- Rating
- 4(+2)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BridgeUQ, a post-hoc framework for estimating aleatoric uncertainty in pretrained time-series image registration models. Stochastic perturbations around predicted velocity trajectories are assigned a Brownian-bridge prior with spatially varying diffusion variance and an inverse-Gamma hyperprior. An energy-based likelihood incorporates the registration objective, while inference alternates variance MAP estimation and velocity sampling.
Critical strengths
-
A relevant focus on uncertainty across complete deformation trajectories. The paper addresses an important distinction between estimating uncertainty independently for image pairs and representing dependencies across a time sequence. Centering perturbations on an existing prediction also provides a useful route for investigating uncertainty without modifying the original registration network’s parameters.
-
An explicit and interpretable temporal prior. The Brownian-bridge formulation makes the assumed temporal covariance and endpoint behavior transparent, while the spatial variance field allows different anatomical locations to have different perturbation magnitudes. This is more interpretable than introducing unstructured noise without specifying its temporal organization, although the suitability of the particular assumptions requires further validation.
-
Encouraging uncertainty-ranking results across multiple backbones and data settings. BridgeUQ achieves lower temporally averaged nAUSC than the reported alternatives on both real-data settings for all four tested backbones. These experiments provide evidence of practical utility beyond a single network configuration.
Critical weaknesses
Before discussing the critical weaknesses, I would like to emphasize that I find the paper sufficiently novel and of high enough overall quality to warrant acceptance. However, the experimental results do not fully substantiate all of the claimed advantages. If my concerns are adequately addressed, I would be willing to increase my score.
1. The variance update is not clearly consistent with the stated conditional posterior.
The method alternates between MAP estimation of the diffusion variance , conditioned on the current velocity trajectory , and posterior sampling of . However, Eq. (11) includes , which should vanish when is held fixed under the stated model. It is unclear whether this is simply an unsimplified zero term or whether the implementation differentiates through a dependence , which would require a different explanation of the optimization objective. This ambiguity does not by itself establish an implementation error, but it needs to be resolved to assess the validity of the inference procedure. Moreover, using a point estimate of rather than integrating over its posterior introduces an approximation whose impact on uncertainty estimates is not established in the main manuscript.
2. The evaluation does not sufficiently establish calibrated, temporally joint uncertainty.
The principal metrics (per-frame nAUSC, Dice, and Jacobian statistics) provide useful evidence about uncertainty ranking and registration quality, but do not directly assess the correctness of cross-time dependencies. Likewise, the correlation between per-frame variance and registration loss in Figure 4(a) does not establish accurate temporal covariance. For example, independently permuting sample identities across time preserves each frame's sample distribution while disrupting the joint trajectories. Ranking metrics are also unchanged by positive rescaling of uncertainty scores, so they cannot establish calibration of uncertainty magnitude. Consequently, additional controls and calibration measurements are needed to substantiate the paper's central claim of a meaningful spatiotemporal posterior, rather than only informative marginal uncertainty maps.
Questions for authors
-
What objective is actually optimized during the diffusion-variance update? When updating , is the current velocity trajectory held fixed? Under the stated factorization, the registration-energy contribution in Eq. (11) should then be zero. Is this term zero in the implementation, or do gradients propagate through a reparameterized trajectory ?
-
How does replacing the diffusion-variance posterior with a MAP estimate affect uncertainty quantification? Please clarify which posterior distribution the alternating procedure is intended to approximate. Have you assessed the effect of fixing , rather than marginalizing or sampling it, on the resulting uncertainty estimates?
-
Can you directly evaluate probabilistic calibration and joint trajectory uncertainty? On the synthetic sequences with known ground-truth deformations, could you report empirical coverage at several nominal credible levels, together with interval widths?
6 comments
Reminder: Author-Reviewer Discussion Period
Dear Reviewer,
As the author-reviewer discussion period ends on November 18th, we kindly remind you that we will be unable to communicate after that date. We would appreciate your feedback on whether our response has addressed your concerns. If you have any further questions or need additional clarification, please let us know before the discussion period concludes.
Thank you for your attention.
Best regards,
The Authors
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. I am raising my score to 3 (Weak Accept).
However, Q2 concerns uncertainty in the estimated variance field itself, not whether variance differs across voxels. A spatially varying variance field can still be fixed at its MAP estimate. Your constant-variance ablation demonstrates the benefit of spatial adaptation, but does not assess the effect of ignoring the variance field’s posterior uncertainty.
To address Q2, please compare the MAP-based approach with sampling or marginalizing the variance posterior, for example on synthetic data, and assess changes in trajectory coverage and interval widths. Alternatively, a convincing justification that the MAP approximation has negligible impact would suffice. If this concern is resolved, I will raise my score further.
Rebuttal by Authors
We thank the reviewer's valuable comments. Please see our point-by-point responses below.
We thank the reviewer for this observation. Here we confirm that the current velocity trajectory v is held fixed when optimizing over σ, making the gradient of the first term with respect to σ zero. No gradients are propagated through the reparameterized velocity trajectory. To avoid this confusion, we have removed this term from Eq. (11) in the revised manuscript.
The alternating procedure is intended to approximate the posterior in p(v∣σ,I;v^) defined in Eq. 12.
Please see the Fig. 4(b) of the main paper regarding the effect of fixing σ on the uncertainty map. We have also included the quantitative results for the fixed-variance in Table 1. As shown in the table below, applying a fixed variance introduces the same level of perturbation at every voxel regardless of the underlying anatomical structure, which results in uncertainty maps that are less anatomically meaningful. As a result, the AUSC values are close to 1, indicating that the estimated uncertainties have limited discriminative power.
Table 1. Effect of fixed diffusion variance for BridgeUQ$_{\mathrm{TLRN}}$ on the cardiac MRI dataset.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. We agree that evaluating probabilistic calibration on synthetic data with known ground-truth deformations provides a more direct assessment of the uncertainty estimates. We have therefore added an evaluation of trajectory-level uncertainty calibration at multiple nominal credible levels (50%, 80%, 90%, and 95%). Specifically, we construct simultaneous credible bands [1] for the deformation trajectories using the maximum standardized deviation across all temporal frames and both displacement components. We then calculate empirical simultaneous coverage, defined as the proportion of evaluated voxels for which the entire ground-truth deformation trajectory falls within the corresponding credible bands. We also report the average band width of the uncertainty estimates.
Table. 2 show that our Brownian bridge prior achieves empirical coverage closest to the nominal levels across all evaluated credible levels, while producing substantially narrower credible intervals than the two baselines. This demonstrates that our method provides better calibrated uncertainty estimates, achieving a more favorable balance between calibration and informativeness.
Table 2. Empirical trajectory coverage at various nominal credible levels, reported as coverage/interval width.
References
[1] Sigrunn H Sørbye and Håvard Rue. Simultaneous credible bands for latent gaussian models. Scandinavian Journal of Statistics, 38(4):712–725, 2011