- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes 3DOSA, a physical adversarial attack method to generate physically realizable adversarial camouflage against autonomous driving. The authors find two main limitations of existing solutions, namely gradient leakage and geometric misalignment. To address these, 3DOSA combines: 1) 3D Gaussian Grouping for explicitly separating optimizable object surfaces from the surrounding scene; 2) 2D Gaussian Splatting (2DGS) for surface-aligned adversarial texture optimization; and 3) Expectation over Transformation (EoT) for improving robustness across camera viewpoints and illumination conditions. The authors then apply the proposed the solution to both stereo matching models by manipulating the predicted disparity of a vehicle and object detection.
Critical strengths
-
The knowledge gap is clear, e.g. the mismatch between digital optimization and real-world 3D geometry is indeed a concrete limitation of physical adversarial attack.
-
The combination of explicit 3D target isolation and surface-constrained radiance optimization also make sense to me.
-
The stereo matching evaluation is also a useful choice.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty seems limited. All the related components are from existing literature, making the contribution more like a integration of existing techniques.
-
There is still gap between the experiments and the realistic traffic. It’s expected to perform experiments on more real world settings.
-
More explanations are needed on why the same rendering framework can support both stereo matching and detection even when the attack is optimised in a task specific way.
-
The whole system seems very large. e.g. the method uses many multi-view observations, segmentation supervision, and a differentiable 3D scene reconstruction. The practicality of obtaining these inputs for a real-world target deserves further investigation.
Questions for authors
-
Can you explain intuitively on the chosen of those existing components?
-
What will be the main challenges when apply the proposed solution in real world traffic?
-
How to guarantee the practicality of having access to all the required inputs of the system in real world settings?
Official comments
After reviewing all reviewers' comment and authors' reply. I decided to keep my score.
I have read the paper and used AI to generate partial reviews. Frankly, I do not have sufficient expertise to assess this submission.