- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Pixelle-Video, an automated video-production framework that combines a stateful storyboard, narration-based temporal coordination, and persistent visual memory. Experiments on three benchmarks demonstrate improvements in visual consistency, cross-modal synchronization, and video quality.
Critical strengths
The proposed video generation agent has practical value and demonstrates strong performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
The literature review needs improvement. It mainly lists state-of-the-art approaches without clearly explaining how Pixelle-Video differs from them or what constitutes its novelty. The framework appears to be an engineering integration of LLMs, VLMs, and visual generation tools, making it difficult to identify the key technical contributions. The authors should clarify the specific limitations of existing video-production systems that motivate their designs and explain how each component addresses these limitations, rather than relying on broad statements about the challenges of video generation.
-
Important implementation details are missing. For example, the temporal coordination mechanism does not clearly explain how narration duration guides video generation or how actions within each shot are aligned with the events described in the narration. Matching durations alone does not guarantee event-level synchronization. Moreover, the cited MM-StoryAgent already uses narration duration to organize multimodal composition, so the authors should clarify what additional coordination their mechanism provides and how it is implemented. Additionally, the used AI tools ands all the parameters should stated for reproducibility.
-
The experimental coverage and statistical analysis are limited. Evaluation on only 35 prompts makes it difficult to assess the robustness of the improvements or their generalization to longer videos.
Questions for authors
-
How is narration duration incorporated into video generation, and how are duration mismatches handled? How does this mechanism differ substantively from adjusting video duration to match the narration after generation?
-
In the supplementary material, Pixelle-Video produces portrait-format videos with fixed black backgrounds, titles, and subtitles, while the compared methods primarily produce landscape-format videos. Were these final videos used for automatic evaluation? Were the added regions removed and preprocessing standardized across methods? If not, does the ranking remain unchanged when evaluation is restricted to the actual generated visual content under a common preprocessing protocol?
-
When visual memory is removed, are inspection and regeneration also disabled? What timing strategy replaces temporal coordination in the corresponding ablation?
-
Since the framework relies on multiple AI models and tools, the authors should compare its computational efficiency with existing systems, including end-to-end generation time, peak GPU memory usage, and computational cost where measurable.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer WbW6 (Part 2 of 2)
W3-2. Generalization to Longer Videos.
We further extended the target duration from 1 to 3 minutes. Background and Subject Consistency decline by 15.3% and 42.4% for ShortGPT, and 10.6% and 26.0% for OpenMontage, respectively. In contrast, Pixelle-Video maintains high scores on both metrics.
| Method | Output Duration | Motion Smooth. | Background Consist. | Subject Consist. | Style & Scene Self-Consist. | Individual Action | Character Interaction | Scene Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pixelle-Video | 1 min | 0.9906 | 0.8927 | 0.8389 | 0.8182 | 3.4340 | 3.5679 | 3.5571 |
| Pixelle-Video | 3 min | 0.9908 | 0.9042 | 0.8323 | 0.8204 | 3.3111 | 3.4667 | 3.4857 |
| MoneyPrinterTurbo | 1 min | 0.9780 | 0.7308 | 0.5225 | 0.4697 | 1.7012 | 2.2500 | 2.4871 |
| MoneyPrinterTurbo | 3 min | 0.9842 | 0.6983 | 0.3985 | 0.3969 | 1.4148 | 2.3429 | 2.5429 |
| OpenMontage | 1 min | 0.9886 | 0.8598 | 0.7242 | 0.5686 | 2.6424 | 2.7690 | 3.1276 |
| OpenMontage | 3 min | 0.9906 | 0.7689 | 0.5359 | 0.4754 | 2.6131 | 2.7976 | 3.0476 |
| ShortGPT | 1 min | 0.9839 | 0.7874 | 0.5872 | 0.4962 | 2.0388 | 2.4283 | 2.7754 |
| ShortGPT | 3 min | 0.9883 | 0.6672 | 0.3383 | 0.5033 | 1.9192 | 2.1777 | 2.5725 |
| Anim-Director | 1 min | 0.9819 | 0.8517 | 0.7876 | 0.7727 | 2.7582 | 2.7607 | 3.1571 |
| Anim-Director | 3 min | 0.9826 | 0.7744 | 0.6061 | 0.7189 | 2.6269 | 2.8254 | 3.1071 |
| ScriptAgent | 1 min | 0.9859 | 0.8346 | 0.7004 | 0.7812 | 2.3990 | 2.5064 | 2.9743 |
| ScriptAgent | 3 min | 0.9871 | 0.8107 | 0.6314 | 0.7281 | 2.3831 | 2.5873 | 2.6627 |
Q2. Fairness of Automatic Evaluation Across Video Layouts.
Thank you for raising this concern. The black backgrounds, titles, and subtitles in our supplementary videos are added solely for presentation. For automatic evaluation, we evaluate only the generated visual content across all methods, so presentation layouts do not affect the reported scores or rankings.
Q3. Settings of the Ablation Variants.
The original w/o Persistent Visual Memory disables VLM inspection and regeneration, removes cross-shot references, and switches from I2V to T2V. To isolate these effects, we add two variants: w/o VLM Inspector and Regen., which retains visual references, and w/o Cross-shot Ref., which retains I2V generation with independently generated first-frame anchors.
The full configuration achieves the best results across all nine metrics. Removing inspection and regeneration reduces Character Interaction, while removing cross-shot references decreases Subject Consistency and Style & Scene Self-Consistency. These results demonstrate the complementary benefits of diagnostic refinement and persistent visual references.
| Method | Motion Smooth. | Background Consist. | Subject Consist. | Style & Scene Self-Consist. | Individual Action | Character Interaction | Scene Score | Text–Video Consist. | Video–Audio Sync. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pixelle-Video | 0.9906 | 0.8927 | 0.8389 | 0.8182 | 3.4340 | 3.5679 | 3.5571 | 0.8197 | 0.5939 |
| w/o VLM Inspector and Regen. | 0.9904 | 0.8871 | 0.8326 | 0.8138 | 2.9511 | 2.9392 | 3.1137 | 0.7965 | 0.5898 |
| w/o Cross-shot Ref. | 0.9895 | 0.8457 | 0.6190 | 0.5511 | 3.3615 | 3.2393 | 3.4216 | 0.8048 | 0.5893 |
| w/o Persistent Visual Memory | 0.9895 | 0.8337 | 0.5724 | 0.4173 | 2.9092 | 3.0107 | 3.1000 | 0.7804 | 0.5816 |
For w/o Cross-Modal Temporal Coordination, we adopt MoneyPrinterTurbo's composition-time matching: generate 5-second clips without narration-derived timing, concatenate visuals and narrations separately and loop or truncate visuals to match the narration.
Q4. Computational Cost.
For efficiency evaluation, we targeted one-minute outputs using Wan3.0 at 720p (USD 0.090/s) and Wan2.7-image (USD 0.030/image), including token costs for DeepSeek-v4-Flash and Qwen3.7-Plus. Pixelle-Video costs USD 0.0964 per video second, averaging 25.6 model calls per video.
Some baselines cost less per output second than the video generation model's rate because MoneyPrinterTurbo, ShortGPT, and ScriptAgent extend clips by holding their final frames to match narration durations without generating additional footage. These simpler workflows achieve weaker visual consistency and content alignment (Table 1 and case studies). Pixelle-Video invests additional computation in persistent visual references and VLM-guided refinement, averaging 0.63 regenerations per image (5.39 per video), to achieve stronger performance.
| Method | API Cost/s (USD) | Model Calls/Video | Runtime (min)/Video |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pixelle-Video | 0.0964 | 25.6 | 19.51 |
| MoneyPrinterTurbo | 0.0394 | 10.9 | 14.32 |
| OpenMontage | 0.0900 | 5.0 | 19.21 |
| ShortGPT | 0.0854 | 14.4 | 19.51 |
| Anim-Director | 0.0977 | 29.9 | 25.67 |
| ScriptAgent | 0.0892 | 13.1 | 29.23 |
Reply to authors
Thanks for your response. I have no questions.
Response to Reviewer WbW6 (Part 1 of 2)
We sincerely appreciate your constructive feedback. Below we address your concerns point by point, and we have accordingly updated the manuscript.
Thank you for the detailed suggestion. We have revised Section 2 to connect the limitations of prior pipelines to our design and clarify the differences.
Our work targets two coordination limitations in existing video-production pipelines:
Both mechanisms coordinate visual and temporal information through the shared Stateful Storyboard throughout production.
Narration duration directly determines the requested clip length before video generation. Pixelle-Video first synthesizes each shot's narration and stores its measured duration in the Stateful Storyboard. The video generator receives the shot content, the visual anchor from Persistent Visual Memory, and this duration as the requested clip length. Any residual mismatch is handled per shot by trimming excess video or extending the final frame.
Unlike MM-StoryAgent, which uses narration duration to set image-clip playback length during composition, Pixelle-Video incorporates it into the video generation request itself. Thus, narration duration guides generation rather than serving solely as a target for post-generation adjustment.
We have clarified the model configurations and parameters in Section 4.1.
Robustness. We repeated end-to-end generation three times for each method on the same 35 prompts and report mean ± standard deviation across runs. Pixelle-Video achieves the highest mean scores across all nine metrics, with limited variation across runs, supporting its robustness.
Evaluations on more tasks. We further expanded evaluation to all 75 DirectorBench instructions, using the same experimental settings and nine metrics. Pixelle-Video ranks first across all nine metrics, consistent with our main findings.