- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes scDeepFusion, a framework for single-cell RNA-seq integration that combines gene-expression fluctuations with module-level features derived from Reactome pathways and chemical/genetic perturbation signatures. A cell-specific top-2 router combines three knowledge-source experts and exports routing weights to track their contributions. The model is trained through alignment to a Harmony reference embedding, together with module reconstruction, gene denoising, and load-balancing objectives. The authors evaluate integration performance across five datasets and demonstrate training on up to 400,000 Tabula Sapiens cells. They report competitive performance, while ablations show that simpler teacher-aligned models achieve similar aggregate scores. The main claimed architectural contribution is therefore auditable knowledge provenance, explored through cell-type-specific routing patterns, replication across datasets, and post-training expert-masking experiments.
Critical strengths
- The model is able to track the use of the knowledge used for model representation explicitly through their routing strategy. It actually provides an explainable way for biologists who want to understand the model's internal predictive behavior.
- The authors explicitly acknowledge that simpler models achieve comparable aggregate performance, which provides useful empirical insight into the field with the adoption of teacher-aligned training.
Critical weaknesses
The author should demonstrate the biological relevance and practical value of the routing-based explanations. The innovative part of the work is the routing weights which offers potential interpretation to the predictive power, but the experiments do not quite establish whether these preferences align with independently supported biological mechanisms. Specifically, the replication of the myeloid–lymphoid routing pattern across datasets demonstrates consistency, but does not by itself establish biological aware understanding. Since these datasets contain similar immune-cell populations, the observed agreement could reflect shared expression patterns or biases in gene-set coverage rather than biologically meaningful expert specialization. It would be great to see some literatures or discoveries that could prove such preference shown in the model output. Known marker expression supports the identities of these populations, but does not explain why they should preferentially rely on Reactome or CGP experts. Therefore, I think unless independent biological evidence and controls for these alternative explanations can be verified, the author cannot claim the interpretable ability of the routing module.
Questions for authors
- What evidence supports interpreting the myeloid–lymphoid routing pattern as biologically meaningful expert specialization, rather than a consequence of shared expression patterns or differences in gene-set coverage? Can you connect these preferences to specific pathways or perturbation signatures supported by independent biological evidence?
- What does the expert-masking experiment establish beyond sensitivity of the weighted representation to removing a component? Does masking affect downstream integration quality, and are the routing patterns stable across training seeds?
- Given that the pathway-MLP, concatenation, and no-module controls achieve comparable aggregate performance, what demonstrated capability justifies the additional architecture? In particular, can you provide a concrete example in which the routing information helps identify a model failure or yields a biologically supported insight unavailable from the simpler controls?
Thanks the authors for the detailed and comprehensive response and the new experiments conducted to address my comments. Although I appreciate that the author is willing to modify their claims on biological aware discovery, I think in general the novelty of the work could be reassessed given the current further analysis. From my point of view, I would expect the routing to show some biologically supported insight, since the central claim is combining gene expression with prior biological knowledge. Given on this, I would keep my current score. Thanks again for the authors’ effort on all the experiments.