- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RAMP, a reliability-conditioned masked-pretraining framework for paired ECG and PPG signals. RAMP extracts patch quality, corruption-type, and spectral-degradation evidence, and uses a small Reliability Policy Network to select a masking threshold, temporal granularity, and cross-modal fusion weights; Reliability-Weighted Reconstruction upweights low-quality masked targets. The paper evaluates reconstruction on MIMIC-III and VitalDB under controlled corruption, then reports transfer to six downstream ECG, PPG, EEG, and accelerometry benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
Well-Motivated Problem: The paper addresses a practical and well-motivated problem: heterogeneous noise in physiological signals, such as electrode-contact noise in ECG and motion-induced optical interference in PPG. Existing fixed masking strategies are ill-suited to handling local variations in signal quality, making the proposed approach a meaningful step toward more robust physiological signal representation learning.
-
Clear and Systematic Framework: The proposed framework is well organized, with clearly delineated modules for performance analysis, strategy generation, strategy-conditioned reconstruction, and downstream encoder transfer. This modular design makes the role of each component easy to understand and facilitates systematic evaluation of the overall approach.
-
Comprehensive Evaluation and Generalization: The paper provides extensive ablation studies on MIMIC-III and cross-dataset validation on VitalDB. Furthermore, its evaluation extends to cross-modal downstream tasks involving EEG and motion accelerometer signals, providing encouraging evidence of the generalizability and transferability of the learned representations.
Critical weaknesses
1. Dependence on Manual Annotations and Limitations in Generalization
The proposed framework relies substantially on manually annotated calibration data. Specifically, Appendix C.4 states that the corruption-type classifier requires 500 manually labeled calibration segments per modality, annotated by biomedical engineers. This introduces additional annotation costs and domain-specific prior knowledge, potentially limiting the framework's applicability across different datasets and clinical environments. More importantly, this dependency raises concerns about the framework's ability to achieve robust adaptation beyond predefined corruption-handling strategies. When deployed in previously unseen clinical settings or with novel wearable devices, corruption patterns and signal quality distributions may differ substantially from those observed during calibration. However, the paper does not investigate whether the proposed framework can generalize to such environments without additional manual annotations.
2. Coarse-Grained Cross-Modal Alignment and Insufficient Consideration of Physiological Differences
According to Appendix D, RAMP enforces a shared temporal granularity for ECG and PPG within each window. However, these modalities reflect fundamentally different physiological processes: ECG captures cardiac electrical activity, whereas PPG measures peripheral blood volume changes. Their temporal dynamics and morphological characteristics differ, and the pulse transit time (PTT) introduces a physiologically meaningful delay between cardiac electrical events and peripheral pulse responses. Applying a shared temporal granularity to both modalities may fail to account for these modality-specific characteristics and could potentially obscure fine-grained temporal relationships between them. The paper does not sufficiently justify why a shared granularity is appropriate for signals with different physiological origins, nor does it establish whether this design preserves meaningful cross-modal temporal dependencies.
3. Insufficient Evaluation of Robustness to Missing Modalities
The proposed RAMP framework appears to assume the simultaneous availability of ECG and PPG. In particular, the cross-modal weighting formulation, , appears to presuppose that both modalities are available during training and inference. However, modality loss is common in real-world clinical monitoring and long-term wearable sensing, for example, when ECG electrodes lose contact or PPG sensors become displaced. In such scenarios, one modality may become entirely unavailable, intermittently corrupted, or temporally misaligned with the other. These conditions may undermine the assumptions underlying the cross-modal weighting mechanism and potentially lead to unstable predictions or degraded representations. The paper does not evaluate whether RAMP remains effective under complete modality absence, severe temporal asynchrony, or dynamically changing sensor availability, leaving its robustness in realistic deployment scenarios insufficiently established.
Questions for authors
Q1. How does the proposed framework perform when transferred to unseen datasets, clinical environments, or wearable devices without access to manually labeled calibration segments? Could the authors provide ablation studies comparing the full model with zero-shot transfer and annotation-free adaptation settings to quantify the extent to which expert annotations are necessary for robust generalization?
Q2. What is the physiological and empirical justification for enforcing a shared temporal granularity across ECG and PPG? Could the authors compare the current design with modality-specific temporal granularities or PTT-aware alignment strategies and report whether these alternatives improve representation quality and downstream performance?
Q3. How does RAMP handle cases in which ECG or PPG is completely missing, intermittently unavailable, or severely misaligned? Could the authors evaluate the framework under controlled modality-dropout ratios, single-modality inference, and varying degrees of temporal asynchrony, comparing its performance with corresponding single-modality baselines? In particular, does the cross-modal weighting mechanism remain well-defined when one modality is unavailable, and what modifications, if any, are required to ensure stable inference?