acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Sparse Query Compilation for Reverse-Cyclic Multiplayer Nim

Abstract

Exact symbolic reasoning in multiplayer games must preserve more than a binary win/loss outcome. We study the phase-zero reverse-cyclic recurrence for Nim, representing a background position by its response to one additional heap. Let be the number of cyclic outcome classes and let bound the background mass above . For backgrounds with distinct heap heights below and binary-encoded multiplicities, we give a uniform deterministic algorithm for exact response queries. A shielding lemma, arithmetic descriptions of unblocked coordinates, and an existential rank-history identity compile each threshold query into integer-linear systems, each with at most variables. Fixed-dimensional integer programming yields polynomial bit time for every fixed , with exact values, requested positive-label coordinates or absence, and preference-maximizing actions. The bound is XP in upper excess, not an FPT result in alone. The construction is supported by a sparse-response theorem and an explicit obstruction to composing response signatures. Definition-level tests and large-integer checks corroborate the interfaces; existing implementations cover restricted layers rather than the full uniform algorithm. Our results separate compact representation, composition, and exact inference in a multi-valued sequential problem.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
symbolic reasoning, exact algorithms, multiplayer games, Nim, parameterized complexity, integer programming, sparse representations

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_PNuEOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

First, I would like to clarify that I am not familiar with the multiplayer Nim problem. Although I tried my best to understand the paper, I might have misunderstood some aspects.

The paper studies the problem of determining the outcome of a multiplayer Nim where each player has reverse cyclic preferences over the winner. More specifically, the paper considers the setting where one heap can be arbitrarily large and the total size of the other heaps is not overly larger than twice the number of players. It denotes the excess amount as qq. The proposed algorithm compiles the problem into multiple fixed-dimensional integer linear programming and proves that the number of variables in each ILP is bounded by 2$q$+1. The running time of the proposed algorithm has an exponent that depends on qq, and runs in polynomial time when qq is a constant.

Critical strengths

1. The paper proposes a new algorithm and establishes its time complexity bound.

The proposed algorithm is supported by formal proof and analysis. The authors also provide complexity bounds under the stated assumptions, which strengthen the theoretical contribution of the paper.

Critical weaknesses

1. The problem seems to be outside the scope of ICLR.

The paper proposes an algorithm for solving multiplayer Nim under certain constraints. However, this is a theoretical and combinatorial problem, and it does not appear to have a direct connection to machine learning, learning theory, or optimization. The references also seem to have limited connection to the ICLR research community. Therefore, I believe the authors should more clearly explain the relevance of this work to ICLR and discuss real-world applications of the problem.

2. The significance of the results under the considered constraints seems unclear.

This may be due to my lack of expertise in this area, but I believe the authors should further clarify the origin of this problem and why addressing this problem is important. Regardless of whether the paper is outside the scope of ICLR, I also find it difficult to assess the significance of this work within the combinatorics and game theory community. It is unclear whether the constraints of one additional heap and a total size bound are motivated by the significance of the problem itself or by mathematical tractability.

3. It is unclear how reasonable it is to treat qq as a constant.

The polynomial time bound holds only when qq is regarded as a constant, and the degree of the polynomial grows rapidly as qq increases. Furthermore, the fixed-dimensional ILP solver also requires an exponential time over qq. Thus, the running time analysis heavily depends on treating qq as a constant, and I believe the authors should discuss how reasonable this restriction is.

Questions for authors

Questions

Q1. Could the authors further clarify the relevance of this work to ICLR and discuss its potential real-world applications?

Q2. Could the authors further discuss how reasonable the constraints in the problem settings are?

Suggestions

The paper would benefit from adding an introduction to multiplayer Nim including a demonstrating example, a formal problem definition, and discussion on the significance of the problem for the readers who are less familiar with this research area.

Reviewer_pKamOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

A classical Nim game starts with a collection of piles of items. Two (or multiple players) take turns picking at least one item from one of the piles. Under normal play, the player taking the last items wins the game. Under misère-play (that is, the current player wins at a terminal position. This game is polynomial time solvable, discovered by Bouton, with a closed form based on XOR of the binary representation of the pile size. This paper considers multiplayer Nim. In general , multi-player variants depend on preferences and termination conventions. The paper focuses on a specific preference-maximization rule recursively defined as their equation (1), potentially making the game far more complex. 

The main technical result of the paper is algorithmic, based on fixed-dimensional integer programming,  for answering strategic queries associated with this multiplayer game in the setting when the number of players, heap sizes, and heap multiplicities can all be very large even when binary encoded. The paper introduces an interesting sparse response representation. However, to demonstrate the challenge of this multiplayer games, the paper also shows that, unlike in traditional Nim, this introduced signature does not retain enough information to support a universal composition operation.

Their algorithm is based on a structural observation that positive outcome label occurs at most once in the one-heap response, and the largest label m−1 occurs exactly once. In addition, instrumentally, the coordinates of the positive labels are strictly increasing. Based on these structures, the paper established some range of conditions under which their algorithm is efficient.

Critical strengths

In general, I enjoy reading this paper. It is fun. The multiplayer version of the classic Nim is interesting. The enhanced structure also makes this a challenging strategic decision problem.

The paper uncovers some insightful structural of this complex game, which lead to polynomial time algorithm for certain range of condition.

Critical weaknesses

The paper lacks an intractable result for the overall game positions, which might make the investigation based on parameterized complexity better motivated.

At the current state, both the results and the scope of this paper is limited. There seems a lot of room for potential improvement.

Questions for authors

Is this multiplayer Nim PSPACE complete or even NP-hard?

Reviewer_ZUYWOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies reverse-cyclic multiplayer Nim. It represents a position by its response to a position with one extra heap. It proves a sparse-response theorem: each positive label occurs at most once, label m−1 occurs exactly once, and coordinates increase with labels. It gives one small counterexample showing that the signature does not compose additively. The main result, Theorem 4.1, is a deterministic algorithm for threshold, value, label and action queries when heights are below m, multiplicities are binary-encoded, and total mass is at most 2m + q. The result is asserted to be XP but not FPT in q. The implementation does not realize the full algorithm and no performance claims are made.

Critical strengths

• Clear Claims. The paper clearly says that the result is XP and not FPT in q, that it covers only phase zero with heights below m and one large observer heap, and that the implementation realizes only part of the algorithm (q ≤ 4, with a supplied top provider). It also makes no performance or learning claims. • Clean result and Crisp Technical Idea. The sparse-response theorem (each positive label occurs at most once, with increasing coordinates, and label m−1 exactly once) is simple and clean. Turning a sequential prefix maximum into an existential integer-linear query, via shielding, CRT descriptions of open coordinates, and the rank–history identity, is a creative route to polynomial bit time for fixed q. It handles binary-encoded m, multiplicities and observer size without enumeration.

Critical weaknesses

• Poor fit for ICLR. There is no learning component, no synthesis experiment, and no baseline. The “symbolic AI” and verification-interface framing is for motivation only. • Presentation. I found the paper to be completely non-self contained, with many definitions missing and undefined symbols in the early equations. Terms such as “blocked,” “open,” “child top,” and “penultimate-label trigger” appear before they are defined. Algorithm 1 is only a sketch, and Lemma 4.2’s proof is one line. A reader cannot check anything about the main theorem from the first eight pages alone.

Questions for authors

How far does the framework extend beyond the stated regime? What breaks when heights can exceed m, when two arbitrary large heaps are present, or when the phase is nonzero? Is the obstacle conceptual (shielding fails) or only a matter of proof effort?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.