- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
AdaShare is a training-free framework for generating images with consistent subject identity and visual style across different prompts. It combines dispersion-based filtering of cross-attention maps and mask-dependent sharing schedules, Adaptive-Capacity Optimal Transport Attention (ACOT) with reference-token capacity bounds determined by subject-mask areas, and frequency-selective whitening and coloring of attention value features. The paper evaluates the framework on ConsiStory+ through baseline comparisons, ablations, and a user study.
Critical strengths
AdaShare achieves DreamSim and VGG-Style scores of 0.1692 and 1.0588, respectively, outperforming the listed methods while retaining competitive text alignment. These results suggest a practically useful trade-off among identity consistency, style consistency, and prompt fidelity.
Critical weaknesses
-
Adaptive mask extraction improves IoU only from 61.07% to 62.22% over the baseline in Table 4, with similarly modest CLIP-I and DreamSim gains in Table 3. The qualitative examples do not establish a general improvement in subject completeness. For the style component, low-frequency-only WCT with preservation of high-frequency structure was already explored in WCT², while SADis applies WCT in diffusion generation and addresses high-frequency texture degradation. Applying these ideas to attention values is a concrete distinction, but the manuscript does not sufficiently establish the new technical insight enabled by this adaptation. Thus, despite attractive overall performance, the methodological contribution remains insufficiently compelling.
-
ACOT differs meaningfully from CoDi’s fixed subject-feature transport by constraining reference-column capacities in dynamic attention. However, at γ=1.25 in Table 7, ACOT underperforms ordinary Extended Attention on CLIP-I and DreamSim, despite improvements in other metrics; this comparison also does not use the final full default configuration. The paper does not separately establish the benefits of mask-area-dependent versus fixed capacities, or adaptive versus fixed scheduling. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the overall gains arise specifically from the proposed mechanisms rather than other components or changes in sharing strength. This uncertainty materially weakens the evidence for the significance of the central contribution.
Questions for authors
-
Among ACOT’s differences from CoDi, is the principal contribution the reference-column inequality constraint, online updating, or mask-area-dependent capacity? Which existing results separately substantiate these claims?
-
Under the final default configuration, how do results change when only ACOT is replaced with ordinary Extended Attention or a fixed-capacity variant, keeping masks, CVA, scheduling, and random seeds identical? Can repeated runs or paired confidence intervals establish a reliable benefit from the proposed mechanisms?
-
Does the Baseline Mask comparison in Table 3 also change the sharing schedule? Can the contributions of mask filtering and adaptive scheduling be separated, and can the authors establish whether these changes meaningfully reduce subject incompleteness rather than merely producing small improvements in average consistency metrics?
2 comments
4. Technical Insight of CVA (FS-WCT) in Self-Attention Value Space (Weakness 1)
While frequency separation has been studied in image-level style transfer (WCT²) and single-image stylization, introducing FS-WCT into early self-attention value features for multi-frame story generation resolves a distinct conflict: aligning cross-frame global style without overriding prompt-driven pose and scene structure in the current frame. In diffusion self-attention, early value features jointly encode global color/texture distributions in low frequencies and scene layout/pose geometry in high frequencies. As shown in Fig. 5, applying full-spectrum WCT directly to introduces up to 12.18% high-frequency spectral deviation, which forces subsequent frames to replicate the reference frame's rigid portrait pose rather than following action prompts such as "walking with a cane". By restricting WCT to low-frequency components of (Eqs. 10–11), CVA aligns cross-frame artistic style while preserving the high-frequency structural cues needed for prompt-faithful pose and scene generation. Manuscript revision: We have updated Section 3.1 "Problem Formulation" accordingly (marked in blue).
We thank the reviewer for the thorough evaluation and for recognizing AdaShare's strong performance on ConsiStory+ and its practical balance across identity consistency, style consistency, and prompt fidelity.
1. Core Differences from CoDi, Primary Contribution, and Experimental Support (Weakness 2, Question 1)
Primary Contribution. Compared with CoDi's fixed feature transport, the core contribution of ACOT Attention lies in jointly formulating the reference-column inequality constraint and the mask-area-dependent adaptive capacity bound τ=∣Mi∣/∣M0∣ (Eqs. 6 and 33), while online Sinkhorn updating (Algorithm 1) serves as an efficient solver for this constrained optimization.
Supporting Evidence in the Paper:
Manuscript revision: We have updated Section 2 "Related Work" accordingly (marked in blue).
2. Controlled Comparison of ACOT vs. Extended Attention and γ=1.25 Analysis (Weakness 2, Question 2)
We have compared ACOT and Extended Attention in the Appendix Table 7 section.
Controlled Experimental Setup. In Table 7, the adaptive subject masks, CVA module, scheduling strategy, and random seeds are held strictly identical across rows; the sole difference is replacing ACOT Attention with standard Extended Attention.
Performance at γ=1.25. Standard Extended Attention leaves a large fraction of attention mass over-concentrated on a few high-response reference tokens. At a moderately high affinity (γ=1.25), this unconstrained attention collapses onto salient local reference patches. While such local hard-copying slightly favors globally pooled similarity metrics, it starves other semantic parts of the subject and causes structural incompleteness (Figs. 4 and 9). Under the exact same controlled setting at γ=1.25, ACOT Attention outperforms Extended Attention in prompt fidelity (CLIP-T), style consistency (VGG-Style), and overall generation quality (FID: 46.5232 vs. 46.7600).
3. Mask Filtering vs. Adaptive Scheduling and Subject Completeness (Weakness 1, Question 3)
Interaction Between Mask Filtering and Scheduling. In Table 3, the Baseline Mask setting only replaces our spatial dispersion filter (Dtl<τs=170, Eqs. 4–5) with standard uniform averaging across candidate layers (Eq. 3), while keeping CVA, ACOT Attention, and the stabilization criterion unchanged. However, as illustrated in Fig. 3 (right), unfiltered cross-attention maps exhibit severe spatial dispersion and background noise across steps 2 to 15. Because consecutive noisy masks fluctuate heavily, the baseline rarely satisfies the IoU≥0.85 convergence condition early and is forced to lock a noisy mask at the upper step bound T2=15. By filtering out near-uniform diffuse layers (where the theoretical uniform variance on a 32×32 grid is 170.5, Appendix B.1 Eqs. 14–19), our Adaptive Mask Extraction stabilizes cleanly at step 11 (green box in Fig. 3 right), preventing subject incompleteness such as the missing hand in Fig. 3 (left) and reducing background leakage in Fig. 8. Manuscript revision: We have updated Section 3.2.1 "Adaptive Mask Extraction" accordingly (marked in blue).