- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
this paper provide a training framework that uses a cVAE that explicitly learning both gene expression values and batch information to align cells from batches, create meta-cells, and generate soft-assignments. the method is validate on several metrics including homogeneity, F1, and coverage, demonstrating its effectiveness.
Critical strengths
S1: batch effect is ubiquitous in gene-expression data analysis and aligning cells across batch is very meaningful to facilitate and advance relevant research.
Critical weaknesses
W1: the aim and scope of this paper is unclear. does it simply create meta-cells and that's all? is there any downstream applications in bioinformatics? how can such meta-cell construction method help their performance? do you mean clustering by prototyping, and does this present a prototype-based cell clustering solution? the impact of this paper should be made more concrete specific.
W2: the method section is not well organized. it is presented in a flat manner, enumerating all model or training component. but this is no hierachical structures that demonstrate the inter-relationship between these design components.
Questions for authors
Q1: in eq.8 the reconstruction is g(z,b) but in figure 1 the reconstruction is g(c,b), please clarify.
Q2: please clariy the concept "meta-cell" and "prototype". what is the discrepency and what is in common, in your scenario. unify the terminology if approriate.