- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents FRAMEWORKERS, a multi-agent framework for automated video production. A Director dynamically plans and revises tasks, while an Assistant coordinates specialized sub-agents and manages scripts, reference assets, and generated content through a shared Workspace. Unlike a fixed pipeline, the framework can adapt its workflow to different user inputs and recover from intermediate failures. The Director is trained with supervised fine-tuning followed by GRPO to improve sub-agent selection and ordering. Experiments evaluate routing accuracy, failure recovery, integration of unseen sub-agents, and end-to-end video quality, reporting improvements over general-purpose LLM planners and existing video-production systems.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed FrameWorkers replaces the fixed pipeline with orchestration composed at runtime, with dynamic task management, workspace-grounded execution, and learned routing, which is reasonable and interesting as the ai video production do not usually strictly follow the same and fixed structure.
-
The performances of the multi-agent framework are impressive.
-
The whole paper is well writen and easy to understand.
Critical weaknesses
- The technical novelty needs to be clearer. Although the paper discusses prior work and compares with MovieAgent, it remains unclear what the Dynamic Task Stack and Workspace add beyond existing multi-agent planning and coordination mechanisms. For example, Magentic-One[1] already supports dynamic task delegation, progress tracking, and replanning after failures, while Plan-and-Act[2] separates planning from execution and trains the planner. A more direct comparison would help clarify which mechanisms are new and which are adapted for video production.
[1] Adam Fourney et al. Magentic-One: A Generalist Multi-Agent System for Solving Complex Tasks. arXiv preprint arXiv:2411.04468, 2024.
[2] Lutfi Eren Erdogan et al. Plan-and-Act: Improving Planning of Agents for Long-Horizon Tasks. arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.09572, 2025.
-
The generated videos in supplementary are only from FrameWorkers. There seems to be a lack of qualitative comparison with previous methods (only frame comparison in the main manuscript), which may weaken the effectiveness of the proposed method.
-
Insufficient details and ablation results. (1) Insufficient details on maintaining cross-shot consistency: The paper mentions persistent identity anchors in the Workspace and evaluator-based rework, particularly in Figure 2 and the discussion of Figure 4. However, the method section does not clearly explain how these mechanisms maintain character/prop/scene consistency across shots. (2) Limited end-to-end ablation of Director training: Tables 1 and 2 show that SFT and GRPO improve routing accuracy. However, it remains unclear how much these improvements contribute to the final video quality (better to provide qualitative results).
Questions for authors
-
About details on maintaining consistency: How are the reference assets created, selected, and passed to the generation models? How is visual drift detected, and what triggers regeneration? A more explicit description, together with ablations of reference reuse and evaluator-based rework, would help explain where the consistency gains come from.
-
About ablation study: Could the authors compare pretrained, SFT-only, and SFT+GRPO Directors within the same framework, while keeping the Assistant, sub-agents, generation backends, and rework budget fixed? This would help show whether better routing leads to better instruction following and cross-shot consistency, beyond the gains provided by shared reference assets and evaluator-based rework.
10 comments
W1. Technical Novelty over Magentic-One and Plan-and-Act Part 2
Furthermore, descriptor-conditioned planning enables FrameWorkers to extend its production capabilities without retraining the Director. The Selection Accuracy reported in Table 4 measures whether the Director correctly selects Sub-agents unseen during training based on task requirements, reaching 93.0% and 99.2% for ComedyAgent and ScreenwriterAgent, respectively. To further evaluate whether these new capabilities can be integrated into the complete production workflow, we additionally assess whether the task chains predicted by the Director correctly invoke the new Sub-agents and successfully complete the entire execution process. With runtime Replanning, the Joint Success rates reach 90.5% and 97.5% for ComedyAgent and ScreenwriterAgent, respectively. Table 8 in Appendix E further illustrates the diverse input configurations and output capabilities supported by the framework. These results demonstrate the design advantages of FrameWorkers: by dynamically selecting, organizing, and coordinating specialized Sub-agents, it supports different types of video-production tasks without redesigning a production workflow for each requirement.
To further validate the practical contributions of these mechanisms, we separately evaluate the recovery correctness of the Dynamic Task Stack, post-recovery execution performance, and the Workspace's cross-stage asset-resolution capability.
(1) Dynamic Task Stack Ablation
The Dynamic Task Stack improves the reliability of runtime failure recovery by explicitly maintaining execution states and modifying pending tasks. To validate this mechanism, we start from manually verified correct production chains and construct controlled perturbation cases by injecting three types of runtime failures: T1 (quality-check failure), T2 (one missing required upstream Producer), and T3 (two missing upstream Producers). These failures require the Replanner to restore the necessary production capabilities and their dependencies based on the current execution state. We construct 1,556 and 466 perturbed cases on DCE and DCH, respectively.
To distinguish the effects of execution-history visibility from those of structured task updates, we compare three recovery strategies. All methods use the same Replanning LLM, user goal, Agent Descriptors, and failure report; only the execution-state information available to the Replanner and the plan-update mechanism differ.
| Method | Information Available to the Replanner | Plan Update Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Stateless Full Regeneration | User goal and failure report, without execution history | Regenerate the entire plan and execute from scratch |
| Magentic-One-style Log-aware Full Regeneration | User goal and an execution log containing the initial plan, completed steps, and failure records | Regenerate the entire plan and execute from scratch |
| FrameWorkers | Completed, failed, and pending steps in the Task Stack | Modify pending tasks through Suffix Editing while preserving completed artifacts |
Here, Magentic-One-style Log-aware Full Regeneration is a controlled comparison strategy inspired by its Task/Progress Ledger approach, not a complete reproduction of the official Magentic-One system.
All methods are evaluated using the same recovery-correctness criterion: the recovered production chain must contain all required capabilities and satisfy Producer–Consumer dependencies.
We evaluate Gemini 2.5 Flash and Gemini 2.5 Pro as Replanners on DCE and DCH to measure Recovery Correctness under the different strategies. The task-chain structures in DCE appeared in the Director's training set, whereas DCH contains task-chain structures unseen during training. The values in parentheses indicate the number of controlled perturbation cases constructed by injecting T1–T3 failures. The Gemini 2.5 Pro experiment on DCE uses 600 of these cases.
W1. Technical Novelty over Magentic-One and Plan-and-Act Part 3
The percentages in the table denote Recovery Correctness: whether the task chain after recovery contains all required production capabilities and satisfies the corresponding Producer–Consumer dependency constraints.
| Method | Gemini 2.5 Flash / DCE (1,556) | Gemini 2.5 Flash / DCH (466) | Gemini 2.5 Pro / DCE (600) | Gemini 2.5 Pro / DCH (466) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stateless Full Regeneration | 88.4% | 86.5% | 89.7% | 90.6% |
| Magentic-One-style Log-aware Full Regeneration | 98.3% | 98.5% | 93.0% | 93.1% |
| FrameWorkers | 99.0% | 99.4% | 99.2% | 99.8% |
FrameWorkers improves over Stateless Full Regeneration by 9.2–12.9pp across all four experimental settings, with all corresponding 95% CIs excluding zero. This demonstrates the importance of execution-history visibility and state management for reliable recovery.
Compared further with Log-aware Full Regeneration, FrameWorkers achieves gains of +0.7pp (95% CI [−0.1, 1.5]) and +0.9pp ([−0.4, 2.2]) with Gemini 2.5 Flash; neither difference is statistically significant. With Gemini 2.5 Pro, however, FrameWorkers achieves improvements of +6.2pp ([4.1, 8.4]) and +6.7pp ([3.7, 10.1]), respectively.
These results show that execution-history visibility already improves recovery performance substantially. Beyond this, the Task Stack organizes execution states into directly editable task records and updates the remaining production workflow through Suffix Editing, further improving recovery correctness with Gemini 2.5 Pro.
(2) Execution-level Validation
The Task Stack not only supports correct recovery planning but also improves task completion after failures and reduces redundant execution by reusing completed work. The preceding experiments primarily verify whether the recovered plans contain the required capabilities and satisfy dependency constraints, but they do not directly reflect actual execution outcomes and execution overhead after recovery. We therefore conduct additional Execution-level Validation.
Specifically, we construct 75 controlled failure cases, spanning T1, T2, and T3, with 25 cases per type. All methods use the same initial production plans and failure conditions, and run with the same Director, Assistant, Workspace, and task execution framework. Only the post-failure recovery strategy is varied.
Fixed Pipeline stops upon failure; Stateless Regeneration regenerates and executes the entire plan in a new Workspace; and FrameWorkers preserves completed artifacts in the original Workspace, modifies the remaining tasks through Suffix Editing, and continues execution. The latter two strategies allow up to two rounds of Replanning.
We evaluate three metrics: Completion, whether all required production capabilities are completed in a valid dependency order; Agent Executions / Case, the total number of Agent executions per case; and Re-executions / Case, the number of repeated executions of previously completed tasks.
| Method | Completion | Agent Executions / Case | Re-executions / Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed Pipeline | 0% | 1.63 | 0 |
| Stateless Regeneration | 90.7% | 8.61 | 1.65 |
| FrameWorkers | 100% | 6.57 | 0.05 |
FrameWorkers achieves 100% Task Completion, compared with 90.7% for Stateless Regeneration. At the same time, average Agent Executions decrease from 8.61 to 6.57, and Re-executions decrease from 1.65 to 0.05.
These results validate the execution-level role of the Task Stack: by preserving completed tasks and their artifacts, FrameWorkers can continue executing the remaining work after failure recovery without re-executing the entire production workflow, thereby improving task completion and reducing execution overhead.
W1. Technical Novelty over Magentic-One and Plan-and-Act Part 1
We thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation of FrameWorkers and the positive assessment of our system design and experimental results. In response to the concerns regarding technical novelty, End-to-end Video Evaluation, cross-shot consistency, and Director Training, we further clarify the relevant technical design and provide additional experiments and analyses.
W1. Technical Novelty over Magentic-One and Plan-and-Act
FrameWorkers addresses dynamic task orchestration and cross-stage multimodal coordination in complex video production. Unlike general-purpose Agent Task Planning, video production involves interdependent stages such as scripting, storyboarding, character and scene references, KeyFrames, video, audio, and final composition. Each stage requires not only correct task scheduling but also specific multimodal assets generated in preceding stages. Moreover, generation failures, quality feedback, or changes in user requirements may necessitate revising subsequent work without re-executing costly generation steps that have already been completed.
To address these challenges, FrameWorkers combines three mechanisms: (1) a Learned Director, which dynamically selects production capabilities and plans execution dependencies based on user requirements; (2) a Dynamic Task Stack, which explicitly maintains task execution states and modifies pending tasks through Suffix Editing while preserving completed work; and (3) a Multimodal Workspace, which manages media assets generated across stages and dynamically resolves and passes the appropriate assets according to Sub-agent input requirements.
Comparison with Magentic-One and Plan-and-Act. The main design differences among the three frameworks are summarized below:
The central technical contribution of FrameWorkers is the integration of dynamic task planning, incremental execution, and multimodal asset coordination, allowing video-production workflows to adapt continuously to task requirements and runtime states without predefined fixed Pipelines for different tasks. This design requires not only selecting which Sub-agents to execute, but also maintaining task states during production, preserving existing results, and correctly organizing media-asset dependencies across stages.
Specifically, unlike Magentic-One, which manages task progress and coordinates execution through Task/Progress Ledgers, the Dynamic Task Stack in FrameWorkers organizes task states into a directly editable execution structure. The Director can adjust the pending suffix through ADD and DELETE, while the Workspace continually preserves artifacts produced by completed tasks, allowing the recovered production workflow to reuse existing results directly. At the same time, through a Strict-out, Loose-in Interface, the Workspace dynamically resolves the required inputs based on Sub-agent input requirements and semantic asset descriptions, without relying on fixed Producer–Consumer wiring. The Task Stack addresses how to incrementally modify the production workflow, while the Workspace addresses how tasks in the modified workflow correctly retrieve and reuse existing media assets. Together, they support continuously running multimodal video production.
Compared with Plan-and-Act, the Learned Director in FrameWorkers does not merely learn to generate task plans; it must also infer the required production capabilities and their dependencies from heterogeneous Sub-agent Descriptors, so that the resulting plans can be used directly for subsequent task execution and asset coordination. This design enables the Director to organize task-chain structures unseen during training, rather than being restricted to predefined production workflows. Tables 1 and 2 provide experimental evidence: on DCH, which contains unseen task-chain structures, the trained Director achieves 81.5% Chain Accuracy, an improvement of 33.5pp over the 48.0% achieved with SFT-only training.