- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
this work builds a representation-dependent theory of PDE identifiability, showing that PSD magnitude reveals only the real fourier symbol while phase information is required for advection and others. The work validates the results over 22 pde families.
Critical strengths
The paper has some theoretical analysis. It separates practical estimation difficulty, structural non-identifiability, and information destroyed by the representation. It has a nice demonstration that good spectral fit can coexist with incorrect inferred parameter ratios
Critical weaknesses
The central theory assumes linear, translation-invariant/constant-coefficient dynamics and much of the numerical study uses controlled periodic simulations. With that said, there is a practical usability gap of the identifiability theory, and the noisy, heterogeneous, and nonlinear biological imaging.
Questions for authors
- could authors include a real-image experiment?
- which core results can be extended to slowly varying coefficients or weakly nonlinear dynamics?
- another question: Why is the identifiability of PDE a topic or interest for ICLR audience?