- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a multimodal self-supervised framework that decouples cross-modal pretraining from downstream risk integration for polysomnography (PSG) and verifies its effectiveness on a large-scale dataset. Results suggest that the framework benefits from cox and have complementary effect to demographic signals. However, the experimental design provides insufficient evidence to validate the effectiveness of individual components, while the limited baselines and presentation issues further weaken the paper.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a novel self-supervised learning design that explicitly models both within-modality and cross-modal information, while naturally handling missing modalities without requiring imputation.
- The experiments are conducted on a large-scale dataset spanning multiple cohorts and disease endpoints, providing relatively comprehensive empirical validation.
- Some analyses are interesting. The analysis of cross-modal representation similarity is interesting and helps characterize the relationships among heterogeneous physiological signals. In addition, Fig. 4 provides a useful study of the incremental contribution of PSG signals beyond basic clinical covariates.
Critical weaknesses
- The reported results suggest that PSG provides very small benefit for several endpoints. While the clinical fusion weight is selected on the validation set, it would be useful to report the selected for each endpoint and quantify how much the final performance actually depends on PSG versus the clinical covariates.
- The comparison with SleepFM is not fully controlled. The paper compares SleepFM + frozen Cox against Ours Full PSG, where the latter additionally uses endpoint-specific whole-night aggregators and modality-specific risk heads. Since SleepFM already performs better under the matched frozen Cox probe (0.692 vs. 0.681), it is unclear whether the gain of the full model comes from a better representation or simply from using a stronger, separately trained downstream head for each task.
- The proposed SSL formulation combines within-modality masked prediction and cross-modal prediction, but there is no clear ablation isolating the contribution of each SSL objective.
- The final PSG risk is obtained by simply averaging the available modality-specific Cox risk scores. A learned or validation-selected modality weighting scheme would seem more appropriate.
- The baseline coverage is limited. Beyond SleepFM, the paper would benefit from comparisons with more recent multimodal/self-supervised sleep representation models, such as sleep2vec (sleep2vec: Unified Cross-Modal Alignment for Heterogeneous Nocturnal Biosignals, 2026).
- The presentation needs substantial polishing. There are unresolved or malformed citations (e.g., “(?)” and “(??)” in Sec. 2.2), duplicated/redundant paragraphs, and some figures use very small fonts that are difficult to read. These issues noticeably reduce the clarity and professionalism of the submission.
Questions for authors
- Could you report the selected for each endpoint and its impact on performance?
- Could SleepFM be evaluated with the same endpoint-specific aggregators and modality-specific risk heads?
- Sleepfm2 is released, although SleepFM2 is concurrent work, could the authors briefly discuss its differences from this method?