acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Diffusion Removes Langevin's Conditioning Dependence: A Sharp Gaussian Analysis

Abstract

Despite their empirical success, why diffusion models overcome the bottlenecks of classical score-based samplers remains unclear. In this work, we leverage Gaussian distributions to isolate this phenomenon. We establish 2-Wasserstein convergence bounds for optimized hyperparameters, showing that diffusion processes achieve a sampling error of , where is the dimension, the number of sampling steps, and the largest eigenvalue of the target covariance matrix. Unadjusted and underdamped Langevin dynamics suffer from an additional factor, where is the condition number. These rates follow from spectral bounds which are sharp: we confirm them via matching first-order asymptotics as . Our analysis provides a rigorous characterization, in the Gaussian setting, of how time-dependent score trajectories remove condition-number dependence during sampling. By contrast, in the learning phase, we show that estimating the unnoised score by gradient descent leads to essentially the same estimator as estimating a noisy score, which suggests that the benefits of noising do not come from the learning phase.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
diffusion models, Langevin sampling

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 4%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.33 over 3 reviews, above 96% of the others.
Reviewer_vGUQOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the conditioning dependence of diffusion-based sampling compared with classical Langevin algorithms in the Gaussian setting. The authors establish non-asymptotic Wasserstein-2 convergence bounds for the unadjusted Langevin algorithm (ULA), underdamped Langevin dynamics (ULD), and a diffusion-based sampler. Under the proposed hyperparameter choices, ULA and ULD exhibit condition-number dependence, whereas the diffusion sampler achieves a condition-number-free convergence rate. The authors further establish matching asymptotic expressions, demonstrating the sharpness of the derived rates for the specified algorithms and parameter choices. In addition, the paper compares standard and noised score matching under gradient descent, suggesting that the benefit of noising primarily arises during sampling rather than learning.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides non-asymptotic Wasserstein bounds together with matching asymptotic expressions. In particular, the asymptotic equivalence establishes the sharpness of the diffusion bound, including the leading constant. These results constitute a meaningful theoretical contribution.

  2. The analysis highlights how time-dependent scores progressively change the conditioning of the sampling problem, providing a useful perspective on the potential advantages of diffusion-based sampling.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main comparison considers ULA and Euler–Maruyama-discretized ULD with constant step sizes, whereas the diffusion sampler employs a geometrically decreasing step-size schedule. Although these choices are reasonable, the comparison does not establish whether the observed improvement arises specifically from the time-dependent score or partly from the discretization strategy. In particular, it remains unclear whether Langevin algorithms with appropriately chosen nonuniform step sizes could achieve improved condition-number dependence. Moreover, the ULD comparison is restricted to the Euler–Maruyama discretization, while more sophisticated integrators are known to improve the convergence behavior of underdamped Langevin methods. Consequently, the results establish a separation between the specific schemes considered, rather than a general advantage of diffusion over Langevin sampling algorithms.

  2. Section 3 shows that, in the Gaussian setting, noised score matching corresponds to ridge-regularized score matching and that some of its regularization effects can be mimicked by early stopping in ordinary score matching. However, this relationship does not establish that noising offers no benefit during learning. Specifically, the two procedures estimate different score functions, and the paper does not compare their finite-sample estimation errors or optimization efficiency. Similarity between the resulting covariance estimators does not necessarily imply comparable statistical performance. Therefore, the conclusion that the benefits of noising arise from sampling rather than learning appears stronger than what Theorem 7 establishes.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors clarify whether the condition-number separation persists when Langevin algorithms are allowed to use nonuniform step sizes? In particular, to what extent is the improvement attributable to the time-dependent score rather than the choice of discretization schedule?

  2. In what precise sense does Theorem 7 establish that noising provides no benefit during learning? Can the authors clarify whether the similarity between the resulting covariance estimators implies comparable statistical estimation errors, given that the two methods estimate different score functions?

2 comments

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of our work and insightful questions.

Q1: We agree that the analysis for other discretization schemes and step size schedules for Langevin is important. We focused on the Euler-Maruyama with uniform step size for simplicity. The main limitation for a more general analysis is that the eigenvalues of the covariance matrices cannot be computed in closed form.

Regarding the discretization schemes, as discussed in our related work section, the literature on Langevin has provided improved condition dependence for Gaussian targets with more complex integrators (splitting, random step-sizes, or Metropolis corrections). To our knowledge, these methods do not yield independence from the condition number, and are arguably more complex than diffusions.

Regarding the step size schedule, we believe that nonuniform step sizes for Langevin do not significantly improve the convergence rates and do not close the gap with diffusions in terms of dependence on the condition number. More specifically, one can show that ULA suffers a κlog⁡(κ)\kappa \log(\kappa) burn-in for any step size schedule as long as the steps remain stable. Furthermore, we investigated convergence rates for ULA with nonuniform step size ηk=c/k\eta_k = c/k, where cc is a tunable hyperparameter. In this setting, the computations remain simple enough. We find that, depending on the value of cc compared with λmax⁡/2\lambda_{\max}/2, there are two regimes. In the first one, we have W2(PN,P)∼A(c)/NW_2(P_N, P)\sim A(c)/N, with A(c)≥18λmax⁡Tr(Σ−1)A(c)\ge\frac 18\lambda_{\max}\sqrt{\text{Tr}(\Sigma^{-1})}, which is the same prefactor as ULA with uniform step sizes. In the second one, we obtain W2(PN,P)∼B(c)N−2c/λmax⁡W_2(P_N,P)\sim B(c)N^{-2c/\lambda_{\max}}. Choosing cc such that 2c/λmax⁡2c/\lambda_{\max} is close to 11 causes the quantity B(c)B(c) to explode.

We will add this discussion to the final version, and state that a lower bound for Langevin-type methods to prove a general separation with diffusions is an interesting next step.

Q2: We have rephrased the sentence mentioned by the reviewer (in the abstract and in the contributions) to clarify that we study the impact of the noise through the lens of the implicit bias of the learning objective, and show that noising does not add an implicit bias. In a data-limited or compute-limited scenario, we agree that one could also study the effect of noising on the estimation error or optimization efficiency. These are interesting avenues for future work that we will mention in the final version.

Thank you for your response. I maintain my positive assessment and score.

Reviewer_89ajOpenReview ↗
Rating
4(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper answers the question of why diffusion models do not have the same disadvantages as unadjusted and underdamped Langevin dynamics, focusing on the unimodal Gaussian case. They identify that diffusion model convergence rates do not depend on the condition number of the covariance matrix unlike those of classical Langevin dynamics. They show that this rates are sharp by matching first order assymptotics. Additionally, they show that diffusion models learning part is not the one providing the improvements since estimating the unnoised score by gradient descent leads to essentially the same estimator as estimating a noisy score.

Critical strengths
  • The theoretical analysis answers an important question in the literature on why diffusion models improve over classical Langevin dynamics, showing that the critical dependence on the condition number that appears in Langevin dynamics and make it fails for ill-conditioned settings is not present in the diffusion case using a telescopic sums cancellations. I think what is very neat is that they obtain sharp rates by matching the first order asymptotics as the number of time steps goes to infinity.

  • Insights on the learning phase. The authors identify that the learning phase of diffusion models which consists in estimating the noisy score across the path of probability distributions is equivalent to estimating the unnoised score in the Langevin case, therefore, the benefits of diffusion models does not steam from this.

Critical weaknesses
  • The analysis is quite restrictive. Although the unimodal Gaussian case allows for close form expressions, it is quite restrictive as different works in the literature argue that a key advantage of diffusion models is their use on multimodal settings. It would be helpful to discuss what happens for a mixture of Gaussians to understand whether similar conclusions hold in that case even if in this case closed form expressions cannot be derive.

  • The analysis for the time-inhomogeneous diffusion sampler is done for a particular variance exploding noising process. However, variance preserving, DDPM type, diffusions are also common in the literature. The authors argue that this choice is made for analytical tractability. I believe it would be beneficial to discuss even if not fully computed how the arguments extend to other type of noising processes.

Questions for authors

Following the weaknesses pointed out above.

  1. Would it be possible to discuss whether the conclusions extend to a mixture of Gaussians?
  2. What are the main limitations to extend the arguments use in the paper to other noising processes?

I think the paper answers an important question. If the authors are able to discuss these questions I would be happy to raise my score.

4 comments

We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and the positive assessment of our work, and the suggestions, which led us to run new experiments.

Q1: Early motivation for the introduction of diffusion models was their good performance compared to Langevin for multimodal distributions and ill-conditioned distributions [1]. Our goal in this work is to provide rigorous justification for this motivation focusing on the second aspect. We agree that the extension to Gaussian mixtures in order to assess the interplay between multimodality and ill-conditioning is an interesting extension.

As pointed out by the reviewer, this raises technical challenges, because the score becomes non-linear and the Wasserstein error cannot be computed in closed form. To gain some insight into this question, we investigate the performance of diffusion compared to ULA on bimodal Gaussian mixtures for which the Wasserstein error can be computed semi-analytically, without stochasticity. To ensure a fair comparison, we perform a grid search over the step size for ULA, while keeping the diffusion hyperparameters as in the Gaussian case (from our Proposition 4). The results clearly show that ULA deteriorates as the condition number increases, whereas diffusion is significantly more efficient and is robust to κ\kappa. Interestingly, in the latter case, the asymptotic rates are proportional to log⁡N/N\log N/N as for Gaussians. We also studied the effect of the potential barrier between the two modes. As expected, ULA is much more sensitive to this parameter than diffusion.

We added the figures and the details of the experiments to the revised version (Appendix F). Given their interest, we will also include a summary of these results in the main text of the final version.

[1] Yang Song and Stefano Ermon, Generative Modeling by Estimating Gradients of the Data Distribution, NeurIPS 2019.

Q2: Part of our analysis extends beyond the VE process. Indeed, for any noising process whose coefficients are scalar, which includes the VP process underlying DDPM, the iterates of the Euler-Maruyama scheme remain Gaussian, with eigenvalues given by a first-order recurrence. The Wasserstein errors along the iterates therefore follow an analytical one-dimensional recurrence. The main limitation is that this recurrence cannot be solved in closed form in general. Hence, optimizing hyperparameters and computing first-order asymptotics is difficult.

We argue that our results nevertheless give a method to tune the hyperparameters beyond the VE case. A noising process with scalar coefficients is, in law, a time change of the VE process, which allows us to map the VE hyperparameters to the new diffusion. We applied this mapping heuristic to the VP process of DDPM, and numerically evaluated the analytical recurrence equation. Interestingly, the resulting sampler exhibits the same behavior as in the VE case: no dependence on the condition number and an asymptotic rate of order log⁡N/N\log N / N. We provide the figure in Appendix F and will add a more detailed discussion in the final version.

Thanks a lot for your reply and for the new results. I would appreciate the authors discussing both the multimodal and extension to other noising process as the VP case, since I believe help to broaden the scope of the work even if not being able to fully analyse these in closed form as in the VE case. One further followup curiosity question is whether you have any intuition about the gap between the VE and VP trajectories in the new Figure 4. It seems that they converge to different asymptotic values as the iteration budget increases. Could this be due to the mapping heuristic used?

We thank the reviewer for the follow-up.

We agree that discussing these two extensions benefits the paper, since they broaden the scope of our work. We will add both discussions to the main text of the final version.

Regarding Figure 4: both errors decay at the same rate log⁡N/N\log N / N, independently of κ\kappa; their leading-order asymptotics differ only by a constant factor. Our intuition is that this gap is due to the discretization error. First, the initialization and early-stopping errors are of order 1/N1/N over both samplers, hence negligible at leading order. Second, the Euler-Maruyama scheme is not invariant under the change of variables: the EM discretization of the VP SDE on the mapped grid is not the image of the EM discretization of the VE SDE. Both schemes are first-order accurate, but their one-step errors differ. Accumulated over the NN steps, this yields the same rate with a different constant, much as two quadrature rules of the same order have different error constants. The gap therefore arises because the mapping transfers the hyperparameters but not the numerical scheme. The fact that the constant is better for VP than VE should not be overinterpreted and may revert for instance by changing \lambda_\max in the data distribution.

Thank you for this additional discussion, I raise my score and recommend acceptance conditional on this discussion being added in the final version of the paper.

Reviewer_ZbcVOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies why diffusion models outperform classical score-based samplers using Gaussian distributions. The paper provides theory that demonstrates that diffusion sampling achieves faster convergence by eliminating dependence on the condition number, unlike traditional Langevin methods. The analysis further suggests that the benefits of diffusion models mainly arise from the sampling process rather than the learning phase.

Critical strengths

This is a great paper with important theory about diffusion that removes Langevin's conditioning dependence -- solving a longstanding difficult issue.

Critical weaknesses

Line 262: Notation \sim_{N\to \infty}, such notation was widely used in this paper, but seems not very well defined. The notation could be a bit hard to follow.

The theory seems based on Gaussian distribution N(0, \Sigma). This condition is somewhat strong that makes the scope narrow. Is it possible to expand?

Questions for authors

My questions for authors would be it is possible to address the critical weaknesses mentioned earlier.

2 comments

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of our work and for their comments.

Q1: The notation f(N)∼N→∞g(N)f(N)\underset{N\rightarrow\infty}{\sim}g(N) is used throughout the paper to denote asymptotic equivalence, i.e., f(N)/g(N)⟶N→∞1f(N)/g(N)\underset{N\rightarrow\infty}{\longrightarrow}1. We have added a definition in the updated version in Section 2.1.

Q2: We focused on Gaussian targets because they allow closed-form expressions and matching first-order asymptotics, which reveal the exact dependence of each sampler on the conditioning. Extending the analysis beyond Gaussians is a natural and important question, and we see two relevant directions.

The first one is multimodal distributions, with Gaussian mixtures. Multimodality is a known weakness of Langevin samplers, so we expect the advantage of diffusion to be even larger for mixtures of Gaussians. This extension raises technical challenges, because the score becomes nonlinear, and neither the laws of the Euler-Maruyama (EM) iterates nor the Wasserstein error has a closed form. To gain some insight into this question, we investigate the performance of diffusion compared to ULA on bimodal Gaussian mixtures for which the Wasserstein error can be computed semi-analytically, without stochasticity. To ensure a fair comparison, we perform a grid search over the step size for ULA, while keeping the diffusion hyperparameters as in the Gaussian case (from our Proposition 4). The results clearly show that ULA's performance deteriorates as the condition number increases, whereas diffusion is significantly more efficient and remains robust to changes in κ\kappa. Interestingly, in the latter case, the asymptotic rates are proportional to log⁡N/N\log N/N as for Gaussians. We also studied the effect of the potential barrier between the two modes. As expected, ULA is much more sensitive to this parameter than diffusion.

We added the figures and the details of the experiments to the revised version (Appendix F). Given their interest, we will also include a summary of these results in the main text of the final version.

The second extension is log-concave distributions, where the condition number is a natural quantity. There again, neither the laws of the EM iterates nor the Wasserstein error have a closed form and our analysis cannot carry over directly. We believe this constitutes a promising direction for future work and will mention it in the conclusion in the final version.

Thank you for your clarification. I will maintain my score.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear reviewers,

We warmly thank you for your time and thoughtful reviews. If accepted, we will take into account your suggestions, which help us improve our work. We answer the specifics of reviewer questions in individual responses.

Sincerely,

The authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.