- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a training-free 3D asset editing framework built on TRELLIS2. Geometry editing combines source–target flow differences with latent anchoring and decoded voxel-space preservation. Material editing uses multi-sample velocity estimation and PBR regularization. Experiments on a proposed 200-task benchmark report improvements in geometry preservation, appearance quality, inference time, and user preference.
Critical strengths
This paper addresses a practically relevant problem: performing localized edits while preserving source geometry and materials. Combining latent-space anchoring with decoded-space preservation is a reasonable direction. The evaluation covers multiple editing categories, includes separate geometry-component ablations, and supplements automatic metrics with a 40-participant user study. The qualitative examples suggest potentially useful editing capabilities.
Critical weaknesses
The central physical assumptions and theoretical guarantees are not sound as stated. Appendix B.2 treats highly metallic, highly rough materials as physically implausible, although rough conductors are valid in standard metallic–roughness PBR models. Consequently, the proposed penalty can suppress legitimate materials rather than enforce physical validity. Similarly, surface roughness does not generally require spatially smooth base-color textures. These terms could potentially serve as empirical priors, but their applicability and effects require validation. Furthermore, Theorem 2 does not follow from the stated Lipschitz assumptions. Eq. (43) establishes descent only when the gradient norm is sufficiently large; no condition relates gradient magnitude to loss value or excludes positive-loss stationary points. Thus, the argument cannot establish the claimed convergence to a physically valid manifold. These concerns affect a principal methodological contribution rather than presentation alone.
The evaluation leaves key conclusions unverifiable and does not sufficiently isolate the incremental contribution. The benchmark description lists source geometry and source/target images, without explaining the target 3D references required for edited-region Chamfer Distance and overall F-Score. Comparing edited regions against source geometry would measure deviation rather than editing correctness. The material consistency metric averages LPIPS across viewpoints without describing correspondence compensation, confounding viewpoint changes with inconsistency. Comparisons also mix generative backbones, making it difficult to attribute improvements to the proposed editing mechanism. Closely related approaches, including AnchorFlow and the TRELLIS2-based VS3D, are omitted. Material ablations compare the complete module against TRELLIS2 without separating sample averaging and individual regularizers. Hardware, resolution, runtime scope, and uncertainty are insufficiently reported.
Questions for authors
1, How are target 3D references and evaluation regions constructed? Please clarify the references, registration, and sampling protocols for Chamfer Distance and F-Score. 2, What justifies excluding rough metallic materials? Can corrected regularizers and component-wise ablations establish their benefit without suppressing valid appearances? 3, What additional assumptions make Theorem 2 valid, and can matched-backbone comparisons establish gains beyond existing flow-based preservation strategies?