- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper distinguishes insufficient information from optimization failure in PDE solving. It characterizes when sparse observations restore identifiability through nullspace rank and conditioning, and proposes a target-independent observation-selection portfolio. Experiments cover symbolic search, finite-dimensional reconstruction, and neural PDE solvers.
Critical strengths
- The distinction between information sufficiency and optimization success offers a useful perspective on why small physics residuals may coexist with large solution errors.
- The analysis connects observation count, ambiguity, and stability, supported by paired experiments across multiple solvers and random seeds.
Critical weaknesses
- Strong dependence on finite-dimensional representations. The main portfolio benchmark uses a predefined eight-dimensional solution library with ten observations. Successful recovery therefore relies heavily on the assumed representation. Although the theoretical scope is acknowledged, its relevance to richer PDE solution spaces remains unclear. The authors should distinguish representation-level identifiability from PDE-level uniqueness and evaluate larger libraries and stronger representation mismatch.
- Limited validation beyond controlled settings. The DeepXDE experiments use fixed uniform observations, demonstrating the benefit of additional information rather than the proposed portfolio. The authors should evaluate the complete selection-and-reconstruction pipeline on more complex settings, such as PhySense benchmarks, using a common reconstruction model and equal observation budgets. Comparisons should include classical and learning-based placement methods, with explicit reporting of information requirements and estimation costs.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
Official Comment by Authors
Thank you for recognizing the distinction between information sufficiency and optimization success. Your questions led us to test richer representations, evaluate the full external pipeline and report information and cost requirements explicitly.
W1: Representation dependence, larger libraries and mismatch.
We agree that representation-level identifiability is not PDE-level uniqueness. The revised rank/local results retain their assumptions. POD/RFF reconstruction spaces are not asserted exact nonlinear-PDE kernels. Three independent-reference PDEs use 96 historical training trajectories, 12 ID/12 OOD targets, POD/RFF dimensions 8/16/32/64 and 1%/5% noise. We separate fixed k=10 from k=2q. At q=64,k=10, 54 feature directions remain unresolved. With k=128, POD ID errors [Burgers,Allen–Cahn,2D RD] are [.10319,.02672,.02110], but OOD errors remain [.67664,.16228,.89622] with projection floors [.61464,.14201,.81433]. These evaluation-only floors show persistent mismatch. Larger libraries do not ensure recovery. All methods, unstable cases and actual solver-rank diagnostics remain, with repeats averaged within target. The continuum appendix separately proves a conditional approximation bound, not unrestricted uniqueness (Secs. 3.1/7, Appendix E.7 (p. 27), Table 55 (p. 48), Figures 7–8, pp. 49–50, Appendix K (p. 43)).
W2(a): Complete external pipeline and matched comparisons.
We agree that fixed uniform DeepXDE points test added information. The complete PhySense SST evaluation instead compares portfolio/A/Predictive A/QR/spatial/random/published PGD with the same frozen 19,059,980-parameter reconstructor, 15/25/50-value budgets and paired flow seeds on all 366 released test frames. Classical acquisition uses 9,843 historical fields and public calendar/mask inputs, not current target fields. For q=16 without added measurement noise, the mean relative L2 errors averaged over the three budgets and paired flow seeds are portfolio .07911, A .06654, QR .06452 and PGD .04368. The learned-model placement baseline remains better. Post-hoc paired moving-block sensitivity uses four block lengths and both release-row and calendar-label orderings. Label alignment is assumed, not independently certified. The intervals do not create independent-year or calibrated significance evidence. This is one previously examined dataset/fold, not a new blind dataset (Table 4 (p. 9), Table 40 (p. 31), Table 56 (p. 51)).
W2(b): Information requirements and estimation costs.
We added an information-requirements summary covering 19 experiment–method combinations and separated historical preprocessing, basis/pilot estimation, design and reconstruction. Geometry-only placement need not use POD, although every SST arm shares the history-trained backbone. Scalar budgets do not equate hardware or pixel-access costs. A continuous PGD query can interpolate four pixels. Recorded SST design-work medians are portfolio 210.492 s, A 3.4095 s, Predictive A 3.3689 s and QR .06003 s. Individual A/Predictive A include their QR initializer. Basis/pilot and reconstruction are separate, nested totals are not added, and cache/batched timings are not standalone latency. Original backbone-training and PGD-placement costs remain explicitly unknown, not zero. We therefore do not claim an end-to-end cost advantage (Sec. 5.6, Appendix L.3 (p. 50), Tables 57–59, pp. 52–53).