- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes an unsupervised domain adaptation framework for optic disc and cup segmentation, combining a SegFormer backbone, domain-specific batch normalization, and decoder-level adversarial alignment. Its main contributions are a differentiable cup-to-disc area-ratio regularizer with classifier-conditioned bounds, and a statistical gate that selectively activates this regularizer using a KS test between source ground-truth ratios and unlabeled target predictions.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a clinically relevant segmentation problem by incorporating the optic cup–disc relationship into UDA. Its differentiable cup-to-disc area ratio constraint combines a two-sided extended log-barrier with sample-specific bounds from an auxiliary classifier. This provides a meaningful complement to distribution alignment by incorporating anatomical knowledge while accommodating variation across patients.
-
The evaluation covers all six directed transfers among REFUGE, RIM-ONE-r3, and Drishti-GS, with competitive results in the REFUGE-source comparisons. Beyond performance, the ablations examine when anatomical regularization helps or hurts, motivating its selective application. This strengthens the empirical support for the approach and clarifies its conditions of usefulness.
Critical weaknesses
-
Table 2 states that the results with and without use “the same trained model,” although this term is a training-time loss. It is therefore unclear how these results were obtained and whether they isolate the effect of anatomical regularization. This ambiguity weakens the experimental evidence for a central component and its selective application through the gating mechanism.
-
The classifier ablation is difficult to reconcile with the stated gradient flow. Section 3.5 blocks classification gradients from entering the shared encoder, so without anatomical constraints or other parameter coupling, the classifier should not directly affect segmentation learning. Yet adding it changes OC Dice from 0.835 to 0.819 on Drishti-GS and from 0.803 to 0.823 on RIM-ONE-r3. Without clarification or variability estimates, these results weaken confidence in the attribution of gains to individual components.
Questions for authors
-
Table 2 presents results obtained with and without using based on the same trained model; however, this loss is employed only during the training phase. Could the authors explain why different segmentation results are produced?
-
Section 3.5 states that the classification loss is not backpropagated to the shared encoder, yet segmentation performance changes when the auxiliary classifier is introduced (as shown in Table 1). Could the authors explain the reason for this?
-
The paper adopts the Cup-to-disc Area Ratio as an anatomical constraint but uses vCDR as one of the evaluation metrics. Could the authors further validate the effectiveness of this area ratio constraint regarding vertical anatomical structures?
-
Could the authors provide a sensitivity analysis of key hyperparameters (such as , , and ) to verify the stability of the proposed method?
-
Compared to BEAL, this method employs more parameters, yet some performance gains are limited. Could the authors further discuss the trade-off between model complexity and performance?