- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Relaxed Distribution-wise Consistency (RDC) for semi-supervised medical image segmentation. It replaces strict affinity value alignment with ranking consistency between teacher and student networks, using reference pixels called agents and a differentiable Kendall's tau loss. The authors provide theoretical analysis of robustness to teacher noise and report improved segmentation performance across four medical image datasets.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a relevant problem in semi-supervised learning, where noisy pseudo-labels can reduce segmentation quality, especially near organ boundaries.
-
The proposed ranking loss can be integrated into existing teacher-student frameworks without additional inference cost. The reported ablations and noise experiments provide some evidence of its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
-
All quantitative experimental tables are placed in the appendix, while the main paper contains no experimental tables. This makes it difficult to assess the empirical contributions and verify the main claims from the paper itself. For a paper that relies heavily on empirical improvements, the current presentation does not meet the expected standard for publication.
-
The method mainly combines existing pixel affinity representations with established ranking objectives, including differentiable Kendall's tau. The so-called agents are essentially reference or anchor pixels, rather than autonomous agents, and their selection is adopted from RankMatch. Previous works have already explored ranking-based segmentation and pixel-level relational learning, so the paper needs a clearer distinction from prior methods. To list a few works: He, H., Yuan, Y., Yue, X., and Hu, H. (2022). RankSeg: Adaptive Pixel Classification with Image Category Ranking for Segmentation. European Conference on Computer Vision (ECCV). Ke, T.-W., Hwang, J.-J., and Yu, S. X. (2021). Universal Weakly Supervised Segmentation by Pixel-to-Segment Contrastive Learning. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR). Mai, H., Sun, R., Zhang, T., and Wu, F. (2024). RankMatch: Exploring the Better Consistency Regularization for Semi-Supervised Semantic Segmentation. IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), pp. 3391–340
Questions for authors
-
Why are all quantitative experimental results placed in the appendix? Which core experiments do the authors consider essential for supporting the main claims?
-
What is the main conceptual difference between RDC and existing ranking-based or pixel affinity methods? Beyond changing the alignment loss, what is the new technical contribution?
-
How do the authors distinguish improvements due to ranking information from those due to the robustness and gradient properties of the chosen loss function?
Serious research-integrity concern: undisclosed overlap with a previously published RDC paper and possible plagiarism or redundant publication.
I identified substantial overlap between this submission and the previously published RDC paper [1], which appeared on January 5, 2026. The earlier paper already presents Relaxed Distribution-wise Consistency for semi-supervised medical image segmentation, including orthogonal agent selection, pixel–agent affinity modeling, and the replacement of strict affinity-value alignment with ranking alignment to improve robustness to teacher noise. These elements closely correspond to the central methodological framework and motivation of the current submission.
The overlap also extends to specific experimental results. Table 5 of [1] reports ACDC Dice scores of 87.21, 88.25, and 88.98 for the baseline, contrastive alignment, and distribution consistency, respectively. Table 7 of [1] reports 88.68, 88.79, and 88.98 for the L2, CE, and KL objectives. These values appear identically in Table 2 of the current submission. This correspondence requires an explicit explanation of the relationship between the two methods and the provenance of the reported results.
I acknowledge that the current submission replaces the earlier soft-rank objective with a differentiable Kendall objective and adds theoretical analysis and experiments. However, I could not find a citation to [1] or an explanation of this relationship in the revised manuscript or the rebuttal provided for review. Consequently, the manuscript does not adequately distinguish its new contributions from this directly relevant, already published work.
This unexplained overlap raises serious concerns about possible plagiarism or undisclosed redundant publication and warrants investigation by the Area Chair. The authors should clarify the relationship to [1], identify any reused methods or experimental results, and explicitly establish the incremental contribution. The observed overlap alone does not establish misconduct, but it is sufficiently substantial to require formal clarification and assessment before an acceptance decision. Until this concern is adequately resolved, I cannot support acceptance.
Reference
[1] SUN R, MAI H, LI Z, et al. Relaxed distribution-wise consistency for semi-supervised medical image segmentation[J]. CAAI Transactions on Intelligent Systems, 2026, 21(1): 132–145. DOI: 10.11992/tis.202507034.