- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a role-preserving multiscale evidence learning framework for compact medical image segmentation. The central idea is to maintain distinct functional responsibilities for object evidence, regional continuity, boundary detail, and class allocation, rather than prematurely merging multiscale representations into a single feature stream. The proposed architecture incorporates local proposal and regional verification at low resolution, compact KAN-based relation mapping, role-specific cross-scale reconstruction, and an image-conditioned foreground/background prototype readout. These components aim to reduce cross-scale interference while preserving a relatively small parameter footprint. Experiments are conducted on three public medical image segmentation benchmarks, BUSI, CVC-ClinicDB, and GlaS. The proposed model achieves a three-dataset average IoU of 80.60% with 5.79M parameters. The authors also provide component ablations, role-fusion comparisons, and computational complexity analysis.
Critical strengths
- A coherent architectural motivation for multiscale feature interaction.
The paper addresses a relevant challenge in medical image segmentation: combining semantic information, regional structure, and fine-grained boundary details without introducing misleading responses. The role-preserving perspective provides a coherent organizational principle for the architecture. In particular, maintaining separate feature carriers while allowing relation-conditioned interactions is a potentially useful design strategy for compact segmentation networks.
- Evaluation across multiple imaging modalities with controlled ablations.
The experimental evaluation covers ultrasound, endoscopy, and histopathology, which exhibit substantially different appearance characteristics. The authors follow a common three-seed evaluation protocol and provide several component-level comparisons. The ablations involving KAN relation mapping, template conditioning, prototype allocation, and alternative fusion strategies offer useful evidence about the behavior of the proposed architecture.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited performance improvements relative to the architectural complexity and computational overhead.
Although the proposed architecture achieves the highest average IoU among the evaluated methods, the improvements over competitive baselines are relatively modest.
On BUSI, the method improves IoU over U-KAN by 1.03 percentage points. On CVC-ClinicDB, the improvement over Attention U-Net is only 0.34 points. On GlaS, the proposed method underperforms Attention U-Net by 0.55 points in IoU. The three-dataset average improvement over U-KAN is 1.08 points.
These relatively small gains should be considered alongside the additional computational cost. Despite having fewer parameters than U-KAN (5.79M versus 6.35M), the proposed method requires 7.19G MACs compared with 1.75G for U-KAN under the reported profiling protocol. Therefore, the reduction in parameter count does not translate into computational efficiency.
Furthermore, the reported standard deviations indicate noticeable variation on BUSI and GlaS, and the paper does not provide paired statistical comparisons establishing the reliability of the relatively small improvements.
These issues weaken the practical significance of the proposed design, particularly given its emphasis on compact medical image segmentation.
- The methodological novelty and generality of the role-preserving principle require stronger validation.
The proposed framework combines several established architectural operations, including residual convolutions, depthwise convolution, nonlinear relation mapping, gated feature modulation, learned cross-scale transport, and prototype-based classification.
Although their combination is carefully motivated, it remains unclear which aspects constitute a fundamentally new learning mechanism beyond a sophisticated arrangement of existing components.
The ablation results also reveal substantial dataset dependence. For example, the single-prototype variant outperforms the full model on CVC, while the parallel proposal-verification variant performs better on both CVC and GlaS. This suggests that the preferred configurations are not consistently optimal across different imaging modalities.
While the paper includes early-fusion, late-fusion, and no-role controls, it is unclear whether these alternatives are sufficiently matched in parameter count and computational cost to isolate the proposed information-organization principle from differences in model capacity.
In addition, the main comparison is restricted to a small set of established segmentation architectures. More recent compact segmentation methods discussed in the related work are not included in the quantitative evaluation. This limits the evidence for the competitiveness of the proposed approach relative to current efficient segmentation designs.
Furthermore, the architecture figures appear to be programmatically generated SVG diagrams, with several mathematical symbols and expressions displayed as raw, unrendered text rather than properly typeset notation, which further undermines the presentation quality and professionalism of the manuscript.
Questions for authors
Q1. Computational efficiency and practical trade-offs.
The proposed model has fewer parameters than U-KAN but requires approximately four times as many MACs, while improving the three-dataset average IoU by only 1.08 points. Could the authors provide actual inference latency, peak GPU memory usage, and throughput comparisons under identical hardware conditions? These measurements would help clarify the practical value of the proposed architecture as a compact segmentation framework.
Q2. Isolating the contribution of role preservation.
Could the authors clarify whether the early-fusion, late-fusion, and no-role variants are matched to the full model in parameter count and computational complexity? If not, could they provide capacity-matched comparisons to establish that the improvements arise from the role-preserving information flow rather than additional feature-processing capacity?
Q3. Robustness and dataset-dependent component behavior.
The performance differences between the full model and several variants are relatively small, and some alternative configurations outperform the complete architecture on individual datasets. Could the authors provide paired statistical comparisons across seeds and further explain why the single-prototype and parallel proposal-verification variants outperform the full model on certain datasets? This would clarify the robustness and generality of the proposed design choices.
Q4. Evaluation protocol and baseline coverage.
Could the authors clarify whether the BUSI and CVC data partitions account for patient or acquisition-sequence grouping, where applicable? Additionally, could they explain why more recent compact segmentation methods, including representative architectures discussed in the related work, are not included in the quantitative comparisons? Stronger contemporary baselines would help establish the significance of the reported improvements.