- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Inlay3D, a novel framework for precise part localization and decoupled texture and shape editing. Guided by a 2D mask, the framework first identifies an explicit target part from a set of 3D part candidates through Target Part Extraction. It then applies a two-stage editing process. It edits the isolated target part, followed by boundary refinement.
Critical strengths
- Effective boundary refinement. Mend combines boundary-localized refinement with O-Voxel replacement to improve integration while preserving non-target regions. This design could also benefit other 3D editing frameworks.
- Comprehensive evaluation. Experiments compare against state-of-the-art methods on both texture and geometry editing, using stage-specific metrics to demonstrate strong performance in localization, editing quality, and non-target preservation.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited component-wise ablations. The Full Mesh Inpainting comparison does not isolate the contributions of individual editing stages.
- Insufficient boundary refinement validation. The ablation provides only qualitative texture-editing results, lacking quantitative comparisons and dedicated evaluation of geometric boundary blending.
Questions for authors
- Limited component-wise ablations. The Full Mesh Inpainting comparison does not isolate the contributions of individual editing stages.
- Insufficient boundary refinement validation. The ablation provides only qualitative texture-editing results, lacking quantitative comparisons and dedicated evaluation of geometric boundary blending.
- Failure case. How does the precomputed boundary band handle large changes in the edited part’s attachment location? Please provide a failure case illustrating its limitations.
- Replacement strategy. Compare O-Voxel replacement with latent replacement in terms of boundary refinement quality.
2 comments
Concerns Addressed
The authors have addressed my concerns, so I will maintain my score.
Thank you for your valuable suggestion to include more ablations. In response, we conducted additional quantitative ablations of latent replacement and boundary refinement. We also show geometric boundary blending results and present a failure case in which the region produced by the first stage extends beyond the precomputed boundary band. 1. Additional Ablation Studies (W1/W2/Q1/Q2/Q4) The existing ablation study on full-mesh inpainting demonstrates the effectiveness of the two-stage editing strategy. We conducted additional ablation studies on specific components of Inlay3D, including Iterative Part Selection and O-Voxel replacement. To evaluate Iterative Part Selection, we removed it and used the best-matching candidate from a single pass of P3-SAM as the target part. To assess O-Voxel replacement, we replaced it with latent replacement. We also included quantitative results for a configuration without boundary refinement ("w/o Boundary Refinement"). FID and KID show larger changes than the other metrics. We hypothesize that these strategies mainly affect boundary regions, which occupy only a small fraction of each rendered image. FID and KID appear more sensitive to these changes. The experimental results are presented in the table below.
The results show that the complete method achieves the lowest FID and KID values, demonstrating the effectiveness of these strategies. We have added these quantitative ablations to Table 4 of the revised manuscript.
2. Geometric Boundary Blending Results (Q2) Following your advice, we have added the results before and after boundary blending to Figure 7 of the revised manuscript. The results show that Boundary Refinement smooths the boundary band and reduces boundary artifacts.
3. Failure Case (Q3) We acknowledge that boundary refinement is sensitive to the precomputed boundary band. If the result of Isolated Mesh Editing changes in size or position, boundary refinement can be less effective. We applied scaling and translation to the first-stage results to simulate deviations that may occur in practice. We have added this failure case to Appendix E (Figure 8) of the revised manuscript.