- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a hierarchical repair framework for maintaining consistency in agent-based long video generation. It introduces an adaptive reference policy and an evaluation-driven refinement process to address narrative and visual inconsistencies without relying on costly, full-pipeline re-generation. Additionally, the authors propose a novel metric, Reconstructed Story Semantic Alignment (RSSA), to quantify the semantic fidelity of the generated videos against the source story.
Critical strengths
- Strong practical motivation & clear presentation: The paper addresses a highly relevant problem—repairing narrative and visual inconsistencies in long video generation efficiently. The proposed agentic pipeline is logically articulated, and the overall writing is of high quality.
Critical weaknesses
-
Weak experimental validation for an engineering framework: The proposed hierarchical approach is primarily an engineering integration rather than a fundamental algorithmic innovation. As an engineering-focused system, it must strictly prove its practical value. However, despite claiming to solve the inefficiency of prior methods, it lacks quantitative comparisons of computational cost or runtime. Furthermore, the evaluation scale of merely 20 source stories is fundamentally too small to demonstrate generalization or practical reliability.
-
Limitations in the RSSA evaluation design: While the motivation behind proposing the RSSA metric is meaningful, its specific design is inadequate. The metric's reliance on sparse frame extraction makes it difficult to guarantee that continuous temporal dynamics are accurately captured. This limitation significantly undermines the soundness of the narrative evaluation itself.
Questions for authors
Clarification Requests:
- Could you provide quantitative data comparing the computational cost and runtime against baseline methods to better understand the efficiency of your framework?
Suggestions for Future Work / Revisions:
- Expand the evaluation scale and test cross-model capabilities by using different foundation video models to better prove practical engineering value.
- Redesign the RSSA evaluation metric to better capture continuous temporal dynamics.
- Optimize the paper's layout.