object's relief by characterizing the caustic patterns (i.e., the catastrophe spectrum ). In addition to the theory, the authors provide the detailed analysis (i.e., stability and identifiability) to characterize the applicability of the proposed theory for the object relief estimation. Simulated data is used for evaluating the proposed method.
Critical strengths
First, I have to admit I am not an expert in this particular field, so I provide my evaluation based on my reading and understanding of the paper content.
This paper asks an interesting question: whether the catastrophe spectrum, which is much less informative than the caustic image, can be used for recovering the transparent object's relief. To address this issue, the authors use the tools from dynamical systems and geometries for building the theory, which further lay a foundation for the above problem. Additionally, the authors provide detailed experimental results for evaluating the derived theory by using simulated data.
Critical weaknesses
One of the major concerns is that this method seems not competitive to the CNN baseline while the authors try to answer an interesting question.
Additionally, the theory part of this paper seems to have low readability. First, definition, lemma, proposition, and theorem are dumped without clear contextual explanation. This makes the readers "extremely" hard to following the story in the paper and lack of interesting of reading right after. It is highly recommended to provide a figure or a top-view summary for explaining the flow of the section and the relation between those theoretical components. Besides that, the background of the theoretical components should be provided (probably in Appendix). For instance, the connection of the jump and the catastrophe spectrum to the object relief should be included and the intuition for why nondegenerate cases are more important should be explained.
Overall, the structure of the paper needs some massaging. Right now, it feels like over-fried chicken—hard to digest, even though the ingredients seem promising (i.e., the paper addresses an interesting research question).
Questions for authors
What is notation in line 157?
In addition to the above notation, it is highly recommended to include some explanation and/or intuition for the important variables in the paper, such as and .
Motivation
Thank you to the authors for addressing our concerns. The readability of the theoretical part has improved substantially. However, I still have concerns regarding the CNN experiments, particularly the motivation for considering event-based measurements.
My concerns are mainly twofold.
While the paper poses an interesting question—whether the underlying geometric shape can be recovered from topological events—I am still not fully convinced by the motivation for restricting the observations to event timings. In particular, extracting these events still requires capturing images across the illumination sweep. Given that these images are already available, and that image-based reconstruction achieves substantially better accuracy, why should we discard the image information and consider this more constrained representation in the first place? What practical advantage does this restriction offer?
One possible motivation, as I understand it, is the invariance and robustness of caustic events to variations in camera settings. However, I am not yet convinced that this advantage is sufficiently compelling in the context of modern vision models. With the recent advances in visual representation learning, particularly vision foundation models, it would be interesting to understand whether image-based approaches could also achieve comparable robustness to camera-dependent variations through appropriate training or adaptation. In fact, the paper's own experiments show that data augmentation substantially improves the robustness of the CNN baseline. Therefore, I would like to better understand what unique advantage event-based measurements offer over modern image-based approaches, beyond their analytical tractability.
Also, I share similar concerns with Reviewer nbh3. Based on your response, I understand that the work is fundamentally studying topological questions. However, I am still unclear about what specific ML problems could benefit from the proposed analysis and how it could contribute to the broader ML community. It might be helpful to give some concrete examples how the proposed framework can bridge to the ML applications.