- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on the OCT-to-OCTA translation task and proposes a dual-prior coarse-to-fine flow-matching framework. The key lies in the fact that the CF-Flow path decomposes volumetric representations into low- and high-frequency components, modeling global structural transport with Coarse Flow and vascular-detail transport with Fine Flow. The results show the improvement of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
- The idea of Coarse Flow first modeling low-frequency structural transport, while Fine Flow uses the predicted coarse coefficients as context to recover high-frequency vascular detail, is reasonable.
- Comprehensive quantitative and qualitative comparisons with existing methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution of the proposed method over existing works is incremental, as flow matching and wavelet transformation are existing works. Coarse and fine flow matching also appear in existing work. Also, only a vessel head connects the proposed method to the OCT domain. This work seems to be a lot of a combination of existing works.
-
The improvement over FlowOCT is not significant. The need for coarse and fine branches remains questionable.
-
The reliance on a pre-trained vessel labeler limits its generalizability to new domains.
Questions for authors
-
The contribution of the proposed method over existing work is incremental, as flow matching and wavelet transformation are existing methods. Coarse and fine flow matching also appear in existing work. Also, only a vessel head connects the proposed method to the OCT domain.
-
The improvement over FlowOCT is not significant. The need for coarse and fine branches remains questionable.
-
The reliance on a pre-trained vessel labeler limits its generalizability to new domains.
Response to Reviewer 3
Q1: The method appears to combine existing techniques, including flow matching, wavelet transformation, and coarse-to-fine flow matching. The OCT-specific contribution also appears limited to a vessel head.
R1: We clarify that our contribution is not the general invention of flow matching, wavelet transforms, or coarse-to-fine modeling. It is their task-specific design for paired 3D OCT-to-OCTA translation. CF-Flow assigns distinct roles to low-frequency structural transport and high-frequency vascular-detail refinement, with the predicted coarse representation conditioning Fine Flow. In addition, the method incorporates two OCTA-oriented priors: MSZ Prior derives global-depth, local-depth, and depth-gradient cues from the source OCT to guide structural emphasis, while VesselAux supervises the high-frequency branch using 3D vessel targets. Thus, the OCT-specific guidance is provided by both the source-conditioned MSZ Prior and the vessel-level auxiliary supervision, rather than by the Vessel Head alone.
Q2: The improvement over FlowOCT is not significant, and the need for coarse and fine branches remains questionable.
R2: We agree that the results should not be interpreted as showing that the dual-path design is universally necessary or statistically superior. In Table 5, the full DuoPrior-CFFlow configuration improves over the Single-Path Flow (FlowOCT) result from 1.22 to 1.13 in MAE, from 28.80 to 29.38 dB in PSNR, from 86.82 to 87.65 in SSIM, from 5.36 to 5.12 in LPIPS, and from 18.76 to 17.48 in FID. The ablation also compares Coarse Flow with CF-Flow to examine the effect of adding Fine Flow. These results support the selected design under our evaluation protocol, but we do not claim statistical significance or that every branch is necessary in all settings.
Q3: Reliance on a pretrained vessel labeler may limit generalizability to new domains.
R3: We clarify that SAM-OCTA is used to construct vessel supervision and to compute the reported segmentation-derived vessel metrics; it is not required by the generator at inference. Therefore, generation does not require running the pretrained labeler on a new-domain input. However, VesselAux training and the reported vessel evaluations do depend on suitable vessel masks, and we have not evaluated cross-domain transfer. We therefore do not claim that the current vessel-supervision protocol establishes generalizability to new domains.