- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper establishes bounds on the Wasserstein-1 distance between the laws of two diffusion processes differing in their drifts and initializations. The results assume a dissapitivity-type condition (Eq. 2) under which bounds on the Wasserstein-1 distance is established.
Critical strengths
I do not see any critical strengths in the paper. The problem statement and motivation is unclear.
Critical weaknesses
This paper is unfortunately unreadable. It is unclear why this manuscript considers diffusion processes driven by what is called "radial drift bounds". It is unclear what implications the results have, or what technical difficulty is resolved. The related work section lists references without describing how they relate to the paper. Is the relation in the underlying setting? Result? What are the differences/similarities?
Constructive comments
The paper needs significant revision with a clear scope. In my best efforts to guide the authors, I state some comments as a starting point.
-
The law is defined as "the law of an approximation with drift ...". I suppose the intent is to define it as the law of the solution to the SDE with replaced by .
-
The sentences "Our objective is to ... which we use to establish sharpness" are unclear. "sharpness" does not have a reference; the last sentence reads as using "the linear transport cost" to establish sharpness, but it's unclear what "sharpness" is being referred to. I suppose the authors are trying to say that they establish sharp bounds on the Wasserstein-1 distance. Moreover, the title states Wasserstein-1 distance, but the introduction defines it in three different ways "expectation errors over 1-Lipschitz observables", "their largest errors", "the linear transport cost".
-
The introduction needs to define the problem and a motivation for the problem. Equation (2) can be satisfied by a choice of , but why should one consider such diffusion processes? What is a "reference" diffusion"? These should be clearly stated.
-
Regarding the math, the paper needs to justify many reasons for considering the assumptions of this paper. For which problems does satisfy Assumption 2.1, and how is this relevant? Even if satisfies Assumption 2.1, why should satisfy Assumption 2.1? Can't the results of this be established under sample path distances, not just distances between laws? The choice of assumptions and metric need to be carefully thought out.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses section.