- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ALM, a lightweight adaptation framework for joint weather-power forecasting. The method integrates pretrained weather and power models through three components: prefusion alignment, latent memory interaction, and postfusion modulation. It enables bidirectional information exchange while keeping most backbone parameters frozen. Experiments on a constructed CONUS weather-power dataset demonstrate improvements in forecasting accuracy and parameter efficiency, with additional evaluations on downstream power forecasting tasks.
Critical strengths
- The paper explores bidirectional information exchange between weather and power forecasting, moving beyond conventional approaches that primarily treat weather as an exogenous input. This is a practically relevant research direction with potential applications in renewable energy forecasting.
- The paper compares ALM against a broad range of parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods, including recent approaches such as WeatherPEFT. It also provides component ablations, computational efficiency analysis, downstream applications, and cross-backbone experiments, demonstrating considerable experimental effort.
Critical weaknesses
- A central concern is that the current experiments do not sufficiently distinguish whether the improvements arise from incorporating additional power information or from the proposed ALM interaction mechanism itself. Although Table 4 provides component ablations and a power-to-weather injection experiment, these comparisons do not fully isolate the two effects. More controlled comparisons under matched conditions, such as using the same weather-power inputs with simpler fusion mechanisms, would help clarify the independent contribution of ALM.
- As described in Appendix A.4, the gridded wind and solar capacity factors are largely constructed using meteorological information and physical conversion models. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the improvements in weather forecasting originate from genuinely complementary power information or from transformed representations of existing weather variables. Further clarification or controlled experiments would strengthen the evidence supporting the claimed bidirectional information exchange.
- Although the paper includes extensive comparisons, downstream applications, and cross-backbone experiments, the evaluations primarily rely on the same author-constructed CONUS weather-power dataset. The cross-backbone experiments also use this underlying data source. Additional validation on an independent dataset or a different geographic region would provide stronger evidence of the framework's generalizability.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors further clarify how much of the forecasting improvement comes from introducing additional power information versus the ALM interaction mechanism itself? Would comparisons with simpler fusion strategies under matched input conditions help isolate these contributions?
- Given that the gridded wind and solar variables are largely derived from meteorological information, how can the authors distinguish genuinely complementary power information from transformed weather representations?
- Could the authors further discuss the generalizability of ALM beyond the constructed CONUS benchmark, particularly to independently collected datasets or different geographic regions?
3 comments
Thank you for the response. The additional experiments address my main concerns, so I am raising my score from 2 to 3.
Responses to Reviewer J5Bq
We thank the reviewer for the careful reassessment and constructive feedback. We are glad that the additional experiments have addressed your main concerns, and we appreciate how your suggestions helped us improve the paper.
Responses to Reviewer J5Bq
We thank the reviewer for recognizing that bidirectional exchange moves beyond treating weather as an exogenous input and for noting the breadth of our experiments.
C1. Separating the contribution of power information from the ALM interaction mechanism.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful question. Table 4 already separates the two: closing the power$\to$weather path (η=0) worsens all 9 weather variables, an information effect, and removing any ALM component worsens all 12 variables, a mechanism effect. The PEFT comparison is confounded, however, because ALM adds a frozen PowerSwin pretrained on the training split. We therefore compared simpler fusion with the same BitFit Aurora and frozen PowerSwin, inputs, 6→24→72 h schedule, and trainable parameters within ±5% of ALM. The last two fusion rows apply the E1 DoRA or AdaptFormer setup to Aurora and attach PowerSwin through concatenation + MLP (72-h RMSE):
We added these baselines to a new subsection of App. D.3.
C2. Complementary power information versus transformed weather representations.
We appreciate this question. Beyond ERA5, the simulated fields encode power-system information (turbine curves, EIA-860 plant data, inverter limits), and load uses no ERA5, so they carry complementary power information (see bpXH-C1). Their ERA5 inputs still include variables outside the nine weather inputs (u100, v100, d2m, sp, ssrd, fdir). To remove this route, we built observation-constrained wind and PV fields from power-system records only. Each balancing authority’s (BA) hourly EIA-930 generation is split among its plants (EIA-860M) by capacity and the same-month EIA-923 utilization of the preceding year, and the plant outputs in each 0.25∘ cell are divided by the cell’s capacity, with zero where no plant exists. Load stays OEDI. The fields cover 2020–2023, so all four models (and PowerSwin) are retrained on 2020–2021, validated on 2022, and tested on 2023, with wind and solar scored against these fields and missing BA-hours excluded (72-h RMSE):
We added this experiment as a new App. D.5.
C3. Generalizability beyond the constructed CONUS benchmark.
Forecasts are already scored against EIA-923 plant and OEDI county data (Table 3), and hourly EIA-930 (bpXH-C2). We added a held-out year (train 2016–2020, validate 2021, test 2022) and metropolitan France (train 2020–2021, validate 2022, test 2023). In France, each method is retrained with ERA5 weather and RTE regional load allocated to 0.25∘ cells by population. Given time limits, all methods use the single-step budget of Table 4 (72-h RMSE):
ALM ranks first on four of five variables in the held-out year and on three of four in France, and lowers the average weather RMSE of A-WFT by 29% and 26%. Its advantage is therefore not tied to the 2023 test year or to CONUS. We added both settings as a new App. D.6.
Related Revisions