- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes StoryRelay, a reference-conditioned autoregressive visual storytelling framework that combines persistent references with evolving visual history. The method introduces Autoregressive Story Modeling (ASM) for next-keyframe prediction, Shot-Aware Identity Grounding (SIG) for identity preservation, and a feedback-controlled rollout for history selection and generation correction. Experiments demonstrate improvements in identity consistency, character-count matching, and prompt alignment over BAGEL.
Critical strengths
- The paper writing is clear, and the motivation of combining persistent references with autoregressive visual history is reasonable.
- The proposed identity grounding mechanism is clean, providing spatial supervision across references and historical frames without requiring masks at inference.
- The experimental results are promising, showing improvements in identity preservation and prompt alignment, with ablations and qualitative examples.
Critical weaknesses
- Fig 5 is overly complicated, making the figure hard to read and understand. Refining the figure to be more simple and highlight the core designs would enhance the paper.
- The inference efficiency analysis is missing. The rollout allows up to four generation attempts per shot with additional VLM calls, but the paper lacks comparisons of inference latency and computational overhead.
- The evaluation could be strengthened with more controlled comparisons and analysis of performance over longer sequences, given that the training stories contain 3.67 shots on average.
- The related work section could be refined to further position the paper with respect to recent reference-conditioned generation methods, such as Scaling Zero-Shot Reference-to-Video Generation (CVPR 2026).
Questions for authors
Please see weakness above.
Discussion
Dear Reviewers, The authors have posted their rebuttal. Please review their responses and engage in the discussion.
Best, AC