- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RankFuse, a method for integrating heterogeneous single-cell encoders through their cross-batch nearest-neighbor rankings. It combines these rankings using reciprocal rank fusion, constructs a unified graph, and trains a lightweight graph adapter over whitened encoder features. Experiments on three single-cell datasets investigate integration performance and the respective contributions of graph construction, feature selection, and adaptation
Critical strengths
The method provides a simple and practical interface for combining heterogeneous encoders without requiring explicit coordinate alignment. The experimental analysis usefully separates graph construction from feature adaptation and includes single-encoder controls and component ablations. The paper also transparently reports dataset-dependent gains and trade-offs between batch correction and biological conservation, which helps clarify the scope of its conclusions.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is that the motivation presents differences in embedding coordinates and scales as a stronger obstacle to direct fusion than the evidence supports. Incompatible coordinates prevent naive coordinate-wise averaging, but do not inherently preclude concatenation or a learned fusion module. Although the paper evaluates whitened concatenation, this relatively limited control does not establish that rank-based fusion is preferable to direct feature fusion with comparable adaptation capacity. A matched concatenation baseline with a learned projection or lightweight fusion network would help determine whether the gains arise specifically from the proposed rank-based interface rather than from the graph construction and subsequent adaptation
Questions for authors
- Could you clarify which forms of direct fusion are considered problematic and distinguish coordinate-wise averaging from concatenation or learned feature fusion? 2. Can you compare RankFuse with whitened concatenation followed by a trainable projection or lightweight fusion network under comparable training conditions and adaptation capacity? 3. Can you better isolate the contribution of rank fusion from graph-based adaptation, for example by comparing alternative graph constructions while holding the features and adapter fixed? I would consider raising my score if the authors can convincingly address this concern and demonstrate the benefit of the proposed fusion interface through matched comparisons.
Reminder - Please review authors' rebuttal
Dear Reviewers,
A quick update on the discussion: we are now halfway through the discussion period, and the authors have posted their rebuttal.
I would appreciate it if you could take some time to join the discussion at this stage. In particular, please go through the authors' responses, consider whether the concerns and questions you raised have been addressed, and let the authors know if you have any further feedback for them.
Getting everyone's input now will help us move toward a well-grounded final decision. Many thanks for your participation.
Best regards,
Your AC