- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose MARMI, a MRI rigid motion correction framework for marginalizing over band-limited clean reference images, with the main argument being that existing motion correction approaches ignore uncertainty and focus on point estimates of clean reference images. This framework consists of two steps: (1) CARS, which generates plausible band-limited samples conditioned on the fully sampled ACS region using a conditional diffusion model, and (2) RAMI which uses a transformer to predict the motion state from each of the shots and band-limited samples. Results on simulated motion indicate that MARMI outperforms two baselines, MoPED and JSMoCo.
Critical strengths
Motion correction in MRI is an important problem and having proper uncertainty estimates of the underlying image (even if band-limited) can help improve trust and reduce motion artifacts in real-world scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
The authors claim Bayesian marginalization of a low-res clean image is the main contribution. However, they opt to train a transformer to estimate reference weights and motion parameters instead of using the analytically available likelihoods for optimization. There is no demonstrated benefit for this approach which is less interpretable, when the motion is so low-dimensional under the rigid parameterization. Additionally, the reference weights are not explicitly used to estimate the motion in the transformer, but rather output in parallel, which is concerning.
The claim that existing methods do not account for uncertainty in the reference image is not true; for example, diffusion-based rigid motion correction [1] the rigid motion parameters and clean image are jointly sampled using diffusion-based posterior sampling, with each diffusion posterior sample representing a new draw of the clean image posterior.
Finally, the writing is difficult to follow and often overcomplicates things. Section 2.3 on CARS spends a full paragraph defining a complex linear map and describing properties of linear operators, just to lead to the residual of the band-limited image. Section 2.4 and 2.5 are very difficult to follow, with many variables introduced.
[1] Levac et al. Accelerated motion correction with deep generative diffusion models, MRM 2024
Questions for authors
How does using the analytic marginalized likelihood for the RAMI step compare to the transformer?
Other methods that also jointly optimize the image and motion estimate continuous update the estimated image; however, MARMI samples clean image candidates at the start and fixes them - what if none of these are close to correct (maybe due to measurement noise, smaller ACS, etc.)? Does it impact the performance of RAMI?