- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents WaveJoint, a dual-task Transformer for joint retinal-vessel and FAZ segmentation in OCTA. The method combines fixed Haar wavelet analysis with WaveDown and wavelet-aware attention to preserve fine vascular structures during scale transitions, and evaluates performance using both conventional segmentation metrics and structure-sensitive measures such as capillary recall and fragmentation. Experiments on OCTA-500 3 mm/6 mm and FAROS report improvements over several published and retrained baselines, together with factorial ablations and cross-dataset evaluations intended to analyze the contribution of the proposed frequency-guided design.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a useful structural evaluation protocol for OCTA that captures fine-vessel quality beyond aggregate Dice.
Critical weaknesses
- The architectural contribution appears too incremental relative to LWTformer (CVPR 2026 Findings), with highly similar modules sharing the same names, functions, and architectural designs, to meet the level of methodological novelty expected for ICLR.
- The experimental evaluation lacks sufficient consistency and rigor. The factorial main-effect magnitude is reported using an unconventional scaling, the same metrics are reported using different aggregation schemes across tables and therefore cannot be directly compared, and methods within the same table are evaluated using different checkpoint-selection and seed protocols. These issues reduce confidence in the fairness and interpretability of the reported results.
Questions for authors
- Please explicitly clarify the methodological differences between WaveJoint and LWTformer, particularly for WaveDown, WACGA, and SEA. Which operations are inherited, which are modified, and what is the motivation for each modification? If the main difference is the replacement of learnable wavelet filters with fixed Haar filters, please explain why this constitutes a sufficiently substantive methodological contribution.
- In Tables 1 and 2, why is WaveJoint evaluated using the last checkpoint while the retrained baselines use their best validation checkpoints? Was this evaluation policy determined a priori, before inspecting the test-set results? Please clarify how this asymmetric checkpoint-selection strategy ensures a fair comparison.
- In Table 3, the 2×2 factorial ablation is conducted using learnable wavelet filters, whereas the final WaveJoint adopts fixed Haar filters. Why was the factorial ablation not performed under the final fixed-Haar configuration? Please clarify whether the conclusions regarding the contributions of WaveDown and WACGA remain valid under the actual model setting.
- The protocol-matched baselines are relatively dated and may not adequately reflect the current state of medical image segmentation. Why were stronger and more widely adopted frameworks, such as nnU-Net, as well as more recent segmentation methods, not included for comparison?