- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on the manga-to-animation task. They find that text-based pipelines lose visual fidelity, while direct video generation misinterprets panel order and dialogue. Thus, they propose Manga2Animate, a multi-agent framework that iteratively refines animation scripts and storyboards through creator-reviewer collaboration and dual-level feedback. To validate their method, they conduct several experiments, including baseline comparisons, component ablations, comparisons across generators, and a 37-participant user study. The experimental results demonstrate that Manga2Animate better preserves the source plot, character identities, and art style while improving consistency across shots.
Critical strengths
-
This paper proposes Manga2Animate, which is the first automated framework that turns existing manga into animation.
-
This paper establishes an evaluation protocol for manga-to-animation generation, which paves the way for future studies.
-
They test their method on the proposed benchmark and further validate their results through a user study.
Critical weaknesses
-
The introduction lacks citations when characterizing prior methods. Its broad claim that current video models cannot understand manga also needs clearer qualification. For example, Figure 2 illustrates specific failures but does not establish this broader conclusion. The authors should cite the relevant methods and clarify the scope and evidence behind these claims.
-
Table 2 supports the overall benefit of the reviewer-equipped pipeline (Sec. 4.7). Removing a reviewer also reduces the candidate counts. A comparison with equal candidate counts would clarify the added value of reviewer selection.
-
Section 3.4 adopts two refinement rounds while motivating this choice by API cost control. Table A4 only compares one and two rounds. No analysis of quality versus API cost explains why refinement stops after two rounds.
-
Minor suggestion: Specific agent models are listed in the Appendix. Briefly naming them in the main text would make the system's external model dependencies clearer.
-
The paper claims that their method can faithfully turn existing manga into animation. However, the video evaluation lacks separate assessments of source-grounded action and expression fidelity. Motion metrics and frame aesthetics do not establish faithful enactment of the manga. Figure 7 reports broad preferences without dedicated action, expression, or timing criteria.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors review and revise the introduction, adding appropriate citations to claims that require supporting references? In particular, please check statements about prior methods and their limitations.
-
Could the authors compare reviewer selection with random selection using the same number of candidates?
-
Could the authors compare generation quality and API cost across different refinement-round counts? Please explain the rationale for choosing N = 2.
-
Could the authors briefly list the LLM backends for the creator and reviewer agents in the main text?
-
Could the authors separately evaluate source-grounded action and expression fidelity, alongside motion timing and naturalness? Task-specific metrics or targeted human ratings would help.